Silver Team - Who you got?

[BrianS]

Here are the candidates and my picks (and some thoughts after):

QB (1):  Beuerlein, Collins, Delhomme, Newton
FB (1):  Floyd, Griffith, Hoover, Tolbert
RB (1):  Biakabutuka, Davis, Foster, McCaffrey, Stewart, Williams
TE (1):  King, Mangum, Olsen, Walls
WR (2):  Benjamin, Carrier, Funchess, LaFell, Muhammad, Smith
C (1):  Garcia, Hangartner, Kalil, Mitchell
G (2):  Campbell, Donnally, Norwell, Turner, Wahle, Wharton
T (2):  Bell, Brockermeyer, Gross, Remmers, Steussie, Terry
DE (2):  Addison, Fox, Hardy, Johnson, Peppers, Rucker
DT (2):  Buckner, Jenkins, Kemoeato, Kragen, Lotulelei, Short
LB (3):  Beason, Davis, Greene, Kuechly, Lathon, Mills, Morgan, Witherspoon
CB (2):  Davis, Evans, Gamble, Lucas, Marshall, Munnerlyn, Norman
S (2):  Coleman, Cota, Godfrey, Grant, Harris, Minter, Terrell
K (1):  Gano, Kasay
P (1):  Baker, Nortman, Palardy, Saurbrun
Return (1):  Bates, Ginn, Smart

 

At QB, I love Jake as much as the next guy, but Cam is the best we've ever seen.  For FB, how can you not go Hoover?  At RB, it's tough to choose only one given our history, and if you ask again in a couple years I suspect I'll change my answer, but for now it's gotta be Stewart.  Olsen at TE is obvious, though Walls was Olsen before Olsen.  At WR, it just shows you how bad we've been when KB and LaFell are even options.  Kalil at C makes us all forget that we have had some pretty good players there . . . but Frank Garcia was good.  Turner was fairly obvious . . . but Norwell over Wharton by a hair I think.  The fact that Byron Bell and Mike Remmers are options here makes you really appreciate Jordan Gross all the more.  Our DE's have been really good over time, and taking Johnson over Rucker was hard.  Our DT's also . . . strong . . . Jenkins and Short would have been devastating if they played in the same era.  And our LB's . . . holy (*@$ our LB's . . . just great historically . . . I stand by my choices, but wow having to leave out Dan Morgan was hard.  At CB, we've historically been pretty good when you look at the list, but yea Norman and Gamble were our best.  At S, it makes you realize how long it's been since we've had a really good one . . . we miss you Mike.  I took Gano over Kasay because Gano has a comparable make percentage, more range and kicks off.  Saurbrun over the field because Saurbrun also kicked off for us.  And all credit to Ted Ginn, but Michael Bates changed games at returner where Ginn did most of his damage on offense.

 

[Carl Spackler]

I know at least one person who will vote for Hardy

[toldozer]

That's a sad list at safety

[Baskinridge]

1 hour ago, BrianS said:

S (2):  Coleman, Cota, Godfrey, Grant, Harris, Minter, Terrell
 

 

blob.jfif

[joemac]

1 hour ago, Carl Spackler said:

I know at least one person who will vote for Hardy

If we're going off of talent and production on the field, then i'd take Hardy over CJ every day of the week....

[Santee_Panther]

Sam Mills and John Kasay are both in the Hall of Honor, so those seem like obvious picks.

[therealmjl]

Marlon McCree > Charles Godfrey and I don’t care if it was only one season

[Carl Spackler]

1 hour ago, joemac said:

If we're going off of talent and production on the field, then i'd take Hardy over CJ every day of the week....

That's a bad vote. Going off one year over many years means you'd also prefer KB over Moose.

[Carl Spackler]

Also, Mark Jones > Ginn as a returner, but still way behind 89 and Bates.

[Carl Spackler]

QB (1):  Beuerlein, Collins, Delhomme, Newton
FB (1):  Floyd, Griffith, Hoover, Tolbert
RB (1):  Biakabutuka, Davis, Foster, McCaffrey, Stewart, Williams
TE (1):  King, Mangum, Olsen, Walls
WR (2):  Benjamin, Carrier, Funchess, LaFell, Muhammad, Smith
C (1):  Garcia, Hangartner, Kalil, Mitchell
G (2):  Campbell, Donnalley, Norwell, Turner, Wahle, Wharton
T (2):  Bell, Brockermeyer, Gross, Remmers, Steussie, Terry
DE (2):  Addison, Fox, Hardy, Johnson, Peppers, Rucker
DT (2):  Buckner, Jenkins, Kemoeato, Kragen, Lotulelei, Short
LB (3):  Beason, Davis, Greene, Kuechly, Lathon, Mills, Morgan, Witherspoon
CB (2):  Davis, Evans, Gamble, Lucas, Marshall, Munnerlyn, Norman
S (2):  Coleman, Cota, Godfrey, Grant, Harris, Minter, Terrell
K (1):  Gano, Kasay
P (1):  Baker, Nortman, Palardy, Sauerbrun
Return (1):  Bates, Ginn, Smart

[Bronn]

3 hours ago, BrianS said:

Here are the candidates and my picks (and some thoughts after):

QB (1):  Beuerlein, Collins, Delhomme, Newton
FB (1):  Floyd, Griffith, Hoover, Tolbert
RB (1):  Biakabutuka, Davis, Foster, McCaffrey, Stewart, Williams
TE (1):  King, Mangum, Olsen, Walls
WR (2):  Benjamin, Carrier, Funchess, LaFell, Muhammad, Smith
C (1):  Garcia, Hangartner, Kalil, Mitchell
G (2):  Campbell, Donnally, Norwell, Turner, Wahle, Wharton
T (2):  Bell, Brockermeyer, Gross, Remmers, Steussie, Terry
DE (2):  Addison, Fox, Hardy, Johnson, Peppers, Rucker
DT (2):  Buckner, Jenkins, Kemoeato, Kragen, Lotulelei, Short
LB (3):  Beason, Davis, Greene, Kuechly, Lathon, Mills, Morgan, Witherspoon
CB (2):  Davis, Evans, Gamble, Lucas, Marshall, Munnerlyn, Norman
S (2):  Coleman, Cota, Godfrey, Grant, Harris, Minter, Terrell
K (1):  Gano, Kasay
P (1):  Baker, Nortman, Palardy, Sauerbrun
Return (1):  Bates, Ginn, Smart

 

 

 

[pantherclaw]

Just voted, and all I got to say is there are a lot of young people voting, because the results I saw are fubar. 

 

Anyways, going fishing.

[KillerKat]

wtf is silver team?

[Go DJ that's my DJ]

56 minutes ago, KillerKat said:

wtf is silver team?

The best players from the franchises 25 years(silver) in existence.