Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Rants Sports Scouting Report: Benjamin and Coleman


top dawg

Recommended Posts

Patrick Karraker of Rants Sports provided scouting reports on these two trees (Benjamin and Coleman). I suggest that you read both.  So as not to blow sunshine up our collective asses (as tends to happen sometimes regarding draft prospects), I decided to emphasize the negatives. Most people here are salivating over Benjamin who had the much better championship year, but Coleman may be available later in the draft. A lot is going to depend on the Combine and team workouts, but it would definitely be nice to draft either of these guys as a value pick (round 3/4). Most of us are thinking that Cam would benefit from a skyscraper being that Cam is tall and throws high at times, and that is food for thought, but perhaps neither will be our next WR1.  Not trying to be funny, but we do have Marvin McNutt waiting in the wings, so I'm sure that the FO will be questioning whether these guys are so different than him. But it is nice to dream, and I am hopeful. 

 

 

 

 

On the flip side, there are plenty of aspects of Benjamin’s playing style which leave something to be desired. He’s not the fastest receiver in the world and has been projected to run around a 4.6 40-yard dash. More importantly, though, he has displayed a lack of effort which could test the patience of his coaches, teammates, and fans if he doesn’t make a change in his approach. He often looks as if he is jogging through routes, he doesn’t always give all he has when he’s trying to break away from defensive backs, and he drops balls that should be easy catches purely because he slows down while running towards the ball.

Read more at http://www.rantsports.com/nfl/2013/12/27/2014-nfl-draft-scouting-report-florida-state-wr-kelvin-benjamin/?oVHS16JhP2ThRFaW.99

 

 

 

 

 

Coleman also needs to prove during the build-up to the draft that he is not going to be permanently affected by a seemingly minor knee procedure that he underwent last offseason. His production dipped significantly in 2013, and he was said to be affected by the ailment during the season. Interested teams will undoubtedly be hoping that Coleman’s issues were more of a matter of him being limited during his preseason preparation than they were sustained pain.
Read more at http://www.rantsports.com/nfl/2014/01/18/2014-nfl-draft-scouting-report-rutgers-wr-brandon-coleman/?JUrWyIwdIr7Cvxxc.99

 

 

 

 

Kevin Benjamin:

 

 

Positives

  • Big, athletic body
  • Positions himself well to make tough catches
  • Nearly impossible to take down once he gets into the open field
  • Long arms allow him to stretch for balls that most receivers wouldn’t get to
  • With only three years each of high school and college experience, still has the ability to improve significantly

Negatives

  • Doesn’t fully use his size to his advantage when getting off the line; needs to be more physical when he is battling defensive backs to get open
  • Lackadaisical, sluggish running style
  • Effort seems inconsistent; looks like he’s jogging through some routes
  • Catching skills need to be improved
  • Over-aged; two years less developed than players who are a year or two younger than him

 

  •  

 

Brandon Coleman:

  •  

    Positives

    • Massive; will be one of the biggest wideouts in the NFL
    • While his breakaway speed is not elite, he has enough of it that he can combine it with his physicality and long stride to get yards after the catch
    • Legitimate deep threat; great perception on long passes allows him to be in the right spot to make the catch
    • Strong and resilient in the end zone
    • Long, smooth stride
    • Surprisingly elusive for a player of his size

    Negatives

    • Hands are inconsistent
    • Catching skills still need a lot of work, catches too many balls close to his chest
    • Not a great route runner
    • Concerns about lasting effects from his 2013 offseason knee surgery

     


    Read more at http://www.rantsports.com/nfl/2014/01/18/2014-nfl-draft-scouting-report-rutgers-wr-brandon-coleman/?JUrWyIwdIr7Cvxxc.99
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Over-aged; two years less developed than players who are a year or two younger than him

 

 

This sentence is hard to digest.  Does this mean he is 2 years under developed or Is he 2 years less developed than people 2 years younger than him meaning he is a total of 4 years behind?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I want to caution everyone from falling in love with Benjamin. he has some major effect issue and before the miami game the canes made a tape just about how many plays Benjamin takes off apparently it was pretty damn long. 

 

You don't say... 

 

Before I started looking up these scouting reports, I was admittedly a Coleman guy (which I still am provided his knee is fine), but after being bombarded with Benjamin after Benjamin after Benjamin in the Huddle (and I ain't talkin' money), I just had to look up some reports to see why he is so hyped to the point of being a 28th pick prospect in many eyes, and compare him to Coleman.  I didn't know that Benjamin was older or that he had questions about his work ethic. I have a raised eyebrow I'll tell ya, especially when I'm thinking that Coleman may ultimately turn out to be the better prospect.

 

I'm afraid that the whole discussion may be useless as both these guys, who really rate too low at this point to be taken at 28, will be gone by the time we pick in the second. But, I also know that they could fall (with the nature of the draft being what it is), the more likely being Coleman because of Benjamin's hype. 

 

I would absolutely curse the football gods if the Saints snap up Coleman in the second as Karraker projects in his early mock.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This sentence is hard to digest.  Does this mean he is 2 years under developed or Is he 2 years less developed than people 2 years younger than him meaning he is a total of 4 years behind?

 

I am taking it to mean, in a literal sense, that Benjamin is at the stage of development of a normal-aged WR, coming out at age 21(perhaps 22) as most of them do because he is 24. So basically his career is going to be virtually two years shorter than most of the younger guys coming out this year. 

 

In the grand scheme of things, I suppose that it could make a little difference towards the middle to end of his career, but I don't see it as a deal breaker.  If he breaks out at 27/28 years old as opposed to 25/26, who cares? I guess it could matter on some level.  If he comes out balling immediately, then he'd be 23, whereas most of the guys will be 20 or 21. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • The bottom line is we saw long stretches this season where T-Mac wasn't even targeted.  He had games where he went an entire half without seeing a pass thrown his way, and it lead to a bunch of games with 5 or less targets.  If he's healthy and we're not up a stupid amount and only running the ball, I can't see him having more than a game or two next year with 5 or less targets. We were also only 22nd this year in pass attempts, and that was with a rookie #1 and no legitimate 2nd option for half the season.  And even then, we were only 46 pass attempts above 31st place. If we go into next season with T-Mac improved in his 2nd season and a healthy Coker for 17 games, there is absolutely no reason for us to not throw it more.  That right away increases both of their target totals without sacrificing any targets from each other or other players, add in them taking targets from the TEs and RBs on top of that, and your argument just doesn't hold water anymore. You can't look at targets/yards in a vacuum and think next year Coker just takes some from T-Mac.  You have to look at the team as a whole and our situations this year and then project what will happen next year. If he's healthy for 17 games, I'd bet my life savings that T-Mac sees increases across the board, targets/catches/yards/TDs.   Just as Coker will also see career highs in all categories, it's not one vs the other, it's shifting offensive strategy given our personnel, which next year will be much better for our passing game (QB issues aside).
    • C'mon now.... First, you can't switch up your argument once someone points out a major flaw in your point. You're saying we shouldn't expect a big increase in targets/yards for T-Mac, but then shift to talking about averages with Chase when I point out the significant leap he took there once you factor in his missing games.  He saw an increase in targets in 5 less games, averages aside, he saw a significant increase in targets in his 2nd season, what he then did with those targets is actually irrelevant in this discussion. Puka seeing no increase is pointless, as he saw such an absurd amount of targets for a rookie, it's near impossible to see an increase. But the real issue in this post is that you think I'm proving your point by showing how Waddle had to share targets with Hill. Tyreek Hill was a 1st team All Pro who was 2nd in the NFL in yards that season. If you think Jaylen Waddle sharing targets with a 1st team All Pro and a future HOFer is even remotely in the same category as T-Mac needing to share targets with Coker... then you are certifiably insane, lol. If anything, you could make the argument that Coker is to Waddle as T-Mac is to Hill in that discussion (which would then lead to a serious increase in targets/yards for T-Mac).  But even that is insane, as neither T-Mac or Coker will be as good as Hill and Waddle respectively that season.  I love both of their potential, but c'mon now, T-Mac isn't getting 119 catches for 1,700 yards and Coker isn't getting 117 for 1,350 next season.
×
×
  • Create New...