Better Panthers receiver: Smitty or Moose?

[Jackofalltrades]

Smith and it's no where close.

I'd like to Smith the Panthers as the receiving leader.

[DaveThePanther2008]

Hell Moose would be ahead of Smitty in TD's if he hadn't of drop 25 TD passes.

[OchoNueve]

I love how once the Moose-lovers realized this was going to be a landslide vote for Smitty, they started attacking #89's character...

[Jackofalltrades]

Character has nothing to do with it.

[CBDellinger]

Smitty and it's not even close nor thread worthy.

[Porn Shop Clerk]

You left out Moose's 85 yard TD in the Superbowl.

[JJlovesthePanthers]

I love Moose, was sad to see him retire. But definitely Smitty!

[Pox 08]

Smith.

I look at it as, If both were in their prime, which would be better? I think Smith was.

[boo7382]

also don't forget Moose has only been in trouble once, when he was found with weed and a gun in his car. No one even remembers that.

Smith almost killed two team mates and got busted for pills.

lol@ almost killed 2 teammates.

punching a teammate in the face>>>>>>>>plotting to kill your pregnant gf

Ricky Proehl did good things.

Mark Carrier had a few moments.

agreed. always loved Proehl and I am happy he will be back this year. Hopefully he can help out Gettis and develop him into the great receiver he seems like he could be.

Would Smith have become the receiver he was without Moose?

very good point. touche jim, touche.

Most athletic receiver- Smitty

Most willing to leave it on the field- Smitty

Makes those around him better- Moose

Mentor and teammate- Moose

Both have their upsides and downsides.

Very true. Moose does a lot for charity around Charlotte as well. He's a big philanthropist.

I really hope Gettis/LaFell can become as good as Smitty/Moose

I hope this too, but if LaFell can't get his hands around the ball, that might be a problem.

Smith and it's no where close.

I'd like to Smith the Panthers as the receiving leader.

I would love to see this too, but seeing as it hasn't happened yet and he wants out, I doubt it will come to fruition. He's had his chance and obv didn't care to take it.

[Easyt65]

Who is better at WHAT?

Smitty, in his prime, was/is one of the most dangerous, electrifying, CB-frightening WRs ever...IMO. Moose, again IMO, is one of the better blocking, posession WRs; however, you have to remember the year Smitty was out - Moose led the league in almost all WR categories. (Of course it was a 'Pay Day year). Together, they were one of - if not THE - best WR tandems this franchise has ever had.

[Wither]

Smitty is the best player to we've ever had.

How is this even a question?

He's trying to get everyone all excited. ;)

[Dpantherman]

Fiz likes to see the huddle go ape poo ;)

[CatMan72]

Is this even a legitimate question?

I love Moose, but there's no comparison.

[bigdog10]

I'd say Smith, but Moose's 16 TD season was un-real. it seemed like he got the majority of those TD's in the 2nd half of the season (or 2nd half of the 49ers game for that matter)