Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Pat's Dline Rankings.

koolkatluke

By koolkatluke,
in Carolina Panthers

Recommended Posts

koolkatluke Newbie

koolkatluke

Posted
Posted

Ranking the NFC South defensive linemen

June 8, 2009 10:59 AM

Posted by ESPN.com's Pat Yasinskas

We're resuming our NFC South position rankings with defensive linemen.

I'm combining defensive ends and tackles into one big group and, as I'm looking at the rosters, I'm mildly surprised that this group isn't stronger. That's especially true at defensive tackle, but there's hope here because I think young players like Atlanta's Peria Jerry and New Orleans' Sedrick Ellis can be very good, very soon.

The overall quality of defensive linemen in the division is a little down right now because Carolina and Tampa Bay don't have the outstanding lines they once did. The ends are a little stronger than the tackles and can become even more so if some young players like Atlanta's Jamaal Anderson, Carolina's Everette Brown and Tampa Bay's Gaines Adams emerge this year.

Anyway, here's the list:

John Abraham, DE, Atlanta. Sure, go ahead and call him one dimensional. But aren't dominant pass-rush skills the dimension you want most from a defensive end?

Julius Peppers, DE, Carolina. Easily the division's most talented defensive lineman. But there are questions about his motivation and intensity with Peppers wanting out of Carolina. Those questions aren't really new.

Jonathan Babineaux, DT, Atlanta. Very quietly, he's become the most solid interior lineman in the division.

Will Smith, DE, New Orleans. No, he didn't play to his potential last year and he's facing a four-game suspension at the start of this season. But this guy plays the run well and has shown pass-rush skills in the past.

Sedrick Ellis, DT, New Orleans. Has the ability to unseat Babineaux as division's top tackle and could do that very soon.

Gaines Adams, DE, Tampa Bay. You can argue that this ranking is way too high. But look at the rest of the division. Adams had 6.5 sacks last season. If he adds a couple of moves, he easily can reach double-digit sacks.

Peria Jerry, DT, Atlanta. He's only a rookie, but there's little bust factor with this guy. He should be a factor right away.

Charles Johnson, DE, Carolina. We're going to rank him ahead of the rookie Brown based on the promise Johnson showed last year. He had six sacks in a part-time role and has the potential to do big things.

Ma'ake Kemoeatu, DT, Carolina. He doesn't do anything except take up space. But that's his job.

Charles Grant, DE, New Orleans. Exact same story as his teammate Smith. But the guy does have a couple of double-digit sack years in his background and you never know what new coordinator Gregg Williams might be able to pull out of him.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Atlanta Falcons, Carolina Panthers, New Orleans Saints, Position rankings, defensive linemen, Peria Jerry, Sedrick Ellis, Jamaal Anderson, Everette Brown, Gaines Adams, John Abraham, Julius Peppers, Jonathan Babineaux, Will Smith, Charles Johnson, Ma'ake Kemoeatu, Charles Grant, Gregg Williams

I don't see how a Part time player gets more prop then a full time player.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
koolkatluke Newbie

koolkatluke

Posted
  • Author
Posted

because that part time player still got 16.5 sacks

Full Time player got 14.5 and didn't get too rest while the other team was running the ball.

Abe is one dimensional and we all know the reason why he's a part time player. If he played the full game he will get hurt. That has too factor in some where.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
scpanther22 Mentor

scpanther22

Posted
Posted

Full Time player got 14.5 and didn't get too rest while the other team was running the ball.

Abe is one dimensional and we all know the reason why he's a part time player. If he played the full game he will get hurt. That has too factor in some where.

this is true but like pat said

Sure, go ahead and call him one-dimensional. But aren't dominant pass-rush skills the dimension you want most from a defensive end?
Link to comment
Share on other sites
carolinarolls Newbie

carolinarolls

Posted
Posted

the "full time player" on the defensive line will be a thing of the past very soon and already is in some circles. I even foresee an expansion in the roster limitations coming during the next CBA discussions so that players can become more specialized and as a result play longer careers. Probably a long shot but I think it could happen. Expand the roster size and institute a rookie cap and you may have just found the compromise we need to be able to value a top 5 draft pick in the future.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
rayzor Grand Master

rayzor

Posted
Posted

the "full time player" on the defensive line will be a thing of the past very soon and already is in some circles. I even foresee an expansion in the roster limitations coming during the next CBA discussions so that players can become more specialized and as a result play longer careers. Probably a long shot but I think it could happen. Expand the roster size and institute a rookie cap and you may have just found the compromise we need to be able to value a top 5 draft pick in the future.
i think you're right here. adding a game or two is most likely going to result in adding roster spots and salary cap. imo, most of that extra space generated on the roster will go towards the line on both sides. rotation is going to be pretty essential and will end up being a lot more specialized because of it. we won't and really shouldn't have every down DLinemen.

one of the reasons i think we will be going with 9-10 DL this year is not just for injuries sake, but we really need to be rotating those guys in a whole lot to keep them fresh against these big offenses we have on the schedule. i wouldn't be surprised to see peppers limited to just 2 downs a series, even with that salary cap #.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
koolkatluke Newbie

koolkatluke

Posted
  • Author
Posted

like him or not, john abraham is the most feared defensive lineman in the nfcs.

period.

for pure pash rushing capabilities, i'd take a part time abraham over a full time peppers without hesitation.

You can't depend on him because he is injury prone.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • SmokinwithWilly
      Which Round Will Carolina Draft Sawyer Robertson?

      By SmokinwithWilly · Posted

      No matter what we still need a QB2 with potential to be a QB1. Keep throwing QBs at the wall until we find someone who sticks.
    • strato
      Panthers bring back TE Feleipe Franks

      By strato · Posted

      Lot of different agendas dictating opinions.  I don’t think it was the best use of money with Hunt, specifically, but the concept of OL, I am a fan. I didn’t complain a ton because I am a believer in winning up front, on both sides of the ball. I’d rather have stout fronts than fancy WRs. I have complained some about Hunt not being worth his deal, after seeing him get pushed around in a game or two. It’s no crusade. And have complained in the context of shorting the defense.   They have leveled out the FA imbalance with the dual big signings this offseason, and it has always been the draft picks I am most protective of. Anyway The picks are the real imbalance. If you did a trade chart value of the picks we directly gave up for Bryce, and added the support picks invested for skill players, and put that on one side… then put the little 3 3rd rounders and a 2nd that the defense got over three years on the other it would be hugely out of balance. I just want the balance restored. Defense is still owed.    
    • SmokinwithWilly
      Panthers bring back TE Feleipe Franks

      By SmokinwithWilly · Posted

      I'm one of the ones that won't let it go because it didn't solve the problem. We didn't address the center position which was a huge mistake. We were in position to easily take 2 or the top IOL. Instead of drafting JPJ over XL or Frazier over Brooks, we relied on an oft injured guard to center conversion and lo and behold, it failed as predicted. XL looks like a 1 year college wonder and an injured Brooks hasn't even surpassed Eric Shelton.  Bryce was also benched for poor performance, so the issue that many claimed was solely bad oline play wasn't. It didn't fix him bailing out of tight pockets because of being unable to see the field or him refusing to work on his atrocious footwork. Then there's the $$$. Lewis got a good guard payday. Hunt got a tackle payday. Pay tackles, draft guards, if you can.  I have no issues addressing problems through FA. It was not addressing C at all that's been the issue and still has been. Ryan Kalil was the anchor of our offensive line. We had years of solid center play and it showed. Now we're still piecemealing the center position with an expensive oline and it's still a shitshow. Why? Because the player responsible for what happens on the line presnap has little to no experience doing it. We did acquire a FA center this year finally. We'll see how much that impacts the line.  Spending on a center, whether it be through draft or FA is not bad. It's not a position that can have anyone just thrown in with no drop off in performance. A great center lifts the play of the guards on each side.  I don't like how we've built the line because we've ignored the hinge pin that everyone counts on every play. And the reality of the situation is, it didn't solve the actual problems with Bryce because those have nothing to do with the oline. 
×
×
  • Create New...