Poll: Berry or KK

[Nails]

Not saying it IS either/or, but if it WAS, who?

[KillerKat]

Berry. We spent a 1st on a DT last year.

[t96]

Neither for what they're asking for. If they come down would consider it but couldn't make a decision this year without knowing exactly what we have in Butler.

[Nails]

6 minutes ago, thomas96 said:

Neither for what they're asking for. If they come down would consider it but couldn't make a decision this year without knowing exactly what we have in Butler.

There's every reason to think Butler has a bright future.  Don't we KNOW what we have in Boston?  Any way to KNOW what we'd have at safety in the draft?

[Davidson Deac II]

Generally speaking, i would say Short since I think that Dlinemen are more valuable than Safeties.  But we are pretty well set DT, so perhaps Berry, assuming his cancer doesn't return.  

 

I think the odds of Berry coming here are very slim though.  

[LinvilleGorge]

I voted Berry, but I can't see Gettleman valuing a DB over a DL.

[pantherphan96]

You really think a rookie who barely played last season can replace KK at DT? Especially with our current DE's? Give me KK over Berry any day.

[Nails]

Just now, Davidson Deac II said:

Generally speaking, i would say Short since I think that Dlinemen are more valuable than Safeties.  But we are pretty well set DT, so perhaps Berry, assuming his cancer doesn't return.  

 

I think the odds of Berry coming here are very slim though.  

People think they're slim based on history and what we know of GMan.  FUG that.  Let's write a new history.  The Falcons did and nearly won the whole thing by being aggressive and signing Alex Mack who stoned our beloved KK.  NOW is the time to be aggressive and sign a guy that's already stoned the Falcons in his own right.

[Nails]

1 minute ago, pantherphan96 said:

You really think a rookie who barely played last season can replace KK at DT? Especially with our current DE's? Give me KK over Berry any day.

I do.  KK was invisible for a large portion of last year and one year ago Butler was mocked in the top 20.  Big time talent.  It's time.

[KillerKat]

4 minutes ago, pantherphan96 said:

You really think a rookie who barely played last season can replace KK at DT? Especially with our current DE's? Give me KK over Berry any day.

Yeah because that really helped us last year.

[pantherphan96]

3 minutes ago, Nails said:

I do.  KK was invisible for a large portion of last year and one year ago Butler was mocked in the top 20.  Big time talent.  It's time.

KK may have not put up big sack numbers but he was huge in putting pressure on the opposing QB. I like Butler but its ridiculous to expect him to replace a 2nd team All-Pro DT.

Just now, KillerKat said:

Yeah because that really helped us last year.

2nd most sacks in the NFL even with the shaky secondary.

[Eazy-E]

Berry will be cheaper long term than KK. This team needs ends very badly. Berry will be 10 to 12 mill per where Kk will be 12 to 16 mill per. Use the extra money saved and sign the best DE we can. 

Butler looked good in limited time last year. He also blocked a kick which is something I haven't seen a Panther do in a long time.

[uncfan888]

Berry

[RoaringRiot]

8 minutes ago, Eazy-E said:

He also blocked a kick which is something I haven't seen a Panther do in a long time.

He actually had two. Which is unreal.