The other lineup question

[Mr. Scot]

Should Torrey Smith get his starting job back when he's healthy?

[t96]

Probably not but he likely will. I do see DJ's snap #s staying pretty high though. This year is more like 2015 where we spread it out a ton. Doubt anyone gets 1000 receiving yards, which is not necessarily a bad thing.

[countryboi]

most likely not but i would be ok with a greatly reduced role. 

[Mage]

I don't think it matters who starts, just comes down to snaps.  Smith will keep starting more than likely, but Moore's snaps are gonna go up a ton as the season goes on.  It was already going in that direction even when Smith was healthy.

[Shaqil915]

RR needs to be fired ASAP if Torrey Smith gets more snaps then DJ next week.

[Lemory]

You ok? You've been on this Torrey Smith thing all day, just enjoy the W.

[MasterAwesome]

When you were typing up this thread, did you really think this question was going to stir up any kind of debate?

[LinvilleGorge]

No, but if he's back next week he almost certainly will. If he has to miss another week or two then we may have seen enough to make the change for good, but one week even against the #1 D almost certainly won't be enough for Ron.

[Mr. Scot]

10 minutes ago, Lemory said:

You ok? You've been on this Torrey Smith thing all day, just enjoy the W.

I'm fine, but admittedly tired of having a head coach's best personnel decisions be made for him.

The saying goes that fate protects fools and little children. I'd probably add "and sometimes Ron Rivera" to that list.

[Mr. Scot]

8 minutes ago, MasterAwesome said:

When you were typing up this thread, did you really think this question was going to stir up any kind of debate?

it's actually generated some pretty decent discussion so far...other than your comment, of course.

[MasterAwesome]

5 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

it's actually generated some pretty decent discussion so far...other than your comment, of course.

You asked if Torrey Smith should get his starting job back and literally everyone has said no...if that’s your idea of good debate, then I don’t know what to tell you. I could start a topic on “do you think Cam should be benched for Heinecke” and it would get similarly insightful discussion by your logic.

[Mr. Scot]

4 minutes ago, MasterAwesome said:

You asked if Torrey Smith should get his starting job back and literally everyone has said no...if that’s your idea of good debate, then I don’t know what to tell you. I could start a topic on “do you think Cam should be benched for Heinecke” and it would get similarly insightful discussion by your logic.

If you look back, you'll find previous posts in this thread don't just contain the word "no".

People are making valid points. Again, except you.

Don't like the discussion? Don't take part in it. It's a superior choice to making an ass out of yourself, anyway.

[CBDellinger]

Mr Scott... your bone cone for Ron is bothering the other guests.  If you insist on wearing a speedo, please wear a robe when you’re not in the pool or hot tub.  TIA.

[Mr. Scot]

1 minute ago, CBDellinger said:

Mr Scott... your bone cone for Ron is bothering the other guests.  If you insist on wearing a speedo, please wear a robe when you’re not in the pool or hot tub.  TIA.

I like Rivera the person. He's a great guy. Rivera the coach makes enough bad decisions to make me uncomfortable.

I'm still not on the firing bandwagon, though. Just the "question his decision making" one.