Bryce Young is the worst QB in Panthers History

[CRA]

1 minute ago, frankw said:

I used to think the Panthers social media team just lacked awareness but the delusion is apparently by design.

If I worked for them I would have used the same picture and when I saw you….

[Mage]

15 hours ago, electro's horse said:

10.5 is ludicrous 

When the Panthers lose, they typically lose by double digits. This has been a betting trend for the last two years.

It’s a fair line. Because if you think the Panthers are gonna cover, you are better off just taking the ML based off precedent. 

[CRA]

8 minutes ago, Mage said:

When the Panthers lose, they typically lose by double digits. This has been a betting trend for the last two years.

It’s a fair line. Because if you think the Panthers are gonna cover, you are better off just taking the ML based off precedent. 

Think we lose by an average of 13.7 points when we do on the year.  

[Jackson113.2]

https://www.facebook.com/share/r/1asGZYuceN/

 

[Mage]

1 hour ago, CRA said:

Think we lose by an average of 13.7 points when we do on the year.  

It is even more jarring when you look at our losses to teams who are objectively good - 16 to the Jags, 29 to the Patriots, 31 to the Bills, 11 to the 49ers, 17 to the Seahawks.

Last year we had that 3-game stretch against the Chiefs, Eagles, and Bucs where we played some competitive football.  But you go outside of that stretch: 37 to the Saints, 23 to the Chargers, 10 to the Bengals, 26 to the Bears, 33 to the Commanders, 14 to the Broncos, 16 to the Cowboys, 34 to the Bucs.

[Mage]

I don't know about the worst QB in Panthers history.

But he is definitely the worst 2+ year starter, regardless of position, in our team history. 

[Jackie Lee]

17 minutes ago, Jackson113.2 said:

https://www.facebook.com/share/r/1asGZYuceN/

 

I hate that guy but he's not wrong on this lol. 

[Car123]

On 1/5/2026 at 8:14 AM, The Lobo said:

Right on cue. Thinks Herbert is overrated but Bryce is good just lacks weapons. Cam Ward outplayed Bryce with no one on his team and an interim coach. What are we doing here? 

In what aspect did Cam Ward outplay Bryce Young?

[Car123]

17 hours ago, DeAngelo Beason said:

He's most certainly the worst starter that we've fully committed to.  That's without doubt.  In that regard he's also one of the worst of all time in the whole league.  I can't think off the top of my head a team sticking with someone who is this much of a bum for this long.  He's utterly pathetic.

Jamarcus Russell, Ponder, Locker, Fielder. Many examples.

[Shotgun]

22 hours ago, *FreeFua* said:

Weeks 9-18

You people talk about Herbert likes he’s a top 5 QB in the league 
 

Since drafting Justin Herbert the chargers have drafted:

1st round RB: 1

3rd round RB: 1

1st round WR: 1

2nd round WR: 2

3rd round WR: 1

1st round OL: 3 (Two tackles and guard)

Playoffs wins: 0

When it’s just you and the same 4-5 going around pie’ing each others posts that should tell you something. 

 Yep he's 21st on this list which seems pretty accurate.

Player Name	Season	Team	Plays	Total EPA	EPA/Play	Pass EPA	Rush EPA	Scramble %	Sack %	Success %	ADoT	Comp %	Pass Yards	Time To Throw	Pass TD	INT	YPA	Rush Yards	Rush TD
1. Drake Maye	2025		642	169.96	0.26	159.80	10.16	10.32%	7.82%	52.96%	9.51	71.95%	4394	2.81	31	8	8.93	450	4
2. Jordan Love	2025		507	120.84	0.24	108.51	12.34	4.96%	4.34%	48.92%	9.42	66.29%	3381	2.72	23	6	7.70	199	0
3. Matthew Stafford	2025		649	109.09	0.17	140.93	-31.84	1.12%	3.67%	50.85%	9.34	64.99%	4707	2.64	46	8	7.88	1	0
4. Josh Allen	2025		612	104.43	0.17	65.66	38.77	9.09%	7.27%	48.86%	7.55	69.35%	3668	2.74	25	10	7.97	579	14
5. Patrick Mahomes	2025		600	96.25	0.16	67.09	29.16	9%	5.77%	49%	8.56	62.75%	3587	2.66	22	11	7.15	422	5
6. Dak Prescott	2025		684	94.09	0.14	103.52	-9.43	3.96%	4.72%	47.37%	8.23	67.33%	4552	2.67	30	10	7.59	177	2
7. Jared Goff	2025		635	92.04	0.14	106.46	-14.42	0.81%	6.12%	47.87%	6.82	67.99%	4564	2.54	34	8	7.90	45	0
8. Daniel Jones	2025		451	76.41	0.17	60.23	16.18	5.36%	5.13%	51%	8.24	67.97%	3101	2.55	19	8	8.08	164	5
9. Brock Purdy	2025		328	74.98	0.23	58.79	16.19	5.75%	3.51%	53.96%	7.90	69.37%	2167	3.01	20	10	7.63	147	3
10. Bo Nix	2025		717	63.64	0.09	55.23	8.41	5.37%	3.28%	43.93%	7.71	63.40%	3931	2.72	25	11	6.42	356	5
11. Trevor Lawrence	2025		683	60.67	0.09	34.88	25.79	6.53%	6.38%	47.73%	8.96	60.89%	4007	2.68	29	12	7.16	359	9
12. C.J. Stroud	2025		494	56.52	0.11	41.48	15.04	5.31%	4.88%	46.15%	8.47	64.54%	3041	2.68	19	8	7.19	209	1
13. Caleb Williams	2025		669	49.36	0.07	43.96	5.40	6.77%	3.78%	43.80%	9.33	58.10%	3942	3.03	27	7	6.94	383	3
14. Sam Darnold	2025		539	47.76	0.09	60.74	-12.97	2.70%	5.21%	51.02%	8.30	67.71%	4048	2.71	25	14	8.49	95	0
15. Jalen Hurts	2025		591	43.94	0.07	27.26	16.68	7.78%	6.07%	44.33%	9.54	64.76%	3224	2.80	25	6	7.10	421	8
16. Baker Mayfield	2025		634	33.88	0.05	-1.84	35.72	6.91%	5.79%	44.48%	8.34	63.17%	3693	2.71	26	11	6.80	382	1
17. Joe Burrow	2025		290	33.02	0.11	29.46	3.57	2.82%	5.99%	49.31%	7.53	66.80%	1809	2.67	17	5	6.98	41	0
18. Mac Jones	2025		341	32.87	0.10	38.13	-5.27	2.56%	5.11%	50.44%	7.64	69.55%	2151	2.58	13	6	7.44	60	0
19. Jaxson Dart	2025		460	29.83	0.06	-8.29	38.12	9.44%	8.47%	45.22%	8.45	63.72%	2272	2.66	15	5	6.70	487	9
20. Lamar Jackson	2025		405	27.04	0.07	6.43	20.61	8.40%	9.76%	45.93%	9.13	63.58%	2549	2.89	21	7	8.44	349	2
21. Justin Herbert	2025		649	19.35	0.03	4.51	14.84	7.97%	8.78%	46.84%	8.12	66.41%	3727	2.74	26	13	7.28	498	2
22. Aaron Rodgers	2025		548	11.16	0.02	14.11	-2.95	2.23%	5.38%	42.34%	6.39	65.66%	3322	2.46	24	7	6.67	61	1
23. Michael Penix	2025		310	4.94	0.02	-2.17	7.11	4.30%	4.30%	44.84%	8.71	60.14%	1982	2.70	9	3	7.18	70	1
24. Marcus Mariota	2025		293	3.64	0.01	-3.06	6.70	6.90%	6.13%	46.76%	10.93	61.23%	1695	2.72	10	7	7.47	297	1
25. Jacoby Brissett	2025		566	2.29	0	-5.17	7.46	4%	7.82%	45.76%	8.09	64.95%	3366	2.80	23	8	6.94	168	1
26. Tua Tagovailoa	2025		434	1.64	0	9.11	-7.47	2.59%	7.06%	43.78%	7.07	67.71%	2660	2.56	20	15	6.93	43	0
27. Jayden Daniels	2025		264	-3.13	-0.01	-5.83	2.70	15.57%	7.38%	45.08%	7.99	60.64%	1262	2.62	8	3	6.71	278	2
28. Kirk Cousins	2025		296	-6.09	-0.02	-3.60	-2.49	0.70%	4.58%	44.26%	7.33	61.71%	1721	2.59	10	5	6.40	7	1
29. Tyler Shough	2025		403	-7.42	-0.02	-7.39	-0.03	5.29%	8.20%	43.67%	8.60	67.58%	2384	2.54	10	6	7.29	186	3
30. Bryce Young	2025		559	-17.02	-0.03	-21.19	4.17	5.96%	5.03%	42.58%	6.99	63.60%	3011	2.70	23	11	6.30	216	2
31. Justin Fields	2025		302	-18.01	-0.06	-24.66	6.66	10.81%	10.42%	44.37%	7.11	62.75%	1259	2.71	7	1	6.17	383	4
32. Spencer Rattler	2025		306	-26.65	-0.09	-36.24	9.59	5.50%	6.19%	46.41%	8.29	67.70%	1586	2.54	8	5	6.17	167	0
33. Joe Flacco	2025		455	-45.56	-0.10	-50.98	5.42	0.91%	4.11%	41.10%	7.89	60.34%	2479	2.57	15	10	5.96	35	1
34. J.J. McCarthy	2025		307	-46.46	-0.15	-53.26	6.80	5.92%	9.41%	41.04%	9	57.61%	1632	2.82	11	12	6.72	181	4
35. Shedeur Sanders	2025		256	-59.50	-0.23	-70.23	10.73	7.11%	9.09%	36.72%	7.82	56.60%	1400	3.09	7	10	6.60	169	1
36. Geno Smith	2025		544	-74.70	-0.14	-73.03	-1.67	3.45%	10.56%	41.91%	6.46	67.41%	3025	2.61	19	17	6.75	109	0
37. Cameron Ward	2025		634	-104.76	-0.17	-113.25	8.49	3.72%	8.90%	37.85%	7.81	59.81%	3169	2.82	15	7	5.87	159	2

 

 

[The Lobo]

12 minutes ago, Car123 said:

In what aspect did Cam Ward outplay Bryce Young?

I already answered it in the post you are quoting. Did more with way less. 

[Car123]

8 minutes ago, The Lobo said:

I already answered it in the post you are quoting. Did more with way less. 

Dumb logic. Should Bryce be ahead of quarterbacks ahead of him because they have better weapons?

[The Lobo]

3 minutes ago, Car123 said:

Dumb logic. Should Bryce be ahead of quarterbacks ahead of him because they have better weapons?

Threw for more yards with a way worse situation, as a rookie. Hit 3k before Bryce did…in year three. 

[SmokinwithWilly]

26 minutes ago, Car123 said:

Jamarcus Russell, Ponder, Locker, Fielder. Many examples.

Not a good list. None of these guys started more games in their 1st 3 seasons than Bryce has and Fielder was a starter for almost 2 full seasons as the longest. 

Edited yesterday at 04:22 PM by SmokinwithWilly