Kuechly Ranked 4th Best Defender in the League by ESPN

[BigBoss]

Cam at 52? Ouch. Still don't see why Kaep always gets rated higher than Cam.

Kap gets a lot of credit for playoff victories. Including shredding the packers multiple times IN Green Bay. Media loves him for it

Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[ctrcat]

Kap gets a lot of credit for playoff victories. Including shredding the packers multiple times IN Green Bay. Media loves him for it

Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

Right, even though the only time Cam has played them he put up 432 in his second game when they were the defending champs.

[BigBoss]

Right, even though the only time Cam has played them he put up 432 in his second game when they were the defending champs.

 

Right well and we lost that game to on account of 3 of his interceptions and I believe a steve smith fumble.

 

I didn't say you had to like it, I'm just explaining one of the reasons why Kap gets so much love.

[London Loves Luke]

Davis at 69. Anyone think of a more underrated player in the league at the moment?

Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[duke11693]

Id put him 2nd. Watt, Keek, ET, Quinn, Sherman

[davos]

Bias aside, I think ET is the best overall player in the league.  Kuechly would be my #3 behind Watt and ahead of Sherman. 

[beastson]

I rank players on what ifs honestly. Like what if I put your ass on the 32nd ranked defense, how would you really do? Would you be as good or how about... look as good as if you were on a top 5 defense

 

I have to, because although there are some great individuality going on, but its a team sport

[Mvp2014]

Sherman isn't, but Thomas is most certainly. He's the key to that defense.

I agree, that boy be covering 3/4 of the field

[Jackofalltrades]

Luke should be ahead of Sherman just by virtue of his job and the added responsibilities that come with being the Mike.

[rmoneyg35]

I don't think sherman is the number one CB let alone #1 defender.

Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[dunnlx]

Sherman isn't, but Thomas is most certainly. He's the key to that defense.

This, I must agree Earl Thomas is the real deal!

Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[B.BERSIN]

Earl Thomas deserves this spot.

•••Sent from my couch while fuging the Saints•••

[Pox 08]

Sherman isn't, but Thomas is most certainly. He's the key to that defense.

 

Oh yeah.  Thomas deserves his ranking.

 

 

Thomas/Sherman -  Like with the old Willis/Bowman rankings where they were considered two of the very top defenders in the league ,  one deserves the credit.... and one doesn't. 

 

Thomas is amazing. Best in the league at his position. 

 

I would take PP over Sherman.

[Verge]

I would probably say

 

1. J.J. Watt

2. Robert Quinn/Earl Thomas

3. Von Miller

4. Luke Kuechly

5. Navorro Bowman

 

 

 

Just noticed how low

Brent Grimes

Thomas Davis

Derick Johnson

and Daryl Washington 

 

were rated, this list is pretty laughable.