So How's Jonathan Stewart Doing in New York?

[Toomers]

8 minutes ago, Snake said:

No no no Shula isn't calling the plays so I have been told. 

Did you not want to be told the truth?

[PantherBoy95]

13 minutes ago, Snake said:

That's what everyone says about every washed up RB but the truth is a good RB will give you 3 a carry no matter what. We got CJ Anderson for less than Stewart is being paid and he does exactly that. 

While I agree with the sentiment. I don't think anyone that watched the first half of our season last year could possibly see 3 yards a carry for even Ezekiel Elliot.
No running back should be getting hit directly after getting the ball.

Stewart showed the above average if not good back he can be once we started blocking well.

[LinvilleGorge]

Stew has been washed up for a couple of years now. He was a good RB for us though and he seems like a great guy. I'm glad he was able to fleece the Giants out of a few more million before he retires.

[Moo Daeng]

It's a fact hes not doing so well. Not sure why the anger towards the op

[Snake]

33 minutes ago, PantherBoy95 said:

While I agree with the sentiment. I don't think anyone that watched the first half of our season last year could possibly see 3 yards a carry for even Ezekiel Elliot.
No running back should be getting hit directly after getting the ball.

Stewart showed the above average if not good back he can be once we started blocking well.

Stewart was washed up last year and had Shula as well. He then goes to NY and same results. Why you ask? Same problems different team. 

[uncfan888]

49 minutes ago, Snake said:

Saquan doesn't need it. Dude is a stud unlike Stewart. 

Stewart was a stud for years

[Mr. Scot]

Just now, uncfan888 said:

Stewart was a stud for years

Arguably the best runningback we've had.

He had the balance of a gymnast. That's what made him so difficult to knock down.

[Snake]

45 minutes ago, Toomers said:

Did you not want to be told the truth?

The truth like how Shula ball is being played in NYC? Or the truth that you were totally wrong? 

[saints4lifeagain]

2 hours ago, Mr. Scot said:

There may be, but Stewart had pretty clearly lost a step in his last year here and as I recall he didn't get a lot of looks in free agency.

I think Stewart's a great guy, and even through a lot of injjuries he was a great player for us. But I also believe his time is up.

Wish him all the best but he's done.

I'm not saying he isn't. I haven't even watched him this year, but anytime a RB averages negative yards, that's not on him. 

[Mr. Scot]

9 minutes ago, saints4lifeagain said:

I'm not saying he isn't. I haven't even watched him this year, but anytime a RB averages negative yards, that's not on him. 

Understood. I'd want to know how much time he spent behind the first team line vs backups though.

[Toomers]

14 minutes ago, Snake said:

The truth like how Shula ball is being played in NYC? Or the truth that you were totally wrong? 

  WTF are you talking about? You’ve spouted this crap many times and every time someone has proven with direct statements that say Shula is not calling plays. Do you have anything besides your “deep thoughts” that say otherwise. 

[nosuchthingasapanther]

i'm a big stewart homer and had no issues defending him in the double trouble debates years ago.

yes, stewart has slowly lost a step. yes, the giants oline is trash...and yes, shula is the oc. but there is a night a day difference between the declining stewart that we saw in carolina and what is on display in new york.

he will always be one of my favorite panthers, but the truth is he looks like hot trash right now.

that being said, i'm still rooting for one last highlight reel season from him.

[Snake]

1 hour ago, Toomers said:

  WTF are you talking about? You’ve spouted this crap many times and every time someone has proven with direct statements that say Shula is not calling plays. Do you have anything besides your “deep thoughts” that say otherwise. 

Shula is coming up with the entire offensive game plan nit wit. My God have you even watched their games? It's Shula ball. Are you really that slow to think a OC that was two years removed of having the #1 offense in the nfl in the NFL would take a job to do nothing! Your stupidity amazes me. Like it or not Shula will be coming up with the game plan and will be calling plays by years end. 

[Toomers]

9 minutes ago, Snake said:

Shula is coming up with the entire offensive game plan nit wit. My God have you even watched their games? It's Shula ball. Are you really that slow to think a OC that was two years removed of having the #1 offense in the nfl in the NFL would take a job to do nothing! Your stupidity amazes me. Like it or not Shula will be coming up with the game plan and will be calling plays by years end. 

Like I said, your “thoughts”. When no other team wants you, and the first two guys turn the job down because they won’t be allowed to call plays, you take anything. Shurmer got the job because of his offensive mind and play calling. And your theory is he going to let Shula have control of his team. Whatever makes you feel good. Find me anything that says Shula has/will/or was ever intended to call plays. If you could, you would have done it the numerous other times your theory was shot to nothing. Including just now.