NFLN Proclaims Newton The Greatest Rookie Ever

[BBQ&Beer]

Big difference between saying he will be compared to Cam (if he is good, he will be compared to a lot of quarterbacks), and saying he will be questioned if he doesn't perform at the same level Cam has this year.

Fwiw, I don't see Indy pushing out a Hall of Fame quarterback for an untested rookie. The rookie salary cap means they will not have to pay Luck an arm and a leg to sign him, so they can afford both of them. They will play with Peyton next year, and maybe try to learn if Luck is as good as advertised. If they feel he is as good as advertised, then maybe 2012 might be Manning's last year as a Colt.

^This.

[bauss]

You think with families like the Luck's and Manning's that it's going to be team decision on what happens? Give me a break. Luck and Manning will both be starting next year.

[BBQ&Beer]

You think with families like the Luck's and Manning's that it's going to be team decision on what happens? Give me a break. Luck and Manning will both be starting next year.

Doubt it.

[Matthias]

Some of you who are saying the Colts can draft Luck and let him sit, seem to be forgetting that Luck has some power about that. Luck could demand a trade. And if the Colts are picking first, I hope he does.

[BBQ&Beer]

Some of you who are saying the Colts can draft Luck and let him sit, seem to be forgetting that Luck has some power about that. Luck could demand a trade. And if the Colts are picking first, I hope he does.

True, or someone could mortgage their future & break the bank to trade up... also some of you who believe that Luck will start seem to be forgetting that you don't know the kid.

[Dpantherman]

Oh, I can't wait to read Peter King's lame ass reasoning why he didn't vote Cam OROY

Last MMQB he had him as his OROY

[mmmbeans]

God. How is it that yet another thread about how great our young qb is playin is transformed into an Andrew luck butt hurt thread?

Owait, its in the OP.

Baussneggar you're an idiot.

[Wither]

It is official, then!

[Chaos]

Hopefully, Andrew Luck don't pull a Tonya Harding.

What, and release a poo quality white-trash homemade sex tape?

[bauss]

What, and release a poo quality white-trash homemade sex tape?

What? Link.

[Fiz]

This is not true btw

[thunderraiden]

If the rams get the first pick (which is 50-50 at this point) I could see the jets giving up thier next 3 drafts for Luck. AFC team so rams wont have to see them much and the jets are a great football team outside of thier Jimmy Clausen QB.

[CatMan72]

You're damn right he is.

[YoungPanthers89]

Where has trd and grits been?