Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Donald and Barron hits. Clean or not clean?


Crazydounut

Recommended Posts

In yesterday's game vs the Rams Cam took 2 shots to the head. 1 from Mark Barron a S/LB combo player and Aaron Donald. Arguably the best DT in the league. 

Review of Barron hit: Overall I thought it was dirty but not intentionally dirty. Barron isn't that kind of player and he was just playing hard. It seemed like he tried to Sack Cam with his shoulder into his chest and he incidentally hit helmet to helmet with Cam. Overall it definetly should have been called roughing the passer. But at the end of the day I guess it is the norm now right?

Review of Donald hit: I think that this one is tougher to decipher. Donald is a intense player but not a dirty player like Suh, or Burfict. But he has had a few roughing the passer calls in the past. It seemed like he jumped onto Cam in a clean way. Just so happened that his helmet hit Cam's when he Leapfrogged onto Cam's upper body. I think that it should have been called roughing the passer as well. Obviously not as clear cut as a missed call that Barron's hit was. But the rules state that you cannot hit a QB in the pocket late, low, or in the head. By rule Donald should've been flagged but a tough call to make live so I am not as mad about this hit.

The NFL seems to not care what Cam and the Panthers say. But the NFL is getting a lot of negative press for these kinds of events continually happening. Hopefully it comes back to bite them in the ass

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, Growl said:

The Donald hit looked clean. The Barron was as dirty as a Clinton.

Donald jumped up and came down and cracked Newton in the head with his helmet.

it isn't about intent or trying to play dirty...Donald's hit was illegal.  Helmet to helmet in the pocket is illegal.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, JayNasty said:

Cleaned Cam's clock.   Both looked clean to me, they were just vicious hits.  Any other QB would be dead from the Barron hit

How is a a defenders helmet hitting Cam's helmet clean? Hitting a QBs helmet with your mere hand draws QBs the call. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, Jase said:

to me it looked like barron came in with the shoulder and forearm and donald came helmet to helmet.

Barron intentionaly went high and contact with the head was clearly made. 

Doesnt matter if he shoulder lead the flight  to Cam head or not 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, CRA said:

How is a a defenders helmet hitting Cam's helmet clean? Hitting a QBs helmet with your mere hand draws QBs the call. 

Those were just football plays.  I just dont see the hit to the head on Barron's hit, maybe I need to see it in slow-mo.  Donald's was a little closer to to helmet to helmet hit, but it could have went either way in my eyes. 

 

Edit:  Just seen the other angle of the Barron hit.  Yep, flag should have thrown.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I see they blamed Slavin for the goal like I did. 
    • See this is the problem, you say "can't get off the line quick" and "can't separate quick" but in reality it's "he can get off the line better and create more separation" which are two completely different things. If he couldn't get off the line or separate, he wouldn't have put up the numbers he did and end up a Top 10 pick. But he can get better, and maybe more accurately, consistent with them both, and that will take his game to the next level.  These are things that are also much easier to improve once you get to the NFL than things like being a poor route runner or having bad hands, two of his strengths. Thinking he can't get open in the short passing game also shows you haven't watched enough tape on him, as he was used in that role so much in college with little issue getting open and making plays. And him not using his physicality as much isn't even something that hurts his game because he's so much more agile than a player of his size should be, which he used to his advantage.  Instead of throwing passes where he'd go up and box out a player like a TE or Mike Evans does, they use his athleticism and put the ball in places that only he can get to it, and he usually does (and yes, he'll still be able to do that against NFL DB's with his catch radius). But now that he's in the NFL, I'd like to see him get stronger and add that to his game because it also will help him take his game to another level. As I've said before, if he doesn't improve on those things at all, I think he's a Top 25 WR in this league, he's already that good.  But I think he'll improve on those things and be a perennial Top 10 WR and in his prime is considered and perform like Top 5 guy in some years. My expectations for him this year at 800 yards and 8 TDs (although I do think he'll get to 10 TDs) with a real chance at getting to 1,000.  But those expectations are because I think Thielen will lead the team in yards with close to 1k and XL/Coker each end up in the 500-600 range themselves, just too many mouths to feed this year for a rookie to dominate yardage, especially if we're running the ball well again. But if Thielen can't stay healthy or puts up sub 750 yards, then yea, my expectations for T-Mac likely shift to getting to 1k as a rookie.
    • Svech only 1 goal behind the guy they've pretty much already given the Conn Smythe to...
×
×
  • Create New...