Is it safe to say?

[Ja Rhule]

Smitty hit the wall? He is still a good route runner but he lost few steps and is having a horrible time separating from his coverage... Also drops almost as much as he catches.

[Vampire the buffet slayer]

He had a bad game.

He is still the best wr we have

[The Huddler]

First round WR folks. Add a first round DB when we trade hardy

[KJ89]

This isn't news. He's been saying for years he wants to have a #1 brought in and be moved to the slot himself.

He's lost a step (he's thirty fuging four) but he's still Steve Smith. The dropped passes won't continue. He'll blow poo up next week and shut all of you up.

[Mother Grabber]

nice ambiguous thread title.

[rayzor]

He had a bad game.

He is still the best wr we have

 

and he had a very good corner covering him that has done very well this year.

 

 

[Ja Rhule]

He had a bad game.

He is still the best wr we have

Thru 4 games he has 18 reception for 203 yards. He has almost no yard after the catch... Proves he lost a step. He had similar stats when Chris Weinke started in 2007 and Jimmy Clausen in 2010.

[g5jamz]

Should've traded him 2 years ago, but we, as fans, get too caught up in the fanfare of the individual sometimes over the health of the team. 

 

Byproduct of Hurney/JR's philosophy that I hope Gettleman changes. 

[Ja Rhule]

nice ambiguous thread title.

Thanks. It's like opening Christmas present, not sure what to expect.

[TheRed]

He's 34 years old. Do people really expect him to still be taking over games at this stage in his career?

[CharlottePanther]

I would trade him. No this isnt hot headed, knee jerk talk. He needs to get Beasoned. Trade him to a contending team that gives him a chance at a ring, we atleast get a draft pick for him before he decides to retire next year anyway to avoid another rebuild.

[Vampire the buffet slayer]

Thru 4 games he has 18 reception for 203 yards. He has almost no yard after the catch... Proves he lost a step. He had similar stats when Chris Weinke started in 2007 and Jimmy Clausen in 2010.

Take away the Arizona game and his stats don't look that bad.

And as for the Zona game.

2005 week 4 GB 2 rec for 16 yds.

That was in the middle of his triple crown.

Bad day.

[Mother Grabber]

maybe we can trade him to the 49ers for Jim Harbaugh

[HPPantherzfan]

The guy has lost a step or two but he still has a huge heart and a desire to win!