If Your Life Depended On It....Cam, Russ or Carr?

[thefuzz]

Each are really different QB's.

 

Honestly, it would depend on what team is surrounding each, and who my coordinators are.....gun to my head though, and I will live and die with Cam at this point out of those 3.

[My Goodness My Guinness]

And why is Derek Carr an option here?

[truthjuice]

Bait, bait, bait. 

[Jangler]

I'd have to know which is the most generous lover to give an honest answer.

[Bronn]

45 minutes ago, TheRed said:

Part of that magical luck goes by the name of Doug Baldwin.

see Jake Delhomme to Steve Smith

[The Question]

Cam.


Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[The Question]

Also, I have to add, Carr or Wilson behind this OL with little to no run game to speak of.

It's really obvious that some people here truly lack a very basic understanding of football or team sport in general.

THIS. Anyone who doesn't choose Cam is a casual football fan at best and shouldn't think otherwise or they should be punched.


Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[Cookie Lyon]

2 hours ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Forever this fanbase has yearned for a legit franchise NFL QB. Now that we have one, we consistently prove that we never deserved one to begin with.

PREACH

[SmokinwithWilly]

It all depends on what type of offense you are wanting to run. 

Carr fits the manager role best. He's going to kill you with his arm, not his feet. 

Wilson is the best improviser of the 3. He's more elusive than Cam imo, though Cam is harder to bring down. Part of that is due to the angel that seems to sit on the football every time he throws up a duck. 

Cam is the dual threat QB. He can run it, he can throw it. But the downside of Cam is his flamboyance, swag, ego, whatever you want to call it, has pissed off a lot of people, mainly refs. He doesn't get the protection other QBs get and he is asked to take more hits than any other QB in the league under our offense. This will lead to a shorter career IMO. 

If we are going to get an OC that will build an offense around Cam instead of trying to have Cam be everything, then I'll take Cam. If we are going to keep letting Shula beat Cam into the ground, then I'll take another QB. I don't want to see Cam's career cut short because Shula keeps using him as a RB. 

[Boxhead85]

Can we stop replying to this BS thread? It doesn't deserve this much attention.

[Malt Liquor]

Cam Newton all day any day. Carr is not that good and Russell Wilson is a straight up cornball.

[CRA]

4 hours ago, RickyManningJr said:

If you are coaching an NFL team and had to win a game with your life on the line who would you choose all things being equal????!!!

 

I would honestly take Cam last and am not sure between Carr and Russ Wilson.

 

Hate to say it, but it is the truth.

Depends what all things be equal means.   Weak OL and weak ground attack?  Cam all day.

Great OL, great run game?  I might lean Carr over the other two just as a pure passer because that is all I am going to do with him.

[Malt Liquor]

5 minutes ago, CRA said:

Depends what all things be equal means.   Weak OL and weak ground attack?  Cam all day.

Great OL, great run game?  I might lean Carr over the other two just as a pure passer because that is all I am going to do with him.

Dude Derrick Carr looked like hotshit in Mexico last nite. Burrito style. Cam 1st, Russell 2nd.

[CRA]

4 minutes ago, Malt Liquor said:

Dude Derrick Carr looked like hotshit in Mexico last nite. Burrito style. Cam 1st, Russell 2nd.

 

Depends on the situation.  I wouldn't rank any positional group 1-10 and want that ranking to apply to all scenarios.