Now that Young/Stroud will be gone before the Panthers pick, what FA QB do u want

[Varking]

1 minute ago, Skack25 said:

While this might be true.. I'd be terrified to take a chance on him in the first.  Especially if I was a GM with my job depending on it.

 This is what you pay the scouts for. Is he a good kid? Does he work hard? Does he have elite traits? If yes to all the above you can work with that. But you need to understand that you need to develop an offense that caters to their strengths until they grow to the point they can run anything you want. 
 

We have pass catching talent here and our offensive line is no longer bottom tier. Any QB we draft has a chance at success because of the talent around him. They will need to work for it. 

[mrcompletely11]

Just now, Varking said:

 This is what you pay the scouts for. Is he a good kid? Does he work hard? Does he have elite traits? If yes to all the above you can work with that. But you need to understand that you need to develop an offense that caters to their strengths until they grow to the point they can run anything you want. 
 

We have pass catching talent here and our offensive line is no longer bottom tier. Any QB we draft has a chance at success because of the talent around him. They will need to work for it. 

In your opinion, is AR a start right away and learn a la Allen or his he a sit a year and watch like mahomes?

[Catsfan69]

@ForJimmy you are pooing the idea of getting Roger Staubach reincarnated?

You like a dual threat QB well using your definition he's the greatest Dual Threat there is. 

But I guess Rings and Gold Jackets are disqualifiers for you.

[Catsfan69]

2 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

In your opinion, is AR a start right away and learn a la Allen or his he a sit a year and watch like mahomes?

He's worth a late 2nd early third.

You guys talk about odds with Matt Corral well the odds of someone repeating what Allen did are pretty long too.

[Catsfan69]

9 minutes ago, Growl said:

Richardson has some first round game

if he finishes the season strong he’ll enter the conversation proper

I don't think he has anyone decent left on his schedule does he? So if they are all scrubs it's going to make him look better.

[Growl]

2 minutes ago, Catsfan69 said:

I don't think he has anyone decent left on his schedule does he? So if they are all scrubs it's going to make him look better.

oh good, it’ll be nice to have another potential QB pick to hope for if the panthers end up picking #8 again

[Varking]

2 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

In your opinion, is AR a start right away and learn a la Allen or his he a sit a year and watch like mahomes?

To me it all depends on what type of offense we are going to plug him into. Do you want to play to his strengths and get him on the go and cut the reads required on a play to just half and then he has the option to run? He can play right away. 
 

You want to take this dynamic athlete and then force him to sit in the pocket every play and make four reads while figuring out the speed in the NFL? I’d prefer he sit for a bit. But a lot of that is going to be based on how he looks in camp. 
 

Im personally a fan of throwing rookies out there and let them take their lumps. 

[ForJimmy]

6 minutes ago, Catsfan69 said:

@ForJimmy you are pooing the idea of getting Roger Staubach reincarnated?

You like a dual threat QB well using your definition he's the greatest Dual Threat there is. 

But I guess Rings and Gold Jackets are disqualifiers for you.

I prefer to look at QBs who have played this past I don't know half a century???  What players did in the 60s doesn't reflect today's NFL.  Different rules, different types of athletes.  We are talking about a Josh Allen style QB and you bring up some guy from the 1960s as the QB you want....

[mrcompletely11]

Just now, Varking said:

 

Im personally a fan of throwing rookies out there and let them take their lumps. 

So am I, if they can play they can play, more times then not they can figure it out as long as the offense is catered to them specifically

[ForJimmy]

Just now, Varking said:

To me it all depends on what type of offense we are going to plug him into. Do you want to play to his strengths and get him on the go and cut the reads required on a play to just half and then he has the option to run? He can play right away. 
 

You want to take this dynamic athlete and then force him to sit in the pocket every play and make four reads while figuring out the speed in the NFL? I’d prefer he sit for a bit. But a lot of that is going to be based on how he looks in camp. 
 

Im personally a fan of throwing rookies out there and let them take their lumps. 

Eagles OC could run a similar offense that run for Hurts.  

[ForJimmy]

Just now, mrcompletely11 said:

So am I, if they can play they can play, more times then not they can figure it out as long as the offense is catered to them specifically

Especially with us having a decent OL for once.

[mrcompletely11]

1 minute ago, Growl said:

oh good, it’ll be nice to have another potential QB pick to hope for if the panthers end up picking #8 again

I was initially really against AR but after watching him and knowing we are getting an offensive guy I think it would be fun again to get a supreme talent and watch him grow.   The kid has talent for days and I think he will be available from picks 5ish-8

[mrcompletely11]

1 minute ago, ForJimmy said:

Especially with us having a decent OL for once.

fug it I am on board now lol

[rippadonn]

6 hours ago, Aussie Tank said:

The thing about Corral playing with all the rag tag bunch was he looked like he fitted in. Normally good players stand out around scrubs not our Matty boy. And for the love of god stop comparing him outlier QBs like it’s the norm and not the exception 

This isn't basketball. Scrubs not blocking and scrubs not catching isn't under Corrals control. I don't see where your premise can be applied. Is he supposed to be a wonder pill of some sort? Throw the ball and catch it?

C'mon man. The mantra is getting worn.