Bryce Young is the worst QB in Panthers History

[mav1234]

On 1/8/2026 at 2:09 AM, Jackson113.2 said:

This is insane - leave it to Panthers fans to ignore rushing production from a QB...

[Castavar]

On 1/8/2026 at 7:51 AM, CRA said:

Cam Newton had close to 4K yards and 30 TDs on a very efficient offense. 

these two things are nothing alike in terms of 2025 and 2013.  Which is why the guy at the top was a Pro Bowler in 2013

Exactly. Like what are we even saying here? Cam on this same team would have us in the superbowl. Imagine Cam with a legit #1 AND #2 WR in Tet and Coker, AND a legit o-line. This MF had Nate Chandler and Byron Bell guarding his entire right side lmfao 

Edited 12 hours ago by Castavar

[dep]

2 hours ago, mav1234 said:

This is insane - leave it to Panthers fans to ignore rushing production from a QB...

 

2 hours ago, Castavar said:

Exactly. Like what are we even saying here? Cam on this same team would have us in the superbowl. Imagine Cam with a legit #1 AND #2 WR in Tet and Coker, AND a legit o-line. This MF had Nate Chandler and Byron Bell guarding his entire right side lmfao 

 

Same poster just weeks ago

 

On 12/18/2025 at 5:08 PM, Jackson113.2 said:

I don't see how anyone that watched Panthers football in the past 3 years could argue for Bryce young.  It's been terrible.  We had more offense under Teddy 2 gloves.

  

On 1/4/2026 at 5:12 PM, Jackson113.2 said:

Bryce is garbage.... 

 

Are they really impressed by that playoff performance?

[mav1234]

I was hugely impressed by his playoff performance and I hope he can come out and play every game with that level next season.

But I'm skeptical of that, heh.

Regardless of that, it's just ridiculous to try to compare him this year to Cam in his first 3 seasons (or ever).

[The Lobo]

7 hours ago, *FreeFua* said:

OVERRATED

 

Ah yes he had a bad game, (see, I can admit a player I said was good has a bad game it happens) let’s go back and look at all of Bryce’s bad games, I don’t think anyone actually has time for that because there are so many.  Let’s forget the fact the announcers said he was the most sacked and pressured qb this year. How about all those high draft picks you always were referring too, they didn’t play in that game did they, especially his high draft pick tackles? How about the first round RB, how many carries did he get? 
 

Patriots beat the brakes off the panthers this year, Bryce had similar stats, is he overrated? If you put Bryce on the chargers this year, how would they do? (Don’t answer those I know what you are going to say) 

 

Which qb would you rather have based off of the pictures I’ve provided? 

[*FreeFua*]

25 minutes ago, The Lobo said:

Ah yes he had a bad game, (see, I can admit a player I said was good has a bad game it happens) let’s go back and look at all of Bryce’s bad games, I don’t think anyone actually has time for that because there are so many.  Let’s forget the fact the announcers said he was the most sacked and pressured qb this year. How about all those high draft picks you always were referring too, they didn’t play in that game did they, especially his high draft pick tackles? How about the first round RB, how many carries did he get? 
 

Patriots beat the brakes off the panthers this year, Bryce had similar stats, is he overrated? If you put Bryce on the chargers this year, how would they do? (Don’t answer those I know what you are going to say) 

 

Which qb would you rather have based off of the pictures I’ve provided? 

Put Bryce on the Chargers with the 6th best defense based on EPA/play yeah that team would do just fine. Ladd is built for Bryce.

Herbert had 28 total TDs to 13 INT’s this year. Bryce had 25 total TD’s to 11 INT’s. Both had 7 fumbles. 

During second half of season Bryce had a better EPA + CPOE comp and a better EPA/play than Herbert

The way people drag Bryce around here but throw Herbert into that elite category is laughable 

[frankw]

32 minutes ago, The Lobo said:

Ah yes he had a bad game, (see, I can admit a player I said was good has a bad game it happens) let’s go back and look at all of Bryce’s bad games, I don’t think anyone actually has time for that because there are so many.  Let’s forget the fact the announcers said he was the most sacked and pressured qb this year. How about all those high draft picks you always were referring too, they didn’t play in that game did they, especially his high draft pick tackles? How about the first round RB, how many carries did he get? 
 

Patriots beat the brakes off the panthers this year, Bryce had similar stats, is he overrated? If you put Bryce on the chargers this year, how would they do? (Don’t answer those I know what you are going to say) 

 

Which qb would you rather have based off of the pictures I’ve provided? 

The Chargers gave up 66 sacks this season. That's the most in the NFL. The Panthers gave up half that. I certainly remember the constant hand wringing and excuses from folks like him when Bryce was getting sacked into oblivion.

Anywho. The Patriots are possibly a legitimate Super Bowl contender. Bryce Young threw the ball 30 times for 150 yards against them for 5 yards per attempt. His stat line basically mirrors that of Herbert against them in the playoffs. Which team got blown out worse though with more at stake? And for clarity. Bryce was only sacked once in that game. Herbert was sacked 6 times.

Bryce on the Chargers would be brutal. Don't expect that unpaid sycophant to offer a rational rebuttal.

Edited 4 hours ago by frankw

[The Lobo]

15 minutes ago, *FreeFua* said:

Put Bryce on the Chargers with the 6th best defense based on EPA/play yeah that team would do just fine. Ladd is built for Bryce.

Herbert had 28 total TDs to 13 INT’s this year. Bryce had 25 total TD’s to 11 INT’s. Both had 7 fumbles. 

During second half of season Bryce had a better EPA + CPOE comp and a better EPA/play than Herbert

The way people drag Bryce around here but throw Herbert into that elite category is laughable 

Which qb would you rather have? 

[The Lobo]

54 minutes ago, frankw said:

The Chargers gave up 66 sacks this season. That's the most in the NFL. The Panthers gave up half that. I certainly remember the constant hand wringing and excuses from folks like him when Bryce was getting sacked into oblivion.

Anywho. The Patriots are possibly a legitimate Super Bowl contender. Bryce Young threw the ball 30 times for 150 yards against them for 5 yards per attempt. His stat line basically mirrors that of Herbert against them in the playoffs. Which team got blown out worse though with more at stake? And for clarity. Bryce was only sacked once in that game. Herbert was sacked 6 times.

Bryce on the Chargers would be brutal. Don't expect that unpaid sycophant to offer a rational rebuttal.

He thinks Bryce would have better production with Ladd than Tmac. I think I’m done engaging with him. 

[Jackson113.2]

One thread to lead them all..

A bunch of guys beating up on Bryce for 26 pages.. oh what fun.. 

Off season is  going to be a long one..

[jb2288]

3 hours ago, The Lobo said:

Ah yes he had a bad game, (see, I can admit a player I said was good has a bad game it happens) let’s go back and look at all of Bryce’s bad games, I don’t think anyone actually has time for that because there are so many.  Let’s forget the fact the announcers said he was the most sacked and pressured qb this year. How about all those high draft picks you always were referring too, they didn’t play in that game did they, especially his high draft pick tackles? How about the first round RB, how many carries did he get? 
 

Patriots beat the brakes off the panthers this year, Bryce had similar stats, is he overrated? If you put Bryce on the chargers this year, how would they do? (Don’t answer those I know what you are going to say) 

 

Which qb would you rather have based off of the pictures I’ve provided? 

Herbert is a better QB. The Chargers would have won yesterday if BY was their QB instead of Herbert. Both things are true. 

[Jackson113.2]

So, who's your pick? Free agents. Who's better than what we have?

Edited 2 hours ago by Jackson113.2

[The Lobo]

24 minutes ago, jb2288 said:

Herbert is a better QB. The Chargers would have won yesterday if BY was their QB instead of Herbert. Both things are true. 

The patriots smoked us and Bryce earlier this year. Their OL (this season) was twice as bad as ours. Mike Tirico said Herbert was the most pressured and sacked qb in the league. @frankwsaid he was sacked 66 times while Bryce was roughly half of that, imagine Bryce getting sacked twice as much, no way they win that game with Bryce at qb.  

[jb2288]

19 minutes ago, Jackson113.2 said:

So, who's your pick? Free agents. Who's better than what we have?

If you’re being objective the only one is Jones assuming he comes back 100% from injury. Willis has more tools but I’m not sold on him being a long term starter guy yet.