Bryce Young is the worst QB in Panthers History

[TN05]

1 hour ago, CRA said:

Wilson only got 2 years. He was a backup going into year 3.  Easy to forget because the Aaron Rodgers era ….lasted a play lol.   

Folks got way more time in the era Carr played in than today.  Joey Harrington would be an example.  QBs no longer are afforded that.  Well, one now is. 

Joey Harrington had more turnovers than touchdowns in his first two seasons and never even sniffed 60% completion.

Bryce has at least shown some improvement through three years, and the team has gotten better each year.

[frankw]

37 minutes ago, TN05 said:

Joey Harrington had more turnovers than touchdowns in his first two seasons and never even sniffed 60% completion.

Bryce has at least shown some improvement through three years, and the team has gotten better each year.

FYI Bryce Young is sitting at 6.0 YPA for his career entering year 4. That's lower than David Carr just a hair under Blaine Gabbert and just a smidge above Joey Harrington.

https://www.pro-football-reference.com/leaders/pass_yds_per_att_career.htm

Buddy needs to get the ball downfield or get to steppin.

[CRA]

9 hours ago, TN05 said:

Joey Harrington had more turnovers than touchdowns in his first two seasons and never even sniffed 60% completion.

Bryce has at least shown some improvement through three years, and the team has gotten better each year.

Yeah, Harrington was an example I gave of a bad QB that got time.   You should of just left at that boss

what you are comparing them for? Different eras and times,  Harrington’s rookie year, league average was 59%.  League average today is 64%. Bryce didn’t get his above 60 until this year and is still below league average.   He and Harrington share that in common and you are highlighting it as Bryce being good lol.  
They are both BELOW and behind the league average. 

Bryce has improved and we are the 27th best O in the NFL thanks to his marginal improvement from horrific.  Go find a bad QB that got time…..and you would find people were claiming improvement lol.  They were doing it for Harrington then too.  

[CPcavedweller]

On 1/3/2026 at 7:37 PM, dep said:

The worst actual quarterback this franchise has ever committed to beyond a trial run or backup. 

Anyone who hasn't reached this conclusion is in denial at this point.

I’m probably the 100th person to say this but you must be new here. Bryce has his issues but he is far from the worst. Almost no QB in the NFL could have won that game against Tampa with how our run game looked. 

[carolinanimal]

1 hour ago, CPcavedweller said:

I’m probably the 100th person to say this but you must be new here. Bryce has his issues but he is far from the worst. Almost no QB in the NFL could have won that game against Tampa with how our run game looked. 

qbs win without run games all the time, especially franchise #1 picks. 

[Shotgun]

3 hours ago, TN05 said:

Joey Harrington had more turnovers than touchdowns in his first two seasons and never even sniffed 60% completion.

Bryce has at least shown some improvement through three years, and the team has gotten better each year.

Yes, Harrington is a good comp.

[strato]

Who, that wasn’t replaced after their horrible season, got another? Anybody? 
Weinke. Clausen. One year.
Who else even made it a season that was that bad? 
 

Edited yesterday at 05:39 AM by strato

[dep]

2 hours ago, CPcavedweller said:

I’m probably the 100th person to say this but you must be new here. Bryce has his issues but he is far from the worst. Almost no QB in the NFL could have won that game against Tampa with how our run game looked. 

you can see when a user joined but I see you have trouble reading regardless

[Car123]

13 hours ago, Shotgun said:

Show me a worse 3 year starter on any team ever. 

Jamarcus Russell? 
Jake Locker? 
Christian Ponder? 
Jay Fiedler?

There have been plenty. The hyperbole that comes from Bryce haters is wild.

[*FreeFua*]

I see the same usual suspects spending their time sh!tty on the QB instead of being excited about the playoffs

If only these casuals weren’t too stupid to understand analytics and the game as a whole

Miserable people 

[CRA]

6 hours ago, Shotgun said:

Yes, Harrington is a good comp.

It’s a great comp IMO.  He was bad, just like Bryce.  And the folks then kept saying the same thing…..if we can just add more around him he won’t stink.   it’s not his fault. Same folks were fixated on the most marginal improvement.   He had his big year 3 too lol. 

they even have the same parallels of BARELY surpassing 3k for the only time in year 3.  Only Joey wasn’t in the passing era then and their career comp % are pretty comparable at the time if you factor the  era difference. 

and we are trending very similar as that era of the Lions adding all the first round WRs trying to make the QB not stink 

[dep]

21 minutes ago, *FreeFua* said:

I see the same usual suspects spending their time sh!tty on the QB instead of being excited about the playoffs

If only these casuals weren’t too stupid to understand analytics and the game as a whole

Miserable people 

facts dont care about your feelings big dawg

[Shotgun]

48 minutes ago, Car123 said:

Jamarcus Russell? 
Jake Locker? 
Christian Ponder? 
Jay Fiedler?

There have been plenty. The hyperbole that comes from Bryce haters is wild.

No hate, those are good comps for Young though. 

[Car123]

5 minutes ago, Shotgun said:

No hate, those are good comps for Young though. 

No