Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

nba all star vs pro bowl


dpanthersman

Recommended Posts

You simply can't have an NFL "All Star" game mid season. Too much injury risk.

However, sans a College BCS Championship game the week between the Championship games and the Super Bowl a Pro Bowl game, minus the SB participants with all the fluff would be great.

i don't think he's refering to the timing of the pro bowl. i think he's talking about the event as a whole.

if i'm not mistaken, there are other events that surround the pro bowl. they just aren't aired on television.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maybe they could have an all-star silly football game

any one that did not make the pro bowl would be eligible

A DL and OL game

players have to weigh 250 and above to play

Use a 50 yd field

Just for fun

Those big lineman would like to touch the ball L O L

Link to comment
Share on other sites

itd be cool if everybody had their bye week at the same time.. that ensures that everyone goes to the pro-bowl, as opposed to leaving Superbowl squads out of the game.. it also puts everyone at a fair advantage, have the bye all at the same time, unlike the way Baltimore had to play like 16 straight games.. have it after the first 8 games, play the game, then everyone gets a week off, and the season resumes after that week..

players play at own risk.. i cant really remember the last time someone got injurd at the Probowl, besides that punter than got his ass nailed by Sean Taylor..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i don't think he's refering to the timing of the pro bowl. i think he's talking about the event as a whole.

if i'm not mistaken, there are other events that surround the pro bowl. they just aren't aired on television.

yea i totally agree that it shouldnt be in the middle of the season. but the event as a whole could be alot better. if they brought back the skills competion and maybe did a legend/celebrity game (which i thnk they used to do) and they aired all of this it would be alot more entertaining

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The NFL actually used to have special events around Pro Bowl week (Fastest Man, QB Challenge, Lineman Challenge, Rookie Skills Challenge, etc) that were broadcast mostly on NFL Network. Fans love that kind of thing, but sadly the league has done away with them.

I do think moving it to the week prior to the Super Bowl rather than the week after was a good idea. Maybe sometime they'll bring the other events back.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think one thing that really helps the NBA is the fact that the game is in the middle of the season, so fans of almost every team are still into basketball. If they played it after the season I do not think it would do as well. Plus, like someone else said the dynamics are just totally different...2 different animals.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • His footwork has been discussed at length, just like Cam's was--no argument from me there. What I'm asking for is a statistical indicator that supports the idea that Bryce's footwork is creating meaningful issues. With Cam, we could clearly correlate occasional high passes to footwork problems. With Bryce, there are occasional misfires as well, but we aren't seeing it surface with the frequency of severity you'd expect if it were such a persistent issue. That's why when concerns about his footwork and height are paired together, there should be some measurable statistical impact. That's what I keep coming back to. That same inconsistency shows up in the deep ball critique. Saying "he misses guys outright" suggests he either isn't seeing them or can't hit them downfield... yet, as we've already seen, he was top-10 in catchable passes over 20+ yards. If accuracy were truly the issue, it should reflect in the data. It's also worth pointing out that deep-ball concerns largely became the next talking point after he made it through the season without the durability disaster some were predicting (despite being sacked for what was then the second-most times ever for a rookie QB). As for those sideline throws you mentioned: what specific throws are you referring to? If you can identify them, I'd be happy to pull up the PFF premium grades or grab All-22 clips from NFL Pro to look at those sequences and assess how real that concern is. For my part, I'd actually like to see improvement in the intermediate game. That was a strength his rookie year, but he seemed to trade it for a stronger deep game this past season. Could that shift relate to height and footwork? Maybe! But again... we'd need data or film trends to verify that rather than assume it. On the "top-10" classification front: I know that it's a moving target for most people. That's why I've been asking for specifics. Without a shared definition, it's hard to engage meaningfully. So with you moving away from raw yardage, does that mean your preferred KPIs are now height, weight, red zone efficiency, and point differential? If so, that's totally fine (just being clear about it helps). That said... red zone success and point differential depend heavily on OL play, WR execution, coaching decisions, defense (for point differential), etc. They're influenced by the QB but not exclusively determined by him... which, like passing yards, makes them more difficult to isolate for analysis of Bryce's performance.
    • I think "amazing" is basically relating to his prior performances, which is a very low bar. Even at his peak(so far), he hasn't consistently been an elite performer either by the simple eye test nor statistically. Regardless, we have seen the flashes of WHY we drafted him #1 overall and he is visibility significantly more confident. Hopefully he has spent an inordinate amount of time this offseason getting that footwork better and more consistent. That's going to be a massive factor in his continuing improvement.
×
×
  • Create New...