Guess who’s on the most over-rated list

[t96]

15 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

If the above posts stopped at "good" we could have a discussion. "Hall of Famer" and "better than Aikman" make me hope these guys being sarcastic.

Great quarterbacks don't choke in the playoffs.

Scot come on man you can't really be that simple. Romo's career playoff passer rating is 93. That's better than Brady's. Numbers aren't everything but Romo is not at all a choker in the playoffs. Romo is just like Marino he got royally fuged by having a horsesh*t team around him for his whole career, it's a team sport and wins reflect the team, NOT the QB. Romo would've won 5 or more SBs in NE if he was there instead of Brady. Jerry Jones wasted Romo's career with crappy teams but that's not on Romo. And he will be a hall of famer, without a doubt, whether you want to come to terms with that or not.

[Mage]

19 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

If the above posts stopped at "good" we could have a discussion. "Hall of Famer" and "better than Aikman" make me hope these guys being sarcastic.

Great quarterbacks don't choke in the playoffs.

Was Dan Marino not a great QB?

[KillaCamNewton]

i love that Russell Wilson is finally getting exposed as the overrated system QB he is now that Marshawn and the best defense of all time is gone. Love the excuses about his supporting cast too---it's no worse than the Costco employees Cam dragged to the playoffs last year and outdueled Brady and Rodgers with

[Mr. Scot]

2 minutes ago, Mage said:

Was Dan Marino not a great QB?

Yes, and not because of his stats. And well he doesn't have a Superbowl ring, Marino played in the Super Bowl are a pretty young age and played well.

Romo was just not a clutch QB.

[Mr. Scot]

6 minutes ago, t96 said:

Scot come on man you can't really be that simple. Romo's career playoff passer rating is 93. That's better than Brady's. Numbers aren't everything but Romo is not at all a choker in the playoffs. Romo is just like Marino he got royally fuged by having a horsesh*t team around him for his whole career, it's a team sport and wins reflect the team, NOT the QB. Romo would've won 5 or more SBs in NE if he was there instead of Brady. Jerry Jones wasted Romo's career with crappy teams but that's not on Romo. And he will be a hall of famer, without a doubt, whether you want to come to terms with that or not.

Tell me you did not just use passer rating to stack Tony Romo up next to Tom Brady...

Oy.

You know who for a long time had one of the best postseason passer ratings in history?

Jake Delhomme.

[GRWatcher]

@KillaCamNewton  Pie just for the "the Costco employees Cam dragged to the playoffs last year and outdueled Brady and Rodgers with" 

Dallas tops another list with double the mentions hahahaha. Mentioning their oline gives all football fans a solid lesson in how quickly a good oline can fall off. 

[Mage]

9 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Yes, and not because of his stats. And well he doesn't have a Superbowl ring, Marino played in the Super Bowl are a pretty young age and played well.

Romo was just not a clutch QB.

What are you talking about? Marino was terrible in the playoffs.  He threw more INTs than TDs in that Super Bowl with a 66 QB Rating.  If you’re gonna call Romo a playoff choker, then how was Marino not one?

Romo was excellent in his last playoff run.  Are you really gonna blame him for losing to Aaron Rodgers? 

Romo also had 29 game winning drives.  He was plenty clutch. I r

 

[Ricky Spanish]

13 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Yes, and not because of his stats. And well he doesn't have a Superbowl ring, Marino played in the Super Bowl are a pretty young age and played well.

Romo was just not a clutch QB.

Romo botched a snap as a holder one time in the playoffs and his entire career was defined by it. Not fair to him in the slightest considering he was the active leader in Game winning drives and 4Q comebacks while he was still playing, but people only remember the fumbled extra point. If we never win a SB with Cam at the helm, would you call it fair for everyone to claim Cam was a creampuff based on not jumping on the fumble in the super bowl? I wouldn't.

Dude only made it to the playoffs like 3 times and played well each time. All the rest of the years the team around him was straight doo doo because of Jones. 

[Mr. Scot]

7 minutes ago, Mage said:

What are you talking about? Marino was terrible in the playoffs.  He threw more INTs than TDs in that Super Bowl with a 66 QB Rating.  If you’re gonna call Romo a playoff choker, then how was Marino not one?

Romo was excellent in his last playoff run.  Are you really gonna blame him for losing to Aaron Rodgers? 

Romo also had 29 game winning drives.  He was plenty clutch. 

How many of those came in the playoffs?

(we know it wasn't a significant number because Romo didn't make the playoffs very much)

Lemme flip the question on you. How great a quarterback is Matt Stafford?

Matt Stafford is pretty regularly ranked high in a lot of statistical categories. He also throws a really nice looking pass. The problem? When the pressure is on he wilts like a flower in the desert. In a big game, you don't want your fate in the hands of this guy, no matter how high his passer rating stat might be.

Basically, if Tony Romo is a great quarterback, then so is Matt Stafford.

[Ricky Spanish]

I will add that I am on the fence of Romo being a HOFer. Definitely Hall of really good, not necessarily HOF though.

Then again I think that Aikman only made it to the HOF because he won three Super Bowls built on the backs of others. 

[Ricky Spanish]

8 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

How many of those came in the playoffs?

(we know it wasn't a significant number because Romo didn't make the playoffs very much)

Lemme flip the question on you. How great a quarterback is Matt Stafford?

Matt Stafford is pretty regularly ranked high in a lot of statistical categories. He also throws a really nice looking pass. The problem? When the pressure is on he wilts like a flower in the desert. In a big game, you don't want your fate in the hands of this guy, no matter how high his passer rating stat might be.

Basically, if Tony Romo is a great quarterback, then so is Matt Stafford.

Stafford is also a great QB. Not his fault the Lions haven't had a RB run for over 100 yards in 69 straight games. Kind of hard to be a successful completely one dimensional team...

Also Stafford is clutch AF are you kidding? Dude has 32 Game winning drives and he's only 30. He constantly Balls out at the end of games to win there's an entire meme based around his ability to make a comeback and beat you. 

[Mr. Scot]

FYI: You guys can I have the last word on this for now. After seeing the Turner news, I don't feel like talking about football anymore today.

We're about to go into a game with an offensive line for whom "patchwork" might be a compliment 

[Ricky Spanish]

8 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

FYI: You guys can I have the last word on this for now. After seeing the Turner news, I don't feel like talking about football anymore today.

We're about to go into a game with an offensive line for whom "patchwork" might be a compliment 

@Mage @t96

That just means we're right. 

We did it bois.

[Mr. Scot]

7 minutes ago, Cracka McNasty said:

@Mage @t96

That just means we're right. 

We did it bois.

In your dreams, dude

And I just told you I'd be back tomorrow anyway. But right now I'm in a bad mood.

(I'm trying not to discuss football when I'm in this kind of mood; it tends to go badly)