Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Bill Barnwell speculation: Panthers trade up with Jaguars


TheSpecialJuan

Recommended Posts

3 minutes ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

There’s no mf reason to trade up while giving up a ransom, neither offense nor defense is “one” playmaker away from being elite. I will personally march down to Charlotte Sherman style and boot hurney out 

I honestly don't think we are exceptionally far away from being an elite offense. But I also don't think there are any players we could even trade up for to make that happen(Elite LT, for instance). Defensively, almost certainly not. I don't think we are as bad defensively as we looked last year but with a scheme shift, you wonder if we have the personnel in place to be an elite defense. Not to mention our obvious need to bolster the DL for the long term, shore up a REAL option at FS, potentially upgrade at nickel/CB2 and add a LB to replace TD(or EDGE to replace him, depending on how heavily we utilize the 3-4 looks). 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Trading down and acquiring picks is the way to go if the player we want isn't there. Most draft picks are a roll of the dice anyway, even the "safe" ones, so I'd be happy with them adding more lotto tickets seeing if we can hit. I mean, the last two year's picks 1-3 were pretty good, so if we can replicate that even a little bit I'd be happy. More picks can't hurt. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, kungfoodude said:

I honestly don't think we are exceptionally far away from being an elite offense. But I also don't think there are any players we could even trade up for to make that happen(Elite LT, for instance). Defensively, almost certainly not. I don't think we are as bad defensively as we looked last year but with a scheme shift, you wonder if we have the personnel in place to be an elite defense. Not to mention our obvious need to bolster the DL for the long term, shore up a REAL option at FS, potentially upgrade at nickel/CB2 and add a LB to replace TD(or EDGE to replace him, depending on how heavily we utilize the 3-4 looks). 

I mean I agree, but in order for either side to be borderline elite we need guys like Bradberry , kk, Shaq, and a Fs to play pro bowl level. Offense doesn’t need much, a healthy cam and the continuing emergence of D.J., Samuel, and Thomas. But like you said there’s not an offensive talent worth drafting top 5 this year besides qb. 

Keep doing what we did last year and build a complete roster, than when we are a couple key pieces away I can see us trading up 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a hard time thinking of a worse way to manage our draft than this nonsense Barnwell came up with. Maybe you could make an argument for this trade if Bosa or Allen somehow fall to 7 (something like Murray, Bosa, Haskins, Williams, Oliver, and White for the top 6 would make Allen available). Those are the only 2 players I would even entertain the idea for. Not Sweat or Gary or whoever your favorite o-lineman is. And definitely not for Hockenson. I still think we're better off sticking at 16 and grabbing whoever's still among Ferrell, Burns or Gary (or even Sweat if that's possible) and filling other needs like free safety and oline with those picks in rounds 2 and 3.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, rayzor said:

Click bait title fixed.

I'd take it a step further - it's not even speculation that Barnwell has on what he thinks we will do. He did a what if mock draft if every team were to make a trade in the first round (even calls it wild deals). It's kind of an "if they did trade in the first round", here's what they could consider. Not with any claims to knowledge of the team's plans, etc...but of course, the initial post just took the snippet about the Panthers and everyone ran wild with it without the proper context - it probably belongs in the mock draft thread.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • It seems the needs for the Panthers are at positions that tend to require intelligence to lift others--going from "good to great"--FS, ILB, and C--as you say. While i like Rodriguez a lot (can see the Hurricanes [Jarvis] and Panthers with a mustache player to get the fans into it)--I also like Golday (WLB?).  However, take a look at smallish Kyle Louis (Pitt).  He is known to be cerebral, but he is small (5'11" I think) and for that, I moved him lower.  But look at the different LB events at the combine--he is near the top in most of them.  I see him as a sleeper.  So if we wait until the second round, we can get a solid LB.   So what if we grab a free agent edge specialist (veteran) for pass situations and help develop Princely.  We draft FS (Oregon) first--maybe trading back to do so--I dunno.  We sign a free agent ILB and draft a rookie like Rodriguez or Louis.  In the third, we could probably find a center, like (former OT Parker from Duke) or Slaughter or Pew (may have to trade up).   So, as you say, others are fighting for Edge players, WRs, and OTs early like seagulls on the beach fighting over spilled corn chips, We sit back, grab intelligent players that make others better.  FS, ILB, and C. OT scares me more that Edge if we do this--but for those screaming for an edge--we have edge players--2 with starting experience who have had some degree of success.  JC Davis can play either T spot and he is good at pass blocking--a bit raw--but could be developmental depth that could play in a pinch. Or you could draft a solid OT with shorter arms that are driving them down into day 3--and convert them to G or C later.  Nijman and BC being re-signed could provide enough to hold down the job until a developmental OT (World, Oregon?) prepares for a shot at it.  Wagner (ND) could play LT but is probably a future RT--he is expected to be drafted early day 3.  My favorite day 3 OT sleeper?  Keagan Trost, Missouri. Great run blocker, soild pass blocker in SEC--just shorter arms.  Maybe a guard down the road, but for the time being, a T.  Not ideal, but at least you are building for the future.  
    • I'm not like most people in this thread in regards to Love. I'm not like most in regards to RBs either. I think certain ones will always be drafted in the first round because they are valued that highly. From an on-the-field perspective, they are as valued as ever; business-wise and contract-wise at times to re-up, that's where things can get tricky with valuation. That being said, Love oozes potential and makes higher-ups' mouths water. I know that he if somehow he is available at 19, he will be considered if not taken. You don't leave that type of talent on the board unless there is another compelling player of arguably equal or more value at another position of need that may have a higher priority (like maybe Sonny Styles). Now all that being said, I  don't realistically see either one of them being there at 19 according to the draftniks.
×
×
  • Create New...