It begs the question, which is a bigger need: Kicker or Punter?

[Cat'sGrowl]

On one hand, you have our Kicker.

An old, overpaid, choke artist who replaced one of the most reliable kickers in league history. He has cost us arguably two games this year, and his few interviews have really made him come across as a doucher. He has been cut from multiple places because he can't keep his panties on in big moments, and is now incurring his wrath unsurprisingly (I told you so =p) on our team. He was brought in to give us great field position, in spite of the fact that the new kickoff rules make him obsolete-if you noticed the stat today, Mare is second in the league in touchbacks, yet we are 4-9 when we could have possibly been 6-7 (including a loss to a 2-win team) and in the hunt for the Wild Card.

On the other hand, you have our Punter, a team captain, also not young anymore, and is having far and away the worst year of his career. Some blame can possibly be attributed to our poor coverage of punts this year-but it's undeniable-Baker has been baaadd...real bad.

So, I'm simply curious, who do you look to replace first?

[Toolbox]

kicker is more important imo

[Proudiddy]

This is a trick question.

Both.

Cut them both ASAP and sign the f*cking smoothie guy.

[Sword]

i'd replace both with one super kicker from brazil

[mav1234]

Don't forget, one could make an argument that Baker could possibly have cost us the Arizona and Chicago games with his punts.

[YoungPanthers89]

Kicker

[DaCityKats]

Both should be on the list because that's what I would pick.

[KillerKat]

The one who puts points on the board is always more important

[NorthTryon]

I wish you put an option for both

[Matthias]

Why do teams have a punter and a kicker? Why not just get a guy that can punt and kick, to save a roster spot?

[Cyberjag]

He'll never say it, but I bet Hurney would like the whole Kasay/Mare decision back.

[Marguide]

Trick question.

Both have been horrible this year.

[SirSingleSentence]

We should look into signing Nick Krut, Division II punting leader 2009.

[davos]

They are both replaceable and without question should never....everrrr!!! return!