Replay Officials

[ichigo1057]

So I think this is an interesting topic to discuss. What do you guys think of how the NFL have done with replays at this point of the season

I think they still can't seem to get their poo together myself. Taking our game as an example, Cam's Superman dive that was ruled down on the line. By all accounts of the replay it showed that the ball crossed the line before any part of his body touched out and as a result should have been reversed to a TD. As we all know the officials ended up letting the play stand citing "Not enough evidence to over call the ruling on the field.". A bunch of BS personally but whatever we scored the next play. Compare that with what happened in the Jets vs. Patriots game where the runner briefly has the ball come loose but secures it before going out for what is ruled as a TD. The replay officials go back and look at this and from all replays shown there was no clear evidence to overturn the TD however they end up ruling it a fumble out of the end zone and as a result a touch back and Patriots ball. I know by all means every replay is different but jeez these guys need to be more consistent with their rulings. If there was no evidence on our call then by all means there should have been no evidence on the Jet's call as well.

[Pimpdaddy]

Jets got boned...

[Darth Biscuit]

Have said for years that calling plays in real time is tough but the replay official should get it right a 100% of the Time and they're constantly getting things wrong 

[raleigh-panther]

Well they have this crap rule about there must be enough evidence to over turn what was called on the field

we,should remember this from Superbowl 50

sadly

newton got robbed without doubt and so did the Jets today 

[Popsickle]

I think the replay officials are doing a decent job, in my opinion (which is not from a trained expert as them) they still mess up a call every but that is going to happen. 

Also, I agreed with the call on the field and the replay of Cams run from Thursday. There was not definitive evidence that he crossed the goal line. There was not angle of the shot to confirm 100%.  

 

[Ace_Aladdin]

Jets ASJ got robbed by the refs for a TD to help Cheatriots win the game.

[LinvilleGorge]

IMO, it's at best no better than in the past this season and honestly, I think it's worse. That Jets/Pats call was unbelievably awful.

[Snake]

I think I could do a better job. I have no clue what they saw on Cam's TD or the Jets. Robots might be the best option. 

[LinvilleGorge]

5 minutes ago, Popsickle said:

I think the replay officials are doing a decent job, in my opinion (which is not from a trained expert as them) they still mess up a call every but that is going to happen. 

Also, I agreed with the call on the field and the replay of Cams run from Thursday. There was not definitive evidence that he crossed the goal line. There was not angle of the shot to confirm 100%.  

 

You realize that you can piece the different angles together, right? When you piece together the head on view with the side view, it was clearly a TD. It really doesn't matter since we scored a TD anyway, but that Pats/Jets call... holy fug.

[CatTower]

8 minutes ago, Popsickle said:

I think the replay officials are doing a decent job, in my opinion (which is not from a trained expert as them) they still mess up a call every but that is going to happen. 

Also, I agreed with the call on the field and the replay of Cams run from Thursday. There was not definitive evidence that he crossed the goal line. There was not angle of the shot to confirm 100%.  

 

Someone with a basic understanding of math and angles could clearly decipher that Cam had crossed the plane before touching the ground.  I guess the replay officials must be 5 year old kids?

[Popsickle]

4 minutes ago, CatTower said:

Someone with a basic understanding of math and angles could clearly decipher that Cam had crossed the plane before touching the ground.  I guess the replay officials must be 5 year old kids?

Let's see your math. 

[toldozer]

6 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

You realize that you can piece the different angles together, right? When you piece together the head on view with the side view, it was clearly a TD. It really doesn't matter since we scored a TD anyway, but that Pats/Jets call... holy fug.

It did matter.  Cost us a time out.  Imo they should always call touchdown when there is any question.  Then neither team has to waste a challenge and potential timeout.

[Darth Biscuit]

Idk what Popsickle or the replay guys were looking at but it couldn't have been any clearer that Cam reached across the goal line before jis foot was oob...

 

Also just saw that Jets replay, holy poo that was awful... how tf is that a fumble???

At absolute worst, it should have been jets ball at the one.

[Darth Biscuit]

2 minutes ago, Popsickle said:

Let's see your math. 

poo watch the video...