Being completely objective here, McAdoo was the best available Candidate for the Job

[flagfootballcoach28]

It was a solid hire. McAdoo had top 10 offenses in NY when he was the OC under Coughlin 

[mav1234]

36 minutes ago, CRA said:

Well, Beckham also had the most targets in his career in 2016.  To go along with his worst catch %.    

And the offense stunk.   OBJ did have production though.   I mean you can over feed a player and while they might still have individual numbers….it’s not actually good offense.    A variation of is over feeding CMC.  And it makes CMC a good fantasy player but our offense isn’t actually good.  To me, that is what the Giants became. 

If 1300+ yards and 10 TDs is figured out... Sure. Otoh maybe it was also Manning's slow decline.

McAdoo also gave up play calling in 2017 - the team didn't really improve without him calling plays.

He was a bad HC all around.  Better OC and offensive assistant more generally so hopefully that carries over here.

[Shocker]

37 minutes ago, Toomers said:

He’s built an average defense that’s losing Reddick, Jackson, Gilmore, Jones and still needs a MLB and a FS. And very little cap to do anything with. Or draft picks. Combined with needing 3 OL and most of all a QB, how long before any of this shows progress. Just because you bought the snake oil, doesn’t mean he’s going to magically figure the NFL out. 

Yeah…you are assuming a ton here and I don’t doubt everything you said is completely wrong.  It has happened numerous times

How you fixing your Steelers should be a bigger question 

Edited January 22, 2022 by Shocker

[Toomers]

1 minute ago, Shocker said:

Yeah…you are assuming a ton here and I don’t doubt everything you said is completely wrong.  It has happened numerous times

How you fixing your Steelers should be a bigger question 

   Everything I posted are facts. What part isn’t? And anytime you want to compare resumes’ of predicting on here, we can do that anytime you’re ready. Show me anything I predicted that has been wrong. If you could dispute any of this you would have. Instead you deflect to acting like I haven’t been predicting all these issues for two years. Back up your BS or go sit down little boy. 
 

   My Steelers, a playoff team as it usually is, has more than double the cap space of the Panthers and many less holes to fill. And all their picks in the draft. Not too mention a history of not being incompetent at every turn. Just a history of the best, most consistent team of the last 50 years. Any other facts you want to discuss?

[Shocker]

Just now, Toomers said:

   Everything I posted are facts. What part isn’t? And anytime you want to compare resumes’ of predicting on here, we can do that anytime you’re ready. Show me anything I predicted that has been wrong. If you could dispute any of this you would have. Instead you deflect to acting like I haven’t been predicting all these issues for two years. Back up your BS or go sit down little boy. 
 

   My Steelers, a playoff team as it usually is, has more than double the cap space of the Panthers and many less holes to fill. And all their picks in the draft. Not too mention a history of not being incompetent at every turn. Just a history of the best, most consistent team of the last 50 years. Any other facts you want to discuss?

Stop trying to look smart…it isn’t working

Edited January 22, 2022 by Shocker

[Shotgun]

[Jared Patterson]

1 hour ago, Shocker said:

I am seriously very happy with this hire as I look at things.  A lot of people look at this guy as joke but he has solid experience in this league.  I look forward to seeing the outcome especially if we get an OL.  Getting a QB for the future might be too much to ask this offseason but we’ll see

No one will give him credit but this is a really good move for Matt Rhule.  He isn’t done here by any stretch 

Rhule mentioned that every coach learns from good moves and bad moves in this league.  Telling comments from a guy that is plugged in and building something special 

LOL

[Toomers]

3 minutes ago, Shocker said:

Stop trying to look smart…it isn’t working

Should I post gifs to prove my knowledge like you? Instead of responding to facts you deem to be “wrong”. You poor thing. 

[Jared Patterson]

5 minutes ago, Shocker said:

Stop trying to look smart…it isn’t working

No you are the dumb one

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

awesome we're going 3-14 next year instead of 2-15

[Shocker]

3 minutes ago, Toomers said:

Should I post gifs to prove my knowledge like you? Instead of responding to facts you deem to be “wrong”. You poor thing. 

Why are you here?  Steelers fan guessing what the Panthers will do.  If we resign Reddick you are completely waved as an idiot.  I will remember this I hope you do…but then your amnesia will probably kick in

Edited January 22, 2022 by Shocker

[Shocker]

1 hour ago, Toomers said:

He’s built an average defense that’s losing Reddick, Jackson, Gilmore, Jones and still needs a MLB and a FS. And very little cap to do anything with. Or draft picks. Combined with needing 3 OL and most of all a QB, how long before any of this shows progress. Just because you bought the snake oil, doesn’t mean he’s going to magically figure the NFL out. 

The defense finished #2 in the league and it is average?  LOL.  So fuggin dumb.  Especially considering our offense…absurd 

BTW…your Steelers finished well below average on defense…maybe you are confused again

The Panthers are way closer to winning a championship than the Steelers.  By a LONG ways.  Steelers are about to totally rebuild 

Edited January 22, 2022 by Shocker

[Toomers]

2 minutes ago, Shocker said:

Why are you here?  Steelers fan guessing what the Panthers will do.  If we resign Reddick you are completely waved as an idiot.  I will remember this I hope you do…but then your amnesia will probably kick in

Because every year I get told by losers like you that I need to be here to take it after the Panthers start winning? It’s just while I wait, and keep betting the under on Ws for the season, I’ll make my observations. They are all easy to find. Post anything I was wrong about. How long you think it will take me to find your horrible predictions. 
 

  And how does me being a Steelers fan change anything I posted? Still the same words. Just another tap out and deflect move because you don’t have the intellect to make anything but excuses. Why does signing Reddick “waved” anything? You can use half your cap space on him and just go with UDFAs on the OL. He’s not on the salary cap this year except for dead money. Say the word. We can go to the tape. 

[Shocker]

8 minutes ago, Toomers said:

Because every year I get told by losers like you that I need to be here to take it after the Panthers start winning? It’s just while I wait, and keep betting the under on Ws for the season, I’ll make my observations. They are all easy to find. Post anything I was wrong about. How long you think it will take me to find your horrible predictions. 
 

  And how does me being a Steelers fan change anything I posted? Still the same words. Just another tap out and deflect move because you don’t have the intellect to make anything but excuses. Why does signing Reddick “waved” anything? You can use half your cap space on him and just go with UDFAs on the OL. He’s not on the salary cap this year except for dead money. Say the word. We can go to the tape. 

But…you don’t even consider that you are completely wrong.  Try it.  Self reflection is amazing 

Reddick is a priority sign.  Stop acting like we can’t get that done.  Silly, of course we can.  The other guys may be obvious but the key guys are back on defense.  You might not like it as a Steelers fan but this team is in good shape with the cap.  

Edited January 22, 2022 by Shocker