Carolina Panthers Day 1 Draft Grade

[Byrdman4real]

1 minute ago, Thanatos said:

If Guice falls to us in round 2...

I'd love Josh Adams, but I can't see taking him until round 5.

That would be bananas 

[John_Sutter]

B

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

a D, same grade I gave KB 4 years ago. Not as bad as the CMC pick (which was a F and is gonna be our worst 1st rounder ever) but this is still bad

[iamhubby1]

17 minutes ago, Sean Payton's Vicodin said:

a D, same grade I gave KB 4 years ago. Not as bad as the CMC pick (which was a F and is gonna be our worst 1st rounder ever) but this is still bad

 

    "You were serious about that?" 

[Shocker]

Its an A no doubt.  Moore was the best overall WR in the draft.  Great pick.

[Toker Smurf]

I said 'B' only because I think DB was a bigger need but I'm very happy with the pick.

[Jangler]

a WR? I've seen this already.

[Cyberjag]

I like Ridley better than Moore, and think we should have gone for a CB instead.  So I gave it a B.  

[rayzor]

biggest thing for me was this being a norv pick. says a lot about the control he's going to have over that offense. we got the guy he was most excited about.