NFL: Brees, Rodgers don't make the NFL's all time quarterback list

[Mr. Scot]

Quote

The 10 quarterbacks are, in alphabetical order, Sammy Baugh, Tom Brady, John Elway, Brett Favre, Otto Graham, Peyton Manning, Dan Marino, Joe Montana, Roger Staubach, and John Unitas.

Link

Saint fans are reportedly considering legal action.

Favre over Rodgers?

[thefuzz]

At least they didn't throw Bradshaw or Aikman in there.

[Mr. Scot]

1 minute ago, thefuzz said:

At least they didn't throw Bradshaw or Aikman in there.

Staubach over Bradshaw is an interesting choice.

Bradshaw bested him repeatedly, but if you were to ask me who was the more skilled quarterback I'd probably have to say Staubach.

[Harbingers]

7 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Link

Saint fans are reportedly considering legal action.

Favre over Rodgers?

Rodgers needs a few more rings to be considered. Bree’s too. 

[Captain Morgan]

2 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Staubach over Bradshaw is an interesting choice.

Bradshaw bested him repeatedly, but if you were to ask me who was the more skilled quarterback I'd probably have to say Staubach.

 

Roger the Dodger didn't have Swan and Stallworth, and the Steel Curtain defense.

[Davidson Deac II]

5 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Staubach over Bradshaw is an interesting choice.

Bradshaw bested him repeatedly, but if you were to ask me who was the more skilled quarterback I'd probably have to say Staubach.

I hate to give any Cowboy a compliment, but I would probably agree. Bradshaw was a very good qb, but the Steelers had a boatload of talent around him.  Dominant defense, great receivers, and a great oline and running game.  

[Mr. Scot]

1 minute ago, Captain Morgan said:

Roger the Dodger didn't have Swan and Stallworth, and the Steel Curtain defense.

He had Drew Pearson and the Doomsday Defense though.

[Toomers]

1 minute ago, Mr. Scot said:

Staubach over Bradshaw is an interesting choice.

Bradshaw bested him repeatedly, but if you were to ask me who was the more skilled quarterback I'd probably have to say Staubach.

That’s because Staubach was a much better QB. 
 

   Bradshaw shouldn’t be in the top 30. He was benched, twice, during their first SB season. In his 5th year. When we get to this elite level of comparison, everything counts. Just like Brees and his first 3 years before the rule change. Those count. 
 
    

[Captain Morgan]

those were great Super Bowls.

[Mr. Scot]

2 minutes ago, Toomers said:

That’s because Staubach was a much better QB. 

Bradshaw shouldn’t be in the top 30. He was benched, twice, during their first SB season. In his 5th year. When we get to this elite level of comparison, everything counts. Just like Brees and his first 3 years before the rule change. Those count.

I wouldn't argue that. Bradshaw was always a more balls than brains kind of player.

Leaving a guy that won four Super Bowls off the top ten list though? Ouch.

[Brooklyn 3.0]

Brees should be in over Elway.

[Mr. Scot]

Speaking of Super Bowls, you know who I'm kinda surprised to see left off this list?

Jim Kelly.

Yeah, I know he lost those games but Kelly was a damn good QB. I could argue he's at least better than Favre and Elway.

[thefuzz]

6 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Speaking of Super Bowls, you know who I'm kinda surprised to see left off this list?

Jim Kelly.

Yeah, I know he lost those games but Kelly was a damn good QB. I could argue he's at least better than Favre and Elway.

I'd agree with that.  Aikman and Elway are as overrated as it gets for me.  Good QB's, but not all time greats like heralded.  Same with Favre, although I like him a bit more than those two.

[Mr. Scot]

Just now, thefuzz said:

I'd agree with that.  Aikman and Elway are as overrated as it gets for me.  Good QB's, but not all time greats like heralded.  Same with Favre, although I like him a bit more than those two.

My thing with Favre is yeah, he probably had a better career overall than Aaron Rodgers has had to this point.

But in the same vein as Staubach and Bradshaw, could you really say Favre is the better quarterback?