Damning indictment of Bryce Young

[kungfoodude]

58 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

I have no idea how anyone could watch Bryce play and come to an honest conclusion that he would "make more throws than" basically *insert name of another QB on an NFL roster*.

Dalton has literally made more throws over the same time period. And that isn't a glowing Andy endorsement. It's a damning statement about Bryce.

[TLGPanthersFan]

19 hours ago, NAS said:

Bryce Young - worst QB,  too short, noodle arm, rinse and repeat

 

Won’t stop until worst QB, noodle arm, too short is off the team. 

[TLGPanthersFan]

Bryce Young and Dalton give us equal chances to win and we have to pretty much play the same way if we want to be with both of them. 
 

[kungfoodude]

18 minutes ago, TLGPanthersFan said:

Bryce Young and Dalton give us equal chances to win and we have to pretty much play the same way if we want to be with both of them. 
 

I would say Dalton is Bryce +10-15%.

So, basically almost what you are saying.

[Carolina Cajun]

3 hours ago, CRA said:

Bryce has played a big role often in our losses. He can lose a game in the first quarter. 

I agree  too, I dont think though its because hes a gunslinger.  Dalton in the late part of his career can do that and it can lead to turnovers which could cost us.  Dalton needs to not try to go out and win the game, just manage the game.

[strato]

50 minutes ago, kungfoodude said:

I would say Dalton is Bryce +10-15%.

So, basically almost what you are saying.

Depends on which Dalton you get. We did this last year and I vouched for Dalton and he delivered. I don’t know what to think this year.
Not as confident, even thought the team around him is a little better I think. 

It’ll be all over but the crying in 24 hours. 

[Carolina Cajun]

3 hours ago, LinvilleGorge said:

I have no idea how anyone could watch Bryce play and come to an honest conclusion that he would "make more throws than" basically *insert name of another QB on an NFL roster*.

this is a disingenuous take.  Bryce isnt gonna blow yer mind with a 60 yard strike in stride like cam did to Ted Ginn vs the raiders (still one of the most impressive throws I've EVER seen, goes dramatically overlooked).  That said, something like his side arm tight window to legette last game is an impressive throw that I dont think Dalton makes AT THIS point in his career. 

Disclaimer: I am not a bryce dick rider.  He absolutely should have improved in SO many areas by now that he hasnt.  However, he is a middle tier QB in the NFL right now, denying that is just not being honest.  I would even agree he hasnt shown to be a franchise QB.  As of right now, his best comparable NFL qb to me is Alex smith.  A qb you'd be  alright having if he wasnt the #1 overall pick.

[LinvilleGorge]

Just now, Carolina Cajun said:

this is a disingenuous take.  Bryce isnt gonna blow yer mind with a 60 yard strike in stride like cam did to Ted Ginn vs the raiders (still one of the most impressive throws I've EVER seen, goes dramatically overlooked).  That said, something like his side arm tight window to legette last game is an impressive throw that I dont think Dalton makes AT THIS point in his career. 

Disclaimer: I am not a bryce dick rider.  He absolutely should have improved in SO many areas by now that he hasnt.  However, he is a middle tier QB in the NFL right now, denying that is just not being honest.  I would even agree he hasnt shown to be a franchise QB.  As of right now, his best comparable NFL qb to me is Alex smith.  A qb you'd be  alright having if he wasnt the #1 overall pick.

He's definitely not a mid-tie starting QB. Mid-tier among all rostered NFL QBs maybe.

[mrcompletely11]

10 minutes ago, Carolina Cajun said:

this is a disingenuous take.  Bryce isnt gonna blow yer mind with a 60 yard strike in stride like cam did to Ted Ginn vs the raiders (still one of the most impressive throws I've EVER seen, goes dramatically overlooked).  That said, something like his side arm tight window to legette last game is an impressive throw that I dont think Dalton makes AT THIS point in his career. 

Disclaimer: I am not a bryce dick rider.  He absolutely should have improved in SO many areas by now that he hasnt.  However, he is a middle tier QB in the NFL right now, denying that is just not being honest.  I would even agree he hasnt shown to be a franchise QB.  As of right now, his best comparable NFL qb to me is Alex smith.  A qb you'd be  alright having if he wasnt the #1 overall pick.

be just about every metric he is a bottom 3rd at best qb