Trade Proposition With The Browns

[XClown1986]

I think the Panthers want to move up badly. I think they want Claiborne, Blackmon, or maybe Kalil.

With all of the ideas of splitting up Double Trouble surfacing lately, what if we offered the Browns this:

Jonathan Stewart

for

a swap of their #4 and our #9

and their 3rd round pick

I personally don't want Stewart gone at all, and the likelihood of us getting a 1st for him from another team is slim and none. So instead we get to move up 5 spots and pick the guy we really want, gain a 3rd round pick back, and don't trade any future picks.

The Browns would still have 2 1sts and a 2nd, plus their runningback of the now and future.

Would you do this?

[Darth Biscuit]

No, I'm not a fan of trading up. I don't see any of those guys you mentioned being worth JStew AND whoever we picked at #9...

[Panthro]

I'd do it only because the asking price for jStew is a 2nd rounder.

So we move up with a 1st and 2nd (jstew's value) and also get a 3rd in return.....yes

[Lout]

Jstew is worth a 2-3rd round pick by himself.. we can't move up AND get a 3rd round pick. Realistically our #9 and JStew for their #4, straight up could happen.

[carolina-chuck]

Probably no.

I think I would rather get a 2nd for stew than moving up and getting a third.

I think we could get three good players in the first two rounds if we traded stew for a 2nd this yr rather than getting three players in the first three rds.

Jst my opinion.

[Lout]

There will be a couple teams offering multiple 1st round picks for the #4 overall (if they want Tannehill).. we would be ripping the Browns off with the trade proposed in the OP.

Miami is going to offer the #8(swap) and next years 1st for Tannehill, I bet. We would be stupid NOT to make that trade. I'd go get Claiborne in a heartbeat.

[Ivan The Awesome]

Browns want to trade out of that spot. Would the Jags or Phins do it for Tannenhill?

[GotSwag?]

I'd do it. Im one of Stewarts biggest fans, but it would allow us to know we will draft one of Claibourne or Kalil..and we pick up another 3rd rounder as well.

[Ken]

If all we're giving up is Stewart, I'd strongly consider it for Claiborne, not so much forward Kallil but no in regards to Blackmon.

[jramsey4]

Sorry but I'd throw things if this happened and Im one of the biggest proponents of trading Stewart. Hurney has an awful track record of trading up and we have mulitple needs. If you can't get a 2nd for him in this draft just wait and we will proabably get a 3rd round comp pick when he walks. Don't be trading a stud just for the sake of trading him.

[Ivan The Awesome]

Sorry but I'd throw things if this happened and Im one of the biggest proponents of trading Stewart. Hurney has an awful track record of trading up and we have mulitple needs. If you can't get a 2nd for him in this draft just wait and we will proabably get a 3rd round comp pick when he walks. Don't be trading a stud just for the sake of trading him.

Wait for a 3rd that might not be there? I don't know about that. I agree about trading him. I don't want that either, but if we can get something out of him instead of being a peppers situation again, I'm all for it. The only players we should be trading up for anyway are Claiborne and Blackmon. More for Claiborne than Blackmon though.

[stirs]

Just moving from 9 to 4 would take more from the Panthers that Stewart.

Browns also don't want to drop as far as 9. 6-7 is as far down as they will go.

I can see them picking Blackmon, then if the Bucs take Richardson, trading with the Rams at that point. Browns pick up even more picks and get Coples or Claiborne.

[CarolinaNCSU]

Not seeing how the Browns would ever do that. It would take the swap of 1st picks and probably our 2nd to maybe do that. They can just take Richardson for less money than Stewart will probably want, and them giving up a 3rd makes no sense.

They would basically be swapping the 4th pick for the 9th in the scheme of things.

[KendrickPanther]

Stewart doesn't have any trade value to the Browns. He would never resign there....no one is giving up a high pick for 1 season of Johnathan Stewart.