Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Gettleman's biggest weakness IMO


Recommended Posts

So, we all know Gettleman and his crew can draft.  If we look back over the past 3 years, no one in the league has been better.  

 

However, Gettleman is atrocious at gauging other teams interest in a prospect.  This causes him to consistently draft players based on his perceived value, and not the league consensus value.  He wastes draft picks trading up for players who more than likely would have been available. And takes players rounds early.

 

We can never be certain of this however.  With the players off the board, we can never be certain they wouldn't have been swipped and we can only see the "media experts" draft boards.  But, I hope Gman gets a better handle on this in the future.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You won't make it in life worrying about what other people think.  GMan has the gumption to stick to this beliefs when the tide is against him.  You have to do you and let it play out.  There's a ying and a yang to everything; with him there's a whole lot more good than bad.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, Leeroy Jenkins PhD said:

So, we all know Gettleman and his crew can draft.  If we look back over the past 3 years, no one in the league has been better.  

 

However, Gettleman is atrocious at gauging other teams interest in a prospect.  This causes him to consistently draft players based on his perceived value, and not the league consensus value.  He wastes draft picks trading up for players who more than likely would have been available. And takes players rounds early.

 

We can never be certain of this however.  With the players off the board, we can never be certain they wouldn't have been swipped and we can only see the "media experts" draft boards.  But, I hope Gman gets a better handle on this in the future.

And just how do you know this "league consensus value"? G-Mans "perceived value" is based on a draft board the Panthers spent a couple of million dollars building. Basically fan and media boards are crap.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Worley could've been picked in the 3rd. Pick 62 is barely a round 2 pick....and I really don't get the Bradberry thing but the other guys that were avail weren't home runs. Kendall Fullers knee is fuged. This Laraven Clark guy was one of the worst OT I've ever seen at the Senior Bowl. Braxton Miller is Armanti Edwards with a bum shoulder. I would've rather had Jeremy Cash or Austin Hooper at 62, but ultimately fans like us and the Mayocks and Kipers of the world don't know true value of guys. It truly doesn't matter where other teams rank guys man, there's 32 teams, it only takes one to take your player.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One the one hand, I think you make a really great point and I wish Gettleman wouldn't trade up for some prospects who would very likely be there when we picked anyways.

On the other hand: I think Gettleman is going about this the right way. If you like a guy, go get him and forget what people think (mama taught me that years ago...)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm still trying to gauge why people considers last years draft some huge success? Last season was the first time in forever none of our rookies were even the race for ROY.

Till this day I still say we reached on Shaq and Funchess. Shaq won't even become a full time starter till 2 or 3 years, Funchess couldn't beat out Cotchery.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And what if some team "reached" and scooped up the exact same players, causing Gettleman to REALLY start scrambling. Gettleman went out and got who he wanted on his terms instead of hoping another team doesn't pick them up. It only takes one team to take your player and I have a good feeling it happened tons before our picks so Gettleman just said fug it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If some team is willing to trade UP to draft a KICKER in round 2, then Gettleman can't trust the other 31 GMs to know what their doing and put the same value Gettleman does on players. Quite frankly, that's how he can find players like KK and Trai Turner in the 2nd and 3rd rounds

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if the panthers used all their draft picks this year, realistically, not all of them would've made the 53

trading lower round picks to get guys that you really like seems like good business to me

and does "league consensus value" mean anything when guys like dimitrioff are in that consensus?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • If you think the NFL or NBA are worried about lawsuits or something like officiating scandals bringing down their empires, I think you're giving them way too much credit.  Go watch the documentary on Tim Donaghy in the NBA and who was involved and what he did.  One of the guys he worked with is still one of the league's top trusted officials, especially for playoff games.  IIRC, they have records showing he was the person Donaghy exchanged phone calls with the most during his time fixing games.  And his reputation is beyond horrible...  but he's untouchable.  I also encourage you to go watch DeMaurice Smith's Breakfast Club interview.  He laid out how for fans, we just know these organizations as a singular, public entity - like THE Carolina Panthers, or THE Dallas Cowboys- but, in actuality, he said that is the public-facing identity of an umbrella company comprised of countless smaller businesses and LLCs.  He is tasked with trying to audit their books, and he said these organizations are structured in such a way that even HE can't ever know what they truly make in a year.  It's impossible.  And now, this is just me speculating on top of that, but you think the league's themselves are structured similarly?  They are untouchable.  IIRC, they are recognized legally as "entertainment" organizations, thus protecting themselves in cases where integrity would come into question.  They are protected, layer, behind layer, behind layer.  Betting works because there is some degree of control that ensures the house wins more than it loses, by a lot.  The short of it is, "Give them bread and circuses" and all that jazz.  These leagues operate with total impunity.  Again, it's not just because I'm a Panthers fan, but even if I wasn't and I watched Superbowl 50 without a dog in the fight I would walk away feeling like that outcome was controlled and influenced HEAVILY to where the Panthers were not given a level playing field.  The same poo happens every Sunday to teams playing those blue blood franchises and ones with intriguing storylines. 
    • This Chuba isn't getting traded, but Rico very well could be in a few weeks if he keeps playing well in a tandem backfield with Chuba also playing well. I think we'd end up going with a two headed monster in that case, but with Rico being on a one year deal, it does open up the possibility of a contending team offering up a decent pick for him.  Depending on the recovery of Hampton, I could see someone like the Chargers giving us a 4th for him if they think he could put them over the top, he would fit nicely in a Harbaugh system I think. If it comes to that, we need to make that trade, as I can't see any way we re-sign Rico with all our other needs and getting Brooks back too.  And he's not going to get a contract big enough to get us any comp picks in return, especially if/when we sign a FA or two ourselves.  So if we're not going to bring him back, the prudent decision would really be to get a draft pick for him at the deadline.
    • It's all about what they do at QB. It's clear the rest of the roster is improving. If they commit long term to Young because he's being carried to wins then we're fuged. I think that's a separate issue to finally being competitive again.  There's no QB in this Draft that's going to ride in on his white horse on day one and save us, so we absolutely shouldn't be playing for Draft position. 
×
×
  • Create New...