I know this sounds crazy, but was Jake really the best QB we have ever had?

[Dpantherman]

I could make a case for Steve Beuerlein. Lets put this in perspective before people throw the playoffs at me. Don't forget that Steve didn't have Steve Smith. and the Defense wasn't the same. Steve's best year kills Jake's best year, when he lead the league with 4,436 yards and a 94.6 passer rating. I think if we went back in time and put our team with Steve as QB, we would be pretty good. If anything they are just as good as each other, i don't think i can call jake the best.

http://www.nfl.com/players/stevebeuerlein/careerstats?id=BEU207645"]Steve's Stats

http://www.nfl.com/players/careerstats?id=DEL367367"]Jake's Stats

--by the way, im talking about numbers as a Panther for both guys---

[Rags]

What does the past have to do with how hes playing right now? Sure, he might've been, the chances of him doing that again is very unlikely.

[Zod]

This sounds really familiar, almost as if there is an exact thread just like it right above this one. Weird.

[err456]

Steve's best year is clearly better than Jakes's but Jake has been better longer.

I know Jake has had a better situation than Steve but "it is what it is"

I like Jake, have always supported him and pulled for him until this year that is.

Fox clearly didn't expect his play to decline so rapidly and is not prepared so this year we have to settle for crap at QB. If Fox is still here next year and he stays with Jake I pity the fool.

[Dpantherman]

This sounds really familiar, almost as if there is an exact thread just like it right above this one. Weird.

O Mighty Ruler-- please, I didn't mean to anger you, but may I explain? One says "Jake is the Best", Here I question that notion

[Dpantherman]

What does the past have to do with how hes playing right now? Sure, he might've been, the chances of him doing that again is very unlikely.

this is a response to the notion of Jake being the best QB we have ever had, so what are you trying say?

[Smithers]

Steve may not have had Steve Smith, but he had plenty of offensive weapons, way more than we do now. He had Muhammad in his prime, Patrick Jeffers, Wesley Walls, and so on. That year he went to the pro bowl our offense was in the top 5 in the NFL. That year was so much fun!

[rayzor]

O Mighty Ruler-- please, I didn't mean to anger you, but may I explain? One says "Jake is the Best", Here I question that notion

not even an underling but the question is begged, why couldn't that notion be questioned in the other thread?

[MrT]

Steve's best year is clearly better than Jakes's but Jake has been better longer.

I know Jake has had a better situation than Steve but "it is what it is"

I like Jake, have always supported him and pulled for him until this year that is.

Fox clearly didn't expect his play to decline so rapidly and is not prepared so this year we have to settle for crap at QB. If Fox is still here next year and he stays with Jake I pity the fool.

Yo Dude, I pity the fool that steals lines from the T. Don't nothin get by me.

[Guild]

This sounds really familiar, almost as if there is an exact thread just like it right above this one. Weird.

It's probably just the acid.

Wait or was it the ether? Where am I? Who am I? How did that lizard get in here?

[Peppers90 NC]

who the f@ck cares? let's create dumber more useless boring threads PLEASE!!!

[Dpantherman]

who the f@ck cares? let's create dumber more useless boring threads PLEASE!!!

why bother coming in and commenting since you don't care? :iamwithstupid:

[Dpantherman]

not even an underling but the question is begged, why couldn't that notion be questioned in the other thread?

didnt feel like it.

[PantherDude]

If Fox is still here next year and he stays with Jake I pity the fool.

Who 'da fool you're calling?

But honestly, who care? Both have done a lot of great thing for the team in their early career here. Let leave it at that. :thumbsup: :sifone: