HOLY CRAP! We drafted who???

[MHS831]

Name a time when you were totally wrong, when we drafted a player that just pissed you off at the time because you thought the player sucked or was not a need player, only to discover how wrong you were later.

I will be man enough to admit that I was PISSED when we drafted Jon Beason. Morgan was the man in the middle and I thought Beason was a second rounder. I think we had the 14th pick, that year, but traded it to NYJ.

I was also pissed when we drafted Ryan Kalil. I think Hartwig was the center and I thought the second round was too high for a Center.

[rodeo]

most people wanted a safety that year to replace Minter, but i remember Mayock had Beason as his #2 LB and had us drafting him at our original pick before we traded down. so i was happy.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

I thought drafting Clausen instead of a receiver was a horrible move. Also, Armanti would've dropped to AT LEAST the 5th round. Drafting him that high was stupid.

And I will be honest, I HATED the J-Stew pick. Everyone thought he would be the new starter with Foster gone, but I was a VERY strong believer in Williams before he even started.

[SorthNarolina]

I hated the Clausen pick.

I remember being confused about Stewart.

I remember hating the Sherrod martin pick because it said he was a safety on the TV. I wanted to draft Duke Robinson:eek:

Jon Beason was alright with me I remember not liking some scouting report said he thought he was better than he was.

[MWCarolina]

hated the LaFell pick (we could've had Shipley), hated the Edwards pick (for easy reasons), other than that, didnt have many problems with the others.

[Dilla]

I got pissed with Stewart pick, I didn't even think RB was on the radar. And I recall him being drafted requiring surgery on his foot. And I was upset when Sherrod Martin was picked when Sean Smith was available.

[SuperMan]

Name a time when you were totally wrong, when we drafted a player that just pissed you off at the time because you thought the player sucked or was not a need player, only to discover how wrong you were later.

I will be man enough to admit that I was PISSED when we drafted Jon Beason. Morgan was the man in the middle and I thought Beason was a second rounder. I think we had the 14th pick, that year, but traded it to NYJ.

I was also pissed when we drafted Ryan Kalil. I think Hartwig was the center and I thought the second round was too high for a Center.

Yeah the jets used it To draft Darrel revis.

We got beason and kalil in the deal.

[scarface]

How could you be pissed at drafting Beason because Morgan was at MLB??

He had missed like half the games of his career with injuries.

I've never hated a pick btw though I've hated some trading of picks.

[bigskypanthersguy]

Drafting Stewart when I wanted Oher made me furious. And then I thought I was hallucinating when we traded up to the 19th for Otah. And then I found out what we gave up, and got even more furious.

[SCMunnerlyn1]

I remember i was steaming mad in the 6th round of this years draft when we took pugh and gettis , while steve smith 2.0 ( looks wise muscular frame and even same basic face look ) Kyle williams was still there and low and behold he went 4 picks later to San Fran ..

Gettis proved me wrong .. pugh needs another year before we'll know, but the potential seems to be there ..

Another one was more of i was pissed at the luck of the draw.. 07 draft 2nd round Minnesota was picking ..mel kiper was talking all about dwayne jarrett and how he'd go there .. and i was like hell yes now WE can get Sidney Rice!! .. then hell broke lose , sidney was drafted and we drafted jarrett the very next pick.. and .. well you know how that turned out

[CharlotteBeer.com]

I thought drafting Clausen instead of a receiver was a horrible move. Also, Armanti would've dropped to AT LEAST the 5th round. Drafting him that high was stupid.

And I will be honest, I HATED the J-Stew pick. Everyone thought he would be the new starter with Foster gone, but I was a VERY strong believer in Williams before he even started.

Agreed.

[Brooklyn Bully]

Some of you aren't doing this right, as Clausen and Armanti haven't proven you wrong as poor picks yet.

For me it's the Cap'n. I was like, great a local shrimp. And he's turned out to be pretty damned decent.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Some of you aren't doing this right, as Clausen and Armanti haven't proven you wrong as poor picks yet.

For me it's the Cap'n. I was like, great a local shrimp. And he's turned out to be pretty damned decent.

True, but I still hated the picks.

[Mr. Scot]

- Kerry Collins over Steve McNair

- Tim Biakabutuka over Eddie George

- Jason Peter over Vonnie Holliday

- Chuck Wylie and Mitch Marrow over Leonard Little

- DeShaun Foster over Clinton Portis

Oh, you said times I was wrong (doh).

Not trying to brag, but I can't think of any draft picks I absolutely hated that wound up winning me over.