Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Fair competition???


firstdayfan

Recommended Posts

I know we don't need another armanti Edwards thread but does anybody else get the feeling that this isn't a fair competition for punt returner? In the first game Edwards took all the punts and the KO returns and no one else got a shot. Last week we saw munnerlyn, Moore, and Witherspoon but only after Edwards' muffed punt.

I feel like some of these guys could be better options but haven't got a fair look...especially Witherspoon. It's like the FO wants Edwards to win it so they can at least have a reason to make him active on gameday. It's obvious that he is a year or two away and I cant imagine why they wouldn't wan the best guy to be back there...which by the way seems to be munnerlyn. I really hope guy gets a chance to return a few this week.

Kinda makes you wonder how many other position "battles" are really an open competition or if it's just whomever the coaching staff wants.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i thought about this just the other day.

it's very rare that carolina has a true competition for any position.

they might say there is, but roles are usually handed to someone by default.

It's not just Carolina.

Another thing is the perception of the fans. Most fans view productivity based on individual plays. They may see an audible to a pass on 3rd and 4 that nets a first down as 100% positive, while the plan may have been to not pass from that formation unless/until late in the 4th if needed. We don't see that, we see the success of the first down without thinking that, had we stuck with the original play, we may have still gained the 1st and left the pass from that formation available as a surprise so to speak if needed later. We'll praise teh QB while the coaches are less than happy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not just Carolina.

Another thing is the perception of the fans. Most fans view productivity based on individual plays. They may see an audible to a pass on 3rd and 4 that nets a first down as 100% positive, while the plan may have been to not pass from that formation unless/until late in the 4th if needed. We don't see that, we see the success of the first down without thinking that, had we stuck with the original play, we may have still gained the 1st and left the pass from that formation available as a surprise so to speak if needed later. We'll praise teh QB while the coaches are less than happy.

You have a problem with white people ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Edwards is getting all the returns because he needs as much in-game experience as possible. He's the best fit for the position athletically so it makes sense that the coaching staff are pushing for him to return kicks, and he did show flashes at times. Obviously if he hasn't fully grasped it by the start of the season Munny will be the guy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you had a guy who you thought had the ability to become a game changer, but he's green and needs experience what do you do? You get him as many reps as you can to get him as much experience as possible. It doesn't hurt the team for him to make mistakes now. If he's going to become the player they hoped he would be on draft day, this is valuable experience for him. He won't get any better sitting on the bench.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • You may be interested to know that the average depth of separation is dependent upon the type of route run. Though go-routes are the most type of route run, they also produce the least amount of separation (and, of course, completions).   "The average pass catcher runs a go route on nearly a quarter of all routes (22.3%), the highest percentage of any route type in our data. However, those routes are targeted roughly 1 out of 10 times (10.8 percent), the lowest target rate of any route. The WR screen is the least-run route (3.4%), and it's the only route where the average target is behind the line of scrimmage. But it's also targeted at the highest rate (40.7%) and early in the play (1.6 seconds average time to throw). The most targeted routes outside of the WR Screen? The out (27.8%) and slant (25.2%) routes are the next most popular across the league."     "The most valuable routes by expected points added per target were the post (+0.48) and corner (+0.43) routes. The go route (+0.19) ranked seventh on the list of 10 route types. The go route (+0.19) ranked seventh on the list of 10 route types. One possible reason for this: It's harder to separate on go routes, which put the player on a straight path, than on posts or corners, which ask the player to make a cut. Targeted pass catchers on posts and corners average 2.4 yards and 2.3 yards of separation from the nearest defender, respectively, while pass catchers targeted on go routes average just 1.8 yards of separation."   https://www.nfl.com/news/next-gen-stats-intro-to-new-route-recognition-model#:~:text=Targeted pass catchers on posts,) and slant (+0.26).   I would expect that Thielen would have an easier time catching the ball based that he runs the routes where it's easier to get open. Tet? Yet to be seen, but we may be better served getting him on some slants and crossers also.  In general, receivers are going to average a lower completion percentage and yards of separation on certain types of routes than others, that's why we shouldn't necessarily be taking stats, even advanced ones, at face value, as there are dynamics that most aren't even thinking about.  In terms of Tet, he's bigger and somewhat slower than a smaller dude, so you'd expect him not to have as much separation on go-routes, but his catch radius is massive and his hands are awesome. Hitting him in stride will probably be killer, but of course QBs are less accurate on go-routes according to the stats. Depending upon Tet's route versatility and how he is used, we could have a unicorn though. He's relatively fast, has great hands and gets YAC (and on an off note, if X can hold on to the ball, he's dangerous as well because he already has shown some separation ability).    
×
×
  • Create New...