Another hypothetical Bryce poll

[OldhamA]

6 hours ago, Navy_football said:

Now come on. So Bryce Young offers no value to this offense? Ever? Come on PNW. I think Bryce Young would be a much more successful player if he was drafted by Philly. 

I'd love to see Young run a 'tush push'.

[csx]

3 minutes ago, OldhamA said:

I'd love to see Young run a 'tush push'.

They could toss him over

[Waldo]

13 hours ago, Navy_football said:

So you think Hurts took Philly to the Super Bowl then, right? 

I disagree. I think he was a passenger but he wasn't driving the ship. 

At least he is carryable is the point. The Panthers can't even carry Bryce to a winning record. 

[Waldo]

7 hours ago, csx said:

They could toss him over

[strato]

7 hours ago, OldhamA said:

Why is everyone getting so up in arms about this?

OP provided two extreme solutions. Short term success, sacrificing long term benefits or the reverse.

There are shades of grey in life, which this poll doesn't account for.

It isn’t everybody. It is the faction akin to those that brought us threads where you could only say positive things about Bryce. 

It is a troll poll anyway. There is no such reality where the options  given in this poll will ever influence Bryce Young’s future or the Panthers’ future. 

Drama

 

edit I said that wrong, the lose option is really the one that is not realistic. They have made their decision already, pretty sure. 

Edited yesterday at 02:28 PM by strato

[Navy_football]

Yall are a little unrealistic. This is the first time in his 3 years that this QB has had a roster they could actuallyt win with - and we're in the playoffs. No one to throw to and the worst interior oline this franchise has ever fielded as a rookie. Defense was meh but would get worse. Second season Derrick Brown gets injured for the year in the first game and we march out the worst run defense (and possibly overall defense) in the history of the NFL. So many on here talking about an average QB would have this team with 12+ wins. You're delusional. How many games would we have won last season with just an average defense? KC, Philly and the first TB games off the top of my head. And that's with Thielen as your best receiver, rookie XL and rookie Coker. David Moore was the second best receiver last season. David Moore. This season the defense has improved but we're lining up too many rookies to make it to the playoffs on both sides of the ball, yet here we are. I ain't saying Bryce Young is the answer, but he has been a big part of some big wins this season. I'm hopeful that we'll see improvement when he has more time with this very young receiving corp. Remember, they're learnig how to be pros at the same time as we're going to the playoffs. The only veteran receiving  presence we've had this year is Tommy Tremble. We could actually see big improvement if David Moore comes back healthy. And that is saying alot. 

[Tr3ach]

8 hours ago, OldhamA said:

Why is everyone getting so up in arms about this?

OP provided two extreme solutions. Short term success, sacrificing long term benefits or the reverse.

There are shades of grey in life, which this poll doesn't account for.

Thanks, yea the very specific black and white extremes were intentional.   I know there are way more scenarios in between.  It was more to gauge overall  extreme perceptions of the team going forward and bryce young. 

[Shotgun]

I think most of us know that we're going to get the worst of both worlds.  A humiliating loss and another year of watching an abomination at QB.   

[strato]

14 hours ago, csx said:

They could toss him over

Need help with the date there but it is almost there. 

1 hour ago, Shotgun said:

I think most of us know that we're going to get the worst of both worlds.  A humiliating loss and another year of watching an abomination at QB.   

That is what I am expecting. Hoping not and know we could be wrong. Still if I am honest…. 

They will need to play well or things could really go south in the stadium after the anticipation and pregame with the stars jacks everyone up as high as I think it will. 

[DeAngelo Beason]

As badly as I cannot stand Bryce Young, I will always want a Panthers victory in a game as meaningful as this.  If we are in the middle of a tank season then I definitely advocate for losses, but if there is meaningful football to be played, I'm pulling for wins.