If Drake Maye was in this draft would you pick him over Young?

[Varking]

15 minutes ago, USDepartmentOfSavagery said:

Name one QB that’s never lost a game lmao. What do you mean why lol

He’s the only one I can think of that painted his nails to trash an inferior team only to lose the game after doing it. It’s a bit childish even if you win but it’s like calling your shot in baseball and then striking out. It makes you look stupid and it makes your team look even worse when your team has so much more talent than the team that just upset you. 

[Day1PanthersFan]

9 minutes ago, panthers55 said:

Young because he won a national championship

Like that has ever mattered, there is a long list of draft busts that won the national title 

 

Edited April 27, 2023 by Day1PanthersFan

[panthers55]

Just now, Day1PanthersFan said:

Like that has ever mattered, The Golden Calf of Bristol also won a national title 

 

It is the experience of playing at the highest level and winning the game. How many players get to do that in their college career. It is a big deal. 

[USDepartmentOfSavagery]

3 minutes ago, Varking said:

He’s the only one I can think of that painted his nails to trash an inferior team only to lose the game after doing it. It’s a bit childish even if you win but it’s like calling your shot in baseball and then striking out. It makes you look stupid and it makes your team look even worse when your team has so much more talent than the team that just upset you. 

He threw for nearly 400 yards and 3 TDs. He did his part. 

Edited April 27, 2023 by USDepartmentOfSavagery

[LinvilleGorge]

16 minutes ago, panthers55 said:

Young because he won a national championship, played in the toughest division and is a great skilled player. 

Maye can only claim the third thing - he is a great skilled player.  Let's see how he plays next year...

I honestly don't care about the first two criteria. You'd miss out on most of the greatest QBs in NFL history of you demanded to check all three boxes.

[Day1PanthersFan]

3 minutes ago, panthers55 said:

It is the experience of playing at the highest level and winning the game. How many players get to do that in their college career. It is a big deal. 

But it isn't an indicator of talent,means your overall team was better than the rest, and it's a lottery to get in the final four anyway, so it's really the team the voters think is the better team

There are plenty examples of bad QBs winning the national championship,it is not an indicator of NFL talent 

 

[panthers55]

8 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

I honestly don't care about the first two criteria. You'd miss out on most of the greatest QBs in NFL history of you demanded to check all three boxes.

You know who else won a national championship, won the Heisman, played in the SEC and went number 1 in the draft? Yeah, Cam Newton and he is on Youngs side. Maye isn't even a consideration at this point.

[96Bravo]

I'd pick Young. Now if Maye absolutely kills it next season? Not sure.

[LinvilleGorge]

7 minutes ago, panthers55 said:

You know who else won a national championship, won the Heisman, played in the SEC and went number 1 in the draft? Yeah, Cam Newton and he is on Youngs side. Maye isn't even a consideration at this point.

Yeah, he did. You know who didn't? A poo ton of NFL HOFers.

The goal is t to draft a great college player. The goal is to draft a great NFL player.

[panthers55]

4 minutes ago, Day1PanthersFan said:

But it isn't an indicator of talent,means your overall team was better than the rest, and it's a lottery to get in the final four anyway, so it's really the team the voters think is the better team

There are plenty examples of bad QBs winning the national championship,it is not an indicator of NFL talent 

 

 But in this case Young did carry that team and brought out the best in everyone. Just because other folks with credentials fail doesn't mean credentials mean nothing or are useless. And iin Young's case it was an indication of his talent which overshadowed his height or build.

[Shocker]

28 minutes ago, Day1PanthersFan said:

Like that has ever mattered, there is a long list of draft busts that won the national title 

 

This just in Georgia has been incredible defensively and offensively for the last two seasons.  Some times the other guys are just better.  Georgia in 2021-2022 was one of the most talented teams in history.  Last season they were great.  The prior year they were not going to lose and Bryce almost beat them.

Edited April 27, 2023 by Shocker

[OldhamA]

30 minutes ago, panthers55 said:

Young because he won a national championship, played in the toughest division and is a great skilled player. 

Maye can only claim the third thing - he is a great skilled player.  Let's see how he plays next year...

Young was sat on the bench for that National Championship win, right?

[panthers55]

1 minute ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Yeah, he did. You know who didn't? A poo ton of NFL HOFers.

The goal is t to draft a great college player. The goal is to draft a great NFL player.

And the best indicator of the future is the past. Of course , the NFL is littered with great college qbs who couldn't replicate their success in the NFL. That includes Cam who almost won a Superbowl. So the best way to find a great NFL quarterback is watch the successful college ones and see if their skill sets match up with the system you are running. People erroneously think that if they aren't as good in the NFL they are underachieving when often it is bad marriage between the system and QB or other factors like revolving coaches and coordinators.

[panthers55]

6 minutes ago, OldhamA said:

Young was sat on the bench for that National Championship win, right?

Your point?

Edited April 27, 2023 by panthers55