Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

I would like to talk about this Matt Kalil situation

electro's horse

By electro's horse,
in Carolina Panthers

Recommended Posts

electro's horse Grand Master

electro's horse

Posted
Posted

Matt Kalil is bad. 

Matt Kalil's contract is bad. 

How bad is it? The Panthers would eat 13.7 million in dead cap space just for the privilege of cutting him after this season. The season after is more palatable at 1.8. After that if he's still on the team, his ass is in the street. 

Now on IR, until at least week 8, Panther nation, along with the rest of the world who appreciates talent and beauty, is hoping he never sees starting time at LT again. That Tyler Moton turns into Walter Jones and holds the spot down for ten years. I mean, hope is important. 

What do we do with Matt Kalil? 

1. Banish to Cleveland

The Panthers could have sent him and a pick to Cleveland back when they were just taking horrible contracts for draft picks (ie Osweiler). At that point, Kalil wasn't as hopelessly lost as he is now, but Jerry was still in charge. Ryan Kalil holds a lot of sway in the organization, and it wouldn't be The Family Way to send someone to die in Ohio when their brother is so important to the organization. 

But Jerry was sent to the molestation ranch, and Ryan is on maybe his final year. Dave Tepper probably doesn't give a poo, although we don't know much about the new office politics. 

Historically, Hurney hasn't taken advantage of stupid front offices like New England does, with one notable exception with Greg Olsen. But the Browns are always there, and now apparently the Raiders are too. There's also enough former Panthers assistants scattered throughout the league that could be foolish enough to think they could rehab him. 

2. Force a Restructure

Okay, we're out of options here. If you're Matt Kalil, why in the world would you restructure that contract? The Panthers have absolutely no leverage, unless Matt wants to keep playing. 

The Panthers could tell him they'll effectively bench him for two seasons then cut him. He'll get his money, hit none of his incentives (god knows what those are), and then they'll ship him out the door the day the 2019 business cycle ends. At that point, he'll have been out of football effectively for 2 seasons, with no good tape since his rookie year. He'll have to take a bunch of flyers with shitty teams offering the vet min. You'd be effectively ending his career.

I think this could work if done correctly and savagely enough. Players have pride. And telling someone "you're not good enough but we're stuck here because we can't trade you" is going to cut deep. At that point, he might be willing to restructure to make himself tradeable. 

Again, there are plenty of former panthers coaches and FO men around the league who know him. This wouldn't be sending a pick to get rid of his contract like in the previous scenario, but it'd be similar. 

3. Change his position

This is a pipe dream. Kalil has sucked at the position he's played all his life; you don't just roll the dice and hope it works out. Furthermore, the Panthers rely on their linemen pulling quite a bit. Who knows if that'll continue under Norv, but as long as cam as there, we're going to need more athletic interior linemen. Imagine Kalil playing LG, stepping back to sprint left, tripping over a tall blade of grass, then falling backwards into every one of Cam's ligaments, and pooping his pants in the process.

No no, there's no salvaging this through madden tricks. 

4. Doing nothing is easier than doing something

Discretion something something valor. You have to play the hand you're dealt. Hurney has never been one to get out of bad contracts; to the opposite, he usually doubles down. It's incredibly possible that Kalil just hangs around as a shitty tackle for the next two seasons. Moton will likely struggle, and Rivera, eager to play both sides like he's done his entire career, will call it "an open competition." Moton will be benched after Kalil has "a strong week of practice," and we'll be right to all this again. 

Moving into 2019, it'll be another open competition, with lots of articles mysteriously coming out that Matt is ready to take the next step. That he started doing yoga or crossfit in the offseason, that he went to a fish only diet, that he's cut out sugars, that he looks leaner than ever, and that he's ready to dominate the left side for years to come. No matter how badly he struggles, he'll continue to split first team reps with moton or whomever. Rivera will take the path of least resistance, name him the starter, and we'll be here again. 

Corporate inertia is a powerful, powerful thing. 

5. Accidents happen all the time

All.

The. 

Time.

So where do we go?

I honestly think forcing a restructure could work if the panthers were ruthless enough to do it. "Take your illgotten fortune and never play football again, or work with us and we'll send you somewhere you can compete."

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Lumps Newbie

Lumps

Posted
Posted
7 minutes ago, electro's horse said:

That Tyler Moton turns into Walter Jones and holds the spot down for ten years. I mean, hope is important. 

Impossible. That means he’d be good and demand money and Panthers don’t pay or really retain olineman.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Mr. Scot Grand Master

Mr. Scot

Posted
Posted
8 minutes ago, electro's horse said:

At that point, Kalil wasn't as hopelessly lost as he is now, but Jerry was still in charge. Ryan Kalil holds a lot of sway in the organization, and it wouldn't be The Family Way to send someone to die in Ohio when their brother is so important to the organization. 

Ugh.

I really really hate when players have influence over roster decisions. That's one thing I absolutely hope Tepper chucks out the door.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
LinvilleGorge Grand Master

LinvilleGorge

Posted
Posted

It always surprises me how many people don't understand that trading a player is the same as cutting a player in terms of cap impact. All that bonus money gets accelerated.

Best case scenario for us, his injuries continue to linger and we work out an injury settlement. I would say the best case is that Matt retires but there's zero chance he walks away from all that money. He'd keep showing up and force us to release him.

Most likely scenario, we cut him next off-season and designate him as a post June 1st cut so we can spread the cap hit out over two years.

Either way, Matt Kalil is the biggest roster love mistake this franchise has made since Sean Gilbert.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
tondi Newbie

tondi

Posted
Posted

I honestly don't think he cares if he ever sets foot on a football field ever again, which is the bigger problem than whatever phantom injury is ailing him.  Dave has made him set for life either way so now that hes found his sucker he's happy to cash a check and kick back.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • raleigh-panther
      Bleacher report not buying Panthers’ hype

      By raleigh-panther · Posted

      Well, everyone is a critic.  not much meat on the bone here in analysis but if the team needs motivation … lol   I have also heard a lot of talking head or two say that ‘Young is not in the same class as most of these teams and that in 12 of the 17 games he is the lesser QB   BR write up below  2025 record: 8-9 Last season, the Carolina Panthers made the playoffs for the first time since 2017. They won the division. Bryce Young made strides, throwing for 3,011 yards, 23 touchdowns and 11 interceptions with a 63.6 percent completion rate. Wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan won the 2025 Offensive Rookie of the Year award. In free agency, the Panthers signed edge-rusher Jaelan Phillips and linebacker Devin Lloyd to bolster their middling defense. Carolina can win with complementary football if the offense continues to trend in the right direction. In 2026, Carolina will play the AFC North and NFC North on a first-place schedule, which includes matchups against the Pittsburgh Steelers, Philadelphia Eagles, Chicago Bears, Denver Broncos, and the Seattle Seahawks. The club will have a much tougher 17-game slate than it had last year, which may lead to regression. The Panthers aren't on the same level as the league's top teams. We'll see the gap between them and division-winning clubs from the previous season. 2026 projection: 6-11  
    • strato
      Panthers 2026 schedule

      By strato · Posted

      If someone key is hurt and your bye week helps you by not forcing you to play without them, it is at a good time.  No way to know about that ahead of time.   I would concede that with 17 games and let’s say you are playoff bound, you would love to have it late  
    • LinvilleGorge
      Turk Wharton Neck Surgery

      By LinvilleGorge · Posted

      Hate it for him personally and hope he recovers well. But honestly, reaching an injury settlement and moving on would probably be a best case scenario for the Panthers. This signing always felt like a desperate knee-jerk reaction to losing out on Milton Williams. Williams was a logical scheme fit while Wharton just wasn't. He's best used as a rotational interior pass rushing specialist in an even front. He's way too small to play the nose in a 3-4 and he lacks the length and juice to play the end. Healthy he's a nice roster piece in the right scheme at the right price but we overpaid him to play him in the wrong scheme. The signing just never made any sense to me and I said so at the time.
×
×
  • Create New...