Stewart wasn't down!

[Pizzle]

I was at the game so only saw the reviews in the stadium....what they showed looked like he was not down....oh well...I guess a W is a W!

[lightsout]

Refs screwed us many times. There were a couple big runs by MJD where, during the replay, there was CLEARLY holding or a block in the back that wasn't called. Then, the score just before halftime, a down field receiver blocked on of our guys in the back and basically threw him down and landed on him to spring the man for a TD, wasn't called. Then, the screen to MJD in the 3rd, block in the back (blatant) that sprung MJD for a first, no call.

Refs just do not like us. I don't know what it is, but it always happens. Really, same can be said for UNC, NC State, and ECU. Every game I watch with them, the penalty ratio is lopsided against them more times than not.

[Match.com]

b.s. call but we won...I really think this division is winnable...we had a bad game today partly due to the elements but I think we are real team...

[Donald LaFell]

Stewart clearly had a fulcrum to rotate around on that play so his elbow definitely was touching. But the replay certainly didn't show that conclusively. So I wouldn't have cared either way but the right call was made I doubt Rivera writes in to the NFL office about that.

[rayzor]

there was no conclusive video proof. should not have been overturned.

[Chimera]

When will you guys learn.... the refs hate the Panthers.

If that Calvin Johnson game winning TD catch (that was ruled incomplete) was against us last year, it would have been called a TD.

[Brooklyn Bully]

Funny how none of us know more than the coach or GM... but we all know more than the refs.

[CRA]

I think the play was overturned b/c it was obvious he elbow touched.

HOWEVER, there was no footage of it.

So I thinkt he refs went with what they knew did occur.....his elbow had to of hit based on what we saw....but that isn't what the rule they have to go by states.

[Dpantherman]

The part that is aggravating is the rule of "Indisputable Evidence". You have to have it to overturn the call. Between the conditions, and the play itself, I call Bullshit on them claiming to have it. I see how in hell they could have overturned the call.

But at the end of the day we won, thank goodness.

[Brooklyn Bully]

I'm sorry, but I saw his forearm hit. If your forearm is flat on the ground, your elbow is touching. As soon as I saw the replay, I was like, "CRAP. He's down."

[Dpantherman]

If you look at that footage 10 times, you'll see 10 different things. It wasn't indisputable.

But again, its kind of a mute point now, but still. I don't believe that had enough evidence to overturn it. Had he been called down, same thing. There was no clear angle to overturn that call.

[Jrock88]

I considered him down, so I wasn't that upset about the reversal. Not a big fan of the whole If you land on another player you're not down thing. Stewy got jacked up on that play and if it wasn't for the Jaguar corpse underneath him he would have been laid out.

[Mattiekrome]

no way, not down. The replay always showed the same look, the only thing ever touching the ground was his hand... no elbow as far as I could see.

[Mr. Scot]

He wasn't down.

I'd be upset about it if we hadn't won.

We did.