Top qbs in the nfl five years from now

[CatfanMO]

Think you forgot Vick. Also there is a bunch of potential for guys like Kolb, Matt Flynn, Colt McCoy.

1. Rodgers

2. Bradford

3. Ryan

4. Luck

5. Vick

6. McCoy

7. Rivers

8. Freeman

9. Young (if he ever gets his head on straight)

10.Kolb

[thefuzz]

Think you forgot Vick. Also there is a bunch of potential for guys like Kolb, Matt Flynn, Colt McCoy.

1. Rodgers

2. Bradford

3. Ryan

4. Luck

5. Vick

6. McCoy

7. Rivers

8. Freeman

9. Young (if he ever gets his head on straight)

10.Kolb

Not forgetting Vick at all. He was drafted in 2001, and is more of a mobile QB than a pocket passer. He will have some majore injury problems later in his career.

P.S. I hope this is not a ranking, but merely a list.

[CatfanMO]

Not forgetting Vick at all. He was drafted in 2001, and is more of a mobile QB than a pocket passer. He will have some majore injury problems later in his career.

P.S. I hope this is not a ranking, but merely a list.

Yeah, it is really hard to rank them. I took the same list approach.

[Evil Hurney]

I'll do you one better. I'll rank the full 32 :D

(Note that before you flame, I considered the age of the player in 5 years, where the might be in their development, and how good the team is on average)

First I looked at every teams current depth chart and tried to determine who their starter might be in 5 years assuming no roster changes and no injuries. Here is that ranked list:

1 ….. Rodgers ….. Packers

2 ….. Rivers ….. Chargers

3 ….. Ryan ….. Falcons

4 ….. Rothlisberger ….. Steelers

5 ….. Flacco ….. Ravens

6 ….. Bradford ….. Rams

7 ….. Stafford ….. Lions

8 ….. Cutler ….. Bears

9 ….. Freeman ….. Bucs

10 ….. Manning ….. Giants

11 ….. Sanchez ….. Jets

12 ….. Kolb ….. Eagles

13 ….. Whitehurst ….. Seahawks

14 ….. Schaub ….. Texans

15 ….. Henne ….. Dolphins

16 ….. Brees ….. Saints

17 ….. Cassel ….. Chiefs

18 ….. Clausen ….. Panthers

19 ….. McCoy ….. Browns

20 ….. The Golden Calf of Bristol ….. Broncos

21 ….. Hoyer ….. Patriots

22 ….. A. Smith ….. 49ers

23 ….. Romo ….. Cowboys

24 ….. LeFevour ….. Bengals

25 ….. Edwards ….. Jaguars

26 ….. Gradkowski ….. Raiders

27 ….. Brohm ….. Bills

28 ….. Skelton ….. Cardinals

29 ….. Webb ….. Vikings

30 ….. Simms ….. Titans

31 ….. Grossman ….. Redskins

32 ….. Painter ….. Colts

Then I projected the top 5 qb's from the next two drafts (2011 and 2012), moved the best of the displaced players, and updated the rankings. Changes are in bold.

1 ….. Rodgers ….. Packers

2 ….. Rivers ….. Chargers

3 ….. Ryan ….. Falcons

4 ….. Luck ….. 49ers

5 ….. Rothlisberger ….. Steelers

6 ….. Flacco ….. Ravens

7 ….. Bradford ….. Rams

8 ….. Gabbert ….. Panthers

9 ….. Stafford ….. Lions

10 ….. Cutler ….. Bears

11 ….. Freeman ….. Bucs

12 ….. Jones ….. Redskins

13 ….. Manning ….. Giants

14 ….. Clausen ….. Colts

15 ….. Sanchez ….. Jets

16 ….. Barkley ….. Raiders

17 ….. Locker ….. Vikings

18 ….. Kolb ….. Eagles

19 ….. Newton ….. Bills

20 ….. Mallet ….. Titans

21 ….. Dalton ….. Cardinals

22 ….. Whitehurst ….. Seahawks

23 ….. Schaub ….. Texans

24 ….. Henne ….. Dolphins

25 ….. Brees ….. Saints

26 ….. Cousins ….. Jaguars

27 ….. Cassel ….. Chiefs

28 ….. Pryor ….. Bengals

29 ….. McCoy ….. Browns

30 ….. The Golden Calf of Bristol ….. Broncos

31 ….. Hoyer ….. Patriots

32 ….. Romo ….. Cowboys

[sharkman]

18 ….. Clausen ….. Panthers

14 ….. Clausen ….. Colts

Wow. You're a much smarter football man than I. I certainly didn't see anything (yes, one year...blah blah) that leads me to believe he will even be in the league 5 years from now.

[jramsey4]

1. Rogers

2. Luck

3. Stanzi (got a feeling he's going to the Pats)

4. Freeman

5. Newton (I could see him going either way. Awesome or outta the league)

6. Stafford (assuming he can stay Healthy)

7. Bradford

8. Kolb (if he stays with the Eagles)

9. Mccoy

10. The Golden Calf of Bristol

[Zithers]

Aaron Rodgers

Peyton Manning

Tom Brady

Josh Freeman

Ben Roethlisberger

Philip Rivers

Sam Bradford

Matt Ryan

Matt Stafford

HM: Drew Brees, Joe Flacco - and Andrew Luck if we were using prospects.

[Verge]

1. Newton

2. Newton

3. Newton

4. Newton

5. Newton

6. Newton

7. Newton

8. Newton

9. Newton

[Ohio]

1. Rogers

2. Rivers

3. Bradford

4. Big Ben

5. Mallett

Keep hating

[Grammer]

aaron godgers will take all 10 spots

[Wither]

All I can say is that Newton will not be one of them.

[Catalyst]

01. Aaron Rodgers

02. Andrew Luck

03. Philip Rivers

04. Drew Brees

05. Josh Freeman

06. Ben Roethlisberger

07. Cam Newton

08. Matt Ryan

09. Sam Bradford

10. Colin Kaepernick

[Hoenheim]

haha, that would be messed up if luck ends up a star qb...there would be endless references on how we missed on the greatest qb because he didn't declare for the draft

[Ja Rhule]

01. Aaron Rodgers

02. Andrew Luck

03. Philip Rivers

04. Drew Brees

05. Josh Freeman

06. Ben Roethlisberger

07. Eli Manning

08. Matt Ryan

09. Sam Bradford

10. Brat Favre