Most Underrated/ Overrated?

[RelaxImaPro]

I know everyone talks about how underrated Lavonte David is, but I seriously think the dude has become so "underrated" that he's overrated.

 

PFF turned him into some sort of folk hero in 2013.  We in the NFCS (most of us anyways) knew he was a good young LBer after his rooke season, yet nobody really even talked about him until PFF started riding his jock.  People who didn't even watch him, just formed their opinion based on whatever PFF said.  That's probably my biggest problem with PFF.

 

Don't get me wrong, in watching games you can see he's the dude is a legit good player, but he doesn't seem anywhere near the level the "underrated" crowd hype him up to be.  He's a weird case... I've watched him plenty and he never really stands out much at all to me - sometimes none at all, yet by season's end he's racked up stats.  For two supposed top of their position HOF caliber players, McCoy being the other, you'd think the Bucs defense would be better than the dogshit it's been the past few seasons.

 

An actual underrated player is Thomas Davis - and this is Panthers bias aside... hardly anyone outside of Panther fans even acknowledge his existence, and he's been playing just as good as David the past 3 years IMO.

 

 

But anyways,

 

Overrated:  Larry Fitzgerald

 

Underrated: Seahawks receiving corps (especially when Golden Tate was still there)

[jackson113]

Over:Peyton and Eli

Under:SCP's helmet

[Jeremy Igo]

Yeah, but NY Strip is ass. Sirloin is wayyyyy better

 

 

Yes, it is, but the question at hand is what is more underrated. 

 

I contend that Sirloin's level of appreciation is pretty even with its level of tastiness. 

 

NY Strip when cooked correctly is delicious, yet it gets no love, as exemplified in your response. Therefore, NY Strip is more underrated. 

[PantherDynasty]

Yes, it is, but the question at hand is what is more underrated.

I contend that Sirloin's level of appreciation is pretty even with its level of tastiness.

NY Strip when cooked correctly is delicious, yet it gets no love, as exemplified in your response. Therefore, NY Strip is more underrated.

Fair enough, but Strip has a sort of grainy texture that I'm not a fan of.

[Jeremy Igo]

Fair enough, but Strip has a sort of grainy texture that I'm not a fan of.

 

 

 

I question the quality of the cuts you are getting. 

[Ricky Spanish]

Over: The Wilson/ Luck hype. 

 

They're both great young QBs, but comparable to Cam in every way, but he is a pariah by the media...

 

Under: Lavonte David, Thomas Davis and Tony Romo. Always been a Romo supporter even though I hate the Cowboys. He's too good for that organization. He doesn't crumble any more or less than any other QB in the NFL, in fact he has great 4th Quarter numbers, but because he's a cowgirl, his poo get's blown out of proportion. Manning chokes more in big games. 

[mbarbour21]

Overrated- Andrew Luck, Russell Wilson, & Matt Ryan

Underrated- Cam Newton, Seahawks' WRs, & T.Y. Hilton

[My Goodness My Guinness]

Overrated - filet mignon

Under-rated - New York strip

Ribeye trumps all

[Nate Dogg]

Overrated RGIII

Underrated Antonio Brown

[Jeremy Igo]

Ribeye trumps all

Sigh.

We aren't taking best, We are talking underrated.

Get on my level.

[Ace_Aladdin]

Underrated: Star Lotulelei 

[TheRumGone]

I know everyone talks about how underrated Lavonte David is, but I seriously think the dude has become so "underrated" that he's overrated.

PFF turned him into some sort of folk hero in 2013. We in the NFCS (most of us anyways) knew he was a good young LBer after his rooke season, yet nobody really even talked about him until PFF started riding his jock. People who didn't even watch him, just formed their opinion based on whatever PFF said. That's probably my biggest problem with PFF.

Don't get me wrong, in watching games you can see he's the dude is a legit good player, but he doesn't seem anywhere near the level the "underrated" crowd hype him up to be. He's a weird case... I've watched him plenty and he never really stands out much at all to me - sometimes none at all, yet by season's end he's racked up stats. For two supposed top of their position HOF caliber players, McCoy being the other, you'd think the Bucs defense would be better than the dogshit it's been the past few seasons.

An actual underrated player is Thomas Davis - and this is Panthers bias aside... hardly anyone outside of Panther fans even acknowledge his existence, and he's been playing just as good as David the past 3 years IMO.

But anyways,

Overrated: Larry Fitzgerald

Underrated: Seahawks receiving corps (especially when Golden Tate was still there)

Lavonte David has played better than TD without question, barely anybody talks about him on TV, never has made any pro bowls and he's one of the best linebackers in the league. That is the definition of underrated. Just because stat websites and forum posters talk about him doesn't mean "he's so underrated, he's overrated"

[camycamcan]

Over: Westbrook melo rose

Under: lamarcus Aldridge klay Thompson Anthony Davis Portlands backcourt hawks as individual players

[Nate Dogg]

Over: Westbrook