Madden 17 Carolina Panthers Ratings

[Crazydounut]

So since our roster is basically set (until we get more UFA's) and I am bored as almighty HELL (offseason blues.) I have decided to do a Madden roster overall rating. From a scale of 0-99 rating. 0-69 being shite 70-73 below average 74-79 average 80-84 above average 85-91 good 92-98 great and 99 being God. I have ranked each player (except for un-notable UDFA's.) To what I would rate their overall grade on Madden 17 (Note this is their overall grade. There is different ratings for a different skill/physical ability. This is just what their overall grade tally's up to. For instance Cam Newton would have 99 Throwing Power but only 88 Deep Accuracy. And Luke would have 99 Tackling but 76 man coverage but 96 zone coverage.)

QB-

Cam Newton: 98 OVR

Derek Anderson: 78 OVR

Joe Webb: 73 OVR

RB-

Jonathan Stewart: 93 OVR

Cameron Artis-Payne: 78 OVR

Fozzy Whittaker: 77 OVR

Brandon Wehger: 74 OVR

FB- 

Mike Tolbert: 96 OVR

WR- 

Kelvin Benjaman: 90 OVR

Devin Funchess: 83 OVR

Ted Ginn Jr.: 83 OVR

Philly Brown: 80 OVR

Keyarris Garrett: 75 OVR

Brenton Bersin: 72 OVR

Stephen Hill: 70 OVR

TE-

Greg Olsen: 96 OVR

Ed Dickson: 77 OVR

Beau Sandland: 71 OVR

OT-

Michael Oher: 86 OVR

Mike Remmers: 81 OVR

David Foucalt: 78 OVR

Daryl Williams: 76 OVR

Donald Hawkins: 71 OVR

OG-

Trai Turner: 98 OVR

Andrew Norwell: 97 OVR

Chris Scott: 76 OVR

Reese Dismukes: 72 OVR

Tyler Larsen: 70 OVR

David Yankey: 69 OVR

C-

Ryan Kalil: 97 OVR

Gino Gradkowski: 75 OVR

DE-

Kony Ealy: 86 OVR

Charles Johnson: 80 OVR

Mario Addison: 79 OVR

Ryan Delaire: 78 OVR

Wes Horton: 74 OVR

Miley Arthur: 72 OVR

Larry Webster: 70 OVR

DT-

Kawann Short: 99 OVR

Star Lotulelei: 96 OVR

Paul Soliai: 85 OVR

Vernon Butler: 78 OVR

Kyle Love: 76 OVR

Robert Thomas: 71 OVR

Chas Alecxih: 69 OVR

OLB-

Thomas Davis: 96 OVR

A.J Klein: 84 OVR

Shaq Thompson: 83 OVR

Ben Jacobs: 74 OVR

Jeremy Cash: 74 OVR

MLB-

Luke Kuechly: 99 OVR

David Mayo: 75 OVR

Brian Blechen: 71 OVR

CB-

Bene Benwikere: 88 OVR

Brandon Boykin: 82 OVR

James Bradberry: 75 OVR

Daryl Worley: 75 OVR

Zack Sanchez: 75 OVR

Lou Williams: 74 OVR

Robert McClain: 74 OVR

Teddy Williams: 72 OVR

FS-

Kurt Coleman: 93 OVR

Colin Jones: 77 OVR

Ras-I Dowling: 70 OVR

SS-

Tre Boston: 84 OVR

Marcus Ball: 72 OVR

K-

Graham Gano: 95 OVR

P-

Swayze Waters: 76 OVR

KR-

Ted Ginn Jr.: 99 OVR

Joe Webb: 84 OVR

PR-

Ted Ginn Jr.: 99 OVR

Brenton Bersin: 0 OVR

(And if they had a coaching overall rating)

Ron Rivera: 96 OVR

Mike Shula: 95 OVR

Shawn McDermott: 96 OVR

TEAM OVERALL RATINGS:

OFFENSE: 90 

DEFENSE: 91

ST: 88

COACHING: 96

OVERALL: 92

Let me know what you think of the ratings

[XClown1986]

Man that interior offensive line is beastly.

[shreddingdefense]

clearly you are not wearing your homer glasses. 99 overall for all!

[CPF4LIFE]

Lmaoo....this is hilarious 

[Leeroy Jenkins PhD]

I think Kalil takes a step back. Love the man, but 97 ovr is really pushing it.  

 

No rating for D.Williams?  I think he challenges for a starting role. 

[Crazydounut]

1 minute ago, Leeroy Jenkins PhD said:

I think Kalil takes a step back. Love the man, but 97 ovr is really pushing it.  

 

No rating for D.Williams?  I think he challenges for a starting role. 

Yeah. I was thinking maybe to bring him down but our running game had such a beastly year and he is a big part of it. I decided to give him a high rating. I have never heard of this D. Williams fellow you are talking about. Is he even a real NFL player?

[nctarheel0619]

To impress a chick, do the helicopter dick.  

[Growl]

This is what you think they are or what you think they will be in the game?

 

Because assuming that buccaneers fan is still their ratings guy, I can assure you they won't be giving Cam 98 overall

[Crazydounut]

Just now, Growl said:

This is what you think they are or what you think they will be in the game?

 

Because assuming that buccaneers fan is their ratings guy, I can assure you they won't be giving Cam 98 overall

What I think they should be. Im sure EA will give our players underrated ratings and give the Cowboys 99 everything since they are the best team in the NFL and Tony Homo is the 2nd coming of Jesus Christ

[GhostP.]

 Stopped reading when I saw this

Mike Tolbert: 96 OVR

 

 

[shreddingdefense]

2 minutes ago, Growl said:

This is what you think they are or what you think they will be in the game?

 

Because assuming that buccaneers fan is still their ratings guy, I can assure you they won't be giving Cam 98 overall

The tampa bay rating guy left sometime after last years game was released. I dunno who is doing it now. But the guys over a fbgratings.com are trying to get their ratings in the game. You would rarely see guys in the 90s. Alot of 60 and 70 overall. I think luke was 78ish. Roster would be rated that way to make the game more realistic and less arcadish.

[t96]

14 minutes ago, Crazydounut said:

Yeah. I was thinking maybe to bring him down but our running game had such a beastly year and he is a big part of it. I decided to give him a high rating. I have never heard of this D. Williams fellow you are talking about. Is he even a real NFL player?

Daryl Williams not DeAngelo.

[Growl]

3 minutes ago, shreddingdefense said:

The tampa bay rating guy left sometime after last years game was released. I dunno who is doing it now. But the guys over a fbgratings.com are trying to get their ratings in the game. You would rarely see guys in the 90s. Alot of 60 and 70 overall. I think luke was 78ish. Roster would be rated that way to make the game more realistic and less arcadish.

Haven't bought the game real recently. I downloaded the free trial  they are doing for '16 though this weekend and while there are some fun improvements (throwing the deep ball actually being possible for one) I still don't know if I can bring myself to buy it this year. 

 

For starters, why is the ea sports logo plastered everywhere all throughout the game.

 

[KillerKat]

12 minutes ago, GhostP. said:

 Stopped reading when I saw this

Mike Tolbert: 96 OVR

 

 

Yeah i had Tolbert at 81 at the end of last season. He is just way overrated by some.