Does Kealoha Pilares beat out Armanti Edwards?

[CarolinaCatBrigade]

Kealoha Pilares:

Height:5'10"

Weight:199 lbs.

Arm Length:30 1/2 in.

Hand Size:8 3/4 in.

Overview:

Pilares tore his PCL in the Hawaii Bowl and must first demonstrate that he is healthy. If he recovers from his injury, he can be an effective slot receiver. He has great foot speed and regularly separates from linebackers and defensive backs on crossing and drag routes. He also finds soft spots in zone coverage and is very difficult to tackle in the open field after the catch. He lacks the speed to stretch the field, but this converted running back is shifty enough to move the chains. Pilares will be a late round pick if his rehabilitation is successful.

Armanti Edwards:

Height: 5'11

Weight: 187 lbs.

Couldn't find much of an analysis on him. But most of us on here already know who he is. So pretty much just compare the two.

Who do you feel will come out on top?

[The Saltman]

Dunno. I will tell you that Armanti isn't going anywhere. Not until he proves on the playing field that he sucks.

[mav1234]

they'll each be on the roster but I expect Pilares to 'start' before Armanti does.

[Millions]

Edwards gotta believe he's working hard to help contribute after the John Fox comments at least I hope he is

[YoungPanthers89]

yes

[jtnc]

Edwards is gonna beat out Pilares no doubt.

[SorthNarolina]

Considering Pilares isn't switching from QB to WR he's beat him before the battle has even started.

But one thing AE needs is good players around him. If we can afford to work him in slowly he'll look much more effective.

[jtnc]

Proehl is gonna transform AE into a monster.

[Easyt65]

Based on the 'Dwayne Jarrett-Eric Shelton Project Player Timeline', edwards has at least this and one more season to make it before being given the boot. :cool:

[Hoenheim]

Honestly, I have no clue what to expect on Edwards. Like someone just said above me, we haven't seen him play enough to make any sort of accurate judgement or prediction on his skill as a wide receiver. I think at this point, it just depends on how hard he works at it and what his natural skill level turns out to be when he gets some playing time...

[CatMan72]

Probably, Pilares has been playing WR all along... Armanti's still a work in progress.

[Sam Mills Fan]

Armanti couldn't make any other roster in the league, at least not as a pure receiver. This is a no-brainer.

[mwright350]

I'm not sure it's fair to compare them this year. I watched all the film I could on both of them though (because I'm bored) and Armanti could be at least as good as long as he has some sort of inner WR they can't bring out.

[GoDaddyGo]

And who was our leading reciever in the pre-season again??