If you were starting a defense or offense with one player from each side past or present Panthers players. Who would you pick?

[SZ James (banned)]

SS & Mills

[CRA]

You guys are forgetting the minister of defense. While we didn't get him n his prime this wish list would make it that way.

Offense

Cam Newton , Steven Davis, Steve Smith

Defenses

Reggie White ( 28 years young), Julius Peppers, Luke Kueckly

This, except I would take the 2008 Williams over Davis

[Guest Tom Cat]

both guys in their prime -

Stephen Davis and Sam Mills

[nickzz]

cam (you don't build an offense around anything but a qb)

peppers

[nosuchthingasapanther]

jake delhomme

kris jenkins

[Herbert The Love Bug]

Impossible for be to decides who is best all time from both sides of the ball

Offense

Cam

Steve Smith

Defense

Sam Mills

Julius Peppers

Kris Jenkins

Kevin Greene

Mike Minter

Kuechly

Dan Morgan before his injuries

Special Teams

John Kasay

Todd Sauerbrun

Michael Bates

Rocket Ismail

Jarrod Cooper

He Hate Me

[Brokenbad]

Jimmy Clausen and Sean Gilbert

[SOJA]

its tough to pick against Steve Smith, but Cam has the potential to turn its into a perennial contender

[Lumps]

smitty

mills...TDavis being close

[Goondal]

I think people are forgetting Reggie White wore a Panther uniform. He has to be the defensive answer doesn't he?

That seems like cheating. It would be like putting Karl Malone on an All-Lakers team.

[CRA]

That seems like cheating. It would be like putting Karl Malone on an All-Lakers team.

Seems fair if Greene and Mills are in play. Both really built there reputation as players elsewhere

[Lumps]

mills did build rep elsewhere but to me we are chooseing people to 'represent' the panthers, not represent the successes of the panthers.

so preformance come second to heart/character. Smitty is a pretty easy pick, mills and davis to me had more heart that Greene or Reggie...Delhomme would be good too..

all matter of opinion but thats what I got from 'represent' the panthers. I picked smitty and davis because I believe the best heart comes from players who are challenged (belived to be too small a la smitty/mills, or not being able to come back like TDavis did which astounds me to this day and is why I choose him.

[nctarheel0619]

Greene had 3 years here.

[Doyle]

I think some of you just ignored the 1 player from each side part.