Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Evolution


Mr. Scot

Recommended Posts

 

Quote

Jacob Manly @JAKE_OB 3h3 hours ago

Replying to @PanthersBill

Rivera: "Offense must evolve" 2016 Off YPG: 19th 2017 Off YPG: 19th Cam Newton 2017: 80.7 psr rate - 2nd worst of career (75.8 - 2016) 16 INTs - 2nd worst of career (17 - 2011) 3,302 yds - 2nd worst of career (3,127 - 2014) 6.7 yd/avg - Career worst 206.4 yds/G - Career worst

1 reply 0 retweets 1 like
 

 Bill Voth @PanthersBill 3h3 hours ago

not good

 

Ouch.

Looking back, I can't help feeling like we stopped "evolving" after the first few games and just went back to the same old things we'd been doing, which led to the same result (i.e. needing Newton to bail us out at the end of games in order to win).

How much "evolution" did you see?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

So in about a million years or so we'll have a competent offense?

I don't think Shula can change for the better, and he showed no evidence of it this year. But as far as criticizing him for not having an offensive evolution in one year, while the QB missed a ton of camp and relying on a rookie as a key piece, is fairly ridiculous. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, thomas96 said:

I don't think Shula can change for the better, and he showed no evidence of it this year. But as far as criticizing him for not having an offensive evolution in one year, while the QB missed a ton of camp and relying on a rookie as a key piece, is fairly ridiculous. 

Still had three months of a healthy Newton to work with.

And even that doesn't explain why we're running what Riddick called "training camp day one" pass routes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Mr. Scot said:

And even that doesn't explain why we're running what Riddick called "training camp day one" pass routes.

But this has nothing to do with "evolution." This is play design. You're arguing micro while evolution is macro. I've never once tried to praise Shula for anything on the micro level. Because it's flat out horsesh*t. And I don't think his strategy on the macro level is anything amazing, earth-shattering, or to write home about. Simply average probably. And when you're a play caller being terrible on the micro level, no matter how great the overall strategy, doesn't cut it. I'm 100% for getting rid of Shula. But to try to criticize him for lack of "evolution" within 1 season is unfair.

 

And as far as the routes against the Falcons go... I'm not so sure that wasn't intentional in order to not show our hand before the playoffs... I really hope that it wasn't, because it's dumber to not gameplan for a huge game for that could be (and wound up being) for the division or even the 2 seed. But I don't put it past Ron to go into week 17 trying to not put what they're doing on film. Stupid, but Ron does a lot of stupid things like that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, thomas96 said:

But this has nothing to do with "evolution." This is play design. You're arguing micro while evolution is macro. I've never once tried to praise Shula for anything on the micro level. Because it's flat out horsesh*t. And I don't think his strategy on the macro level is anything amazing, earth-shattering, or to write home about. Simply average probably. And when you're a play caller being terrible on the micro level, no matter how great the overall strategy, doesn't cut it. I'm 100% for getting rid of Shula. But to try to criticize him for lack of "evolution" within 1 season is unfair.

And as far as the routes against the Falcons go... I'm not so sure that wasn't intentional in order to not show our hand before the playoffs... I really hope that it wasn't, because it's dumber to not gameplan for a huge game for that could be (and wound up being) for the division or even the 2 seed. But I don't put it past Ron to go into week 17 trying to not put what they're doing on film. Stupid, but Ron does a lot of stupid things like that.

I don't put the lack of evolution on Shula.  I put it on Rivera.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh, if evolution were but a simple, straight and unbothered line --- amoebae to homo extremis in 30 generations and lasers by day 5.

Evolution has never been about the leaps and bounds but by the dogged trial and error mixed with an unwillingness to give up on tomorrow.

We've had a lot of growing pains (and a lot of serious injuries to boot) but somehow the team put together 11 winning performances, some against some very strong play-off teams. We may fall flat at the start of the post season, we may stall out somewhere along the way, or we might just hoist a trophy in our battered, weary hands at the end of all this.

I've got faith in them, I still believe, how about you?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Shula is incapable of evolving. He might change a little, but it will be lateral movement at best. He’s awful. He’s been awful at every point of his career. He’s too old of a dog to be learning new tricks. And Rivera doesn’t want to evolve. He’ll pay lip service, but he’s too gd stubborn in his ways. Probably the military upbringing. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I mean you can always talk good or bad in just about everything. 8 wins and leading poo mountain, this rookie class is a big reason. Think about no Tmac or Dan Morgan didn't make that trade to gain a future 2nd rounder. So after Pat Jones breaks his back, DJ " who's not on any roster or PS" Johnson would be starting. Gods knows how bad they already are- 32nd in sacks/pressure/PDs etc... Sure Prince, Trevor, Cam, and little Jimmy haven't done too much, but they are still here.  Honestly its not smart or wise to judge rookies, *unless pro-bowl or cut. Lets revisit this next year, there are slump sophomore years and the biggest jump in players careers most times happens in the 2nd full off-season. You see who wants to be NFL pro and who's happy with teppers checks. I know many of them will be getting surgeries, got to see how they attack that as well....Tmac is playing hurt currently, if they were out of the race, he would be IR'd and maybe half the rookie class as well....I thought Cam was headed for the IR. 
    • It actually looks pretty solid.  A few players to re-sign and three primary positions to upgrade (starters).  Beyond that, we don't have a bunch of holes or need to overpay free agents. this is how I see it (using OTC for the 2026 roster information) on December 22, 2025.  This is rather basic, focusing on the core needs. Blue: Potential players to re-sign in the offseason.  Green: Players under contract for the 2026 season.  Italics: Possible cap casualties Analysis   Offense:  Center:  First, sign Mays for the long term (He is 26–I’d give him a 3-4 year deal).  He is not great, but he is decent and we need consistency on the OL. He does not make stupid mistakes. While the draft is not great in the interior offensive line, signing a veteran who can backup G and C would be a strategy.   Guard:  Canalas seemed to be impressed with Curhan, as I was.  He will be 28 next year, so he has a few years in him. I think he comes cheap and is quality depth.  He can play center, but is perhaps best at G and T.  Valuable reserve.   Tackle:  While Nijman returns as the swing T behind Moton and Ekwonu, the Panthers need to start developing a RT to play behind Moton.  A late-round draft pick that is rough but has all the tools is ideal. As the fourth OT, he can develop behind some pretty good veterans.   Wide Receiver:  We need a playmaker to play opposite TMac.  I believe in Coker, but think he is the AT-type slot. He needs to be re-signed. XL cannot be counted on to step into that role.  He is not that familiar with the WR position and he does not seem to be a student of the game.  This is a strong WR draft. First or second round.   Tight End:  I dunno.  I can see us upgrading the position, but Tremble does a lot of stuff well aside from catching the ball.  Evans is a decent all-around TE, and Sanders has some upside.  I’d love a weapon, but add the WR.   Running Back:  If Dowdle wants to be here, how do you let him walk?  He will be 28, and most RBs hit the wall then.  He deserves a big contract, but 28-year old RBs on big deals don’t earn them.  Go with Hubbard, Brooks, and Etienne.  Build the OL and the backs get better.   Quarterback:  Well, Bryce is improving and his confidence is growing.  Look at how many other QBs have taken time to get it. He is going to be the QB, regardless.  I want a young QB behind him, not the Red Senior Citizen.     Overview: Free Agent Priorities are to re-sign Mays and Coker.  I have Dowdle in blue, but I would let him walk (for reasons provided).  Cuhran played well and is versatile and should be signed if possible.  Draft a developmental OT, a raw, late-round OT.  In the draft, take a WR in rounds 1 or 2.  The offense is in tact–little needs to be done.  Let the OL develop chemistry, sign Mays while he is entering his prime, and get a weapon opposite TMac.  Give Coker a long-term deal.    Defense: ILB;  With only Wallace on the 2026 payroll, this position needs to be addressed.  Rozeboom might be able to be re-signed. I think ILB will be addressed in free agency and the draft. ILB will be the second or third round pick.  We will re-sign Rozeboom and maybe Cherulus and another priority free agent.   Edge/OLB: Scourton seems to be the real deal, but Princely (needs to develop) and Jones II are role players.  The draft is LOADED at the edge rush position.  I expect a first or second round edge player to be taken.   Defensive Tackle:  We have some big salaries at DT, and with Brown on the field, you dont need stars beside him.  I think the team cuts Robinson to get $8.5m in cap room, especially since C Jackson seems to be ready.     Cornerback:  Morgan has done a tremendous job finding talent in the bargain bins at CB.  Smith-Wade has been very solid.  Thornton seems to be a find.  Mike Jackson is a solid pro.     Safety:  Ransom seems to be the heir apparent for the Scott job, and Moehrig gives them a very aggressive, violent pair of safeties.  I like the safeties in this draft, fwiw.  I expect a late round pick.   Overview:  The Panthers must address ILB and Edge as priorities.  The ILB could be a free agent, Rozeboom re-signing, and maybe a draft pick. However, they need a pass rush more than anything else.   This is a great draft for edge players; I would not be surprised to see Dan Morgan double dip at edge.  Depth at S.   As soon as the season is over, look for Morgan to re-sign Mays, Coker, Cuhran, and possibly Rozeboom and Dowdle.  That would lock up the starting C, #3/slot WR, versatile depth on the OL, and get your leading tackler back at ILB.  Three HUGE moves that sould not break the bank.   Free agency would be focused on adding an ILB and a Safety who can play FS in three-S or big nickel sets. The draft would target Edge, WR, and ILB on days 1 and 2. Day 3:  OT depth, S depth, ILB depth.  
    • Seattle is coming across country to our house which will be packed.  We can beat this damn team.  Agree @TheBigKat the team has improved tremendously from last season
×
×
  • Create New...