My Armanti thread.

[Mage]

How is Armanti Edwards "freakishly athletic"?

[CRA]

Do you believe Marty makes mistakes?

Of course, who doesn't?

[koolkatluke]

Of course, who doesn't?

So people can question his logic. I can see taking this "don't question the FO" route if he never made a mistake. But since he has made mistakes his moves are free game to be questioned sometimes.

[stirs]

We collects Edwards', not discard them

[Kurb]

How is Armanti Edwards "freakishly athletic"?

Uhh he beat Michigan...Durrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

[koolkatluke]

We collects Edwards', not discard them

I wish we can Collect Revies'.

[CRA]

So people can question his logic. I can see taking this "don't question the FO" route if he never made a mistake. But since he has made mistakes his moves are free game to be questioned sometimes.

I agree 100%.

[FirstRoundPick]

Oh noes! This guy hates his life. What a loser. He also has never been a NFL GM so his opinion on anything means about as much as my fart.

....am I doing it right?

You forgot to post your opinion a few posts later, even though you aren't a GM either. That is how the cool kids do it.

[Jackofalltrades]

Another Armanti thread. Great. You make a pretty good argument but calling Appalachian State a glorified high school makes you look like an idiot.

Lol, ok. Had he come from the SEC or other legit school the transition may have been easier, but ASU football is minor leagues, at best.

[SCP]

Do you believe Marty makes mistakes?

2009 and 2010 drafts come to mind.

[GSO_Pantherz]

Oh noes! This guy hates his life. What a loser. He also has never been a NFL GM so his opinion on anything means about as much as my fart.

....am I doing it right?

Was I calling you out? Some people take it too far, and yes, I believe that it reflects on something greather than just football. Take it easy.

[Ivan The Awesome]

I love how people try to spin pointing out the Amanti project has been a complete bust based on other QB conversions......somehow means people are miserable and hate their lives.

Talk about a desperate reach.

Fans critique their team. Simple and plain.

I concur. There's a difference between critiquing and nit picking.

[ElkinPanthersFan]

Clemson wanted him to play DB

[MuchAdoAboutNewton]

Lol, ok. Had he come from the SEC or other legit school the transition may have been easier, but ASU football is minor leagues, at best.

Like Dwayne Jarrett? I don't care where a guy went to school so long as he can play. There are guys that can make the transition from a small school to the NFL and some that come from BCS schools that can't. Each player has to be judged on what they can do. Will AE ever complete the transition? I doubt it. But, the coaches and FO apparently feel he is one of the 53 best in the Panthers organization at this point. I think belittling ASU's FCS level is a waste of time.