Are you comfortable with the roster?

[UpstatePanther]

Forgive the very basic, 10-minute excel chart, but i think its about as clear as i could make it. Just curious for the thoughts and discussion. Not considering the draft, would you be comfortable taking this roster into 2017? In other words, if the Panthers decided to sit out the draft and not take ANY rookies, would this roster be enough to get us to the playoffs?

Personally, I think so. And that is very exciting. I dont think we would sniff 15-1 with this roster, but 12 games is not out of the question, IMHO.

and the most exciting part is that we have 4 picks in the top 98 to add starting-level talent to this roster to compete for spots. 

I am officially excited for the 2017 season, my friends. What say you?

[h0llywood]

I haven't been this excited about our roster going into the Draft in a long long time.

[La Pantera]

Not comfortable with WR or Oline  depth.

 

[Bartin]

I'm very comfortable with it going into the draft. I would not be comfortable with it going into the season.

[UpstatePanther]

1 minute ago, La Pantera said:

Not comfortable with WR or Oline  depth.

1 minute ago, Bartin said:

I'm very comfortable with it going into the draft. I would not be comfortable with it going into the season.

i understand those sentiments. Personally, i think our receiving corps will be much improved this year and that Oher will come back and ball out. if he was really still dealing with his concussion, they would have worked out an injury settlement with him already and moved on. i bet Dave is just being sneaky with Oher's status so as to not key in other teams to our draft plans. That said, i would be comfortable taking this roster into the season. my thoughts are that it can only get better from here. :)

[OldNorthPowell]

6 minutes ago, La Pantera said:

Not comfortable with WR or Oline  depth.

 

Add RB depth for me 

[Cyberjag]

No, I think we need help at WR, RB, and DE.  

[The Huddler]

very comfortable

 

 

 

those who don't like the WR group are looking at that group in a Superbowl hangover vacuum and are simply short sighted to the potential in that group.

[UpstatePanther]

1 minute ago, The Huddler said:

very comfortable

 

 

 

those who don't like the WR group are looking at that group in a Superbowl hangover vacuum and are simply short sighted to the potential in that group.

i 100% agree with this, no disrespect to anyone's thoughts.

[La Pantera]

3 minutes ago, UpstatePanther said:

i understand those sentiments. Personally, i think our receiving corps will be much improved this year and that Oher will come back and ball out. if he was really still dealing with his concussion, they would have worked out an injury settlement with him already and moved on. i bet Dave is just being sneaky with Oher's status so as to not key in other teams to our draft plans. That said, i would be comfortable taking this roster into the season. my thoughts are that it can only get better from here. :)

 

If KB takes the next step and Funboy takes the 3rd year leap, we would be sitting with 2 and whole lot of possibles. We could possibly be worse at WR. We have no way of knowing what the potential is at this point. Johnson and Shepard me look like just special teams players. Let's be realistic. Do you see either gaining much more than 300+ yards in the season? I don't...

[rodeo]

WR, RT (Oher is not a RT, he is garbage there), FS. If we can fill all of those holes in 1 draft it would be nice.

[The Huddler]

I see Johnson being an upgrade to Ginn...

 

if ya disagree then so be it. I'm going on gut feelings

 

 

 

and IDC if Shepard is exactly what he was for the bucs. A ST stud is worth the money.

[The Huddler]

1 minute ago, rodeo said:

WR, RT (Oher is not a RT, he is garbage there), FS. If we can fill all of those holes in 1 draft it would be nice.

Adams will play SS, Coleman back to FS. I disagree. If anything we could use a good young SS

[Hoenheim]

25 minutes ago, La Pantera said:

Not comfortable with WR or Oline  depth.

 

I'm not comfortable with the starters either except Benjamin, R.Kalil, Norwell , and Turner