Story on the Joe Brady situation from Charles Robinson..

[WOW!!]

https://pantherswire.usatoday.com/2022/08/18/panthers-oc-ben-mcadoo-matt-rhule-joe-brady/

[WOW!!]

Added to Chris Simms opinion seem right...

 

[Tbe]

So an inexperienced HC with an inexperienced staff isn’t a winning strategy?

[WOW!!]

Just now, Tbe said:

So an inexperienced HC with an inexperienced staff isn’t a winning strategy?

Exactly.... Which is a valid reason he should have been fired.. But also a reason to believe he's growing by changing his situation and staff..

[Castavar]

So hiring a college passing coordinator that had superstar WRs everywhere on the field to make him look good and wasn't even the OC was a bad idea?

[Tbe]

2 minutes ago, WOW!! said:

Exactly.... Which is a valid reason he should have been fired.. But also a reason to believe he's growing by changing his situation and staff..

From what I remember, allowing him to pick his staff was a condition to coming here. That mistake is all on Tep.

[CRA]

So…..micromanaging Matt Rhule was micromanaging.  

But totally isn’t going to keep micromanaging things because Ben McAdoo had some relative success under another micromanaging HC named Coughlin while paired with a Super Bowl QB. 

[gofightwin]

They could have hired an old experienced OC and had Brady be passing game coordinator and still pay him a ton and actually learn the OC job. But always with the big splash that turns into the big belly flop. 

[CRA]

5 minutes ago, WOW!! said:

Exactly.... Which is a valid reason he should have been fired.. But also a reason to believe he's growing by changing his situation and staff..

Matt Rhule hired him.  Rhule wasn’t getting a false set of goods.  He hired someone that had never been a full time playcaller on any level and Rhule had no clue how to provide any guidance or even run a practice week. 

Joe Brady remains a lesson in why Matt Rhule isn’t a NFL coach.  It’s reminder 737 at this point. 

[WOW!!]

Just now, CRA said:

So…..micromanaging Matt Rhule was micromanaging.  

But totally isn’t going to keep micromanaging things because Ben McAdoo had some relative success under another micromanaging HC named Coughlin. 

At this point you would have a problem with the toothpaste he uses.. 

It's clear Brady couldn't handle the job and Rhule micromanaged because he knew it..

Mcadoo is a different story and has more NFL experience then Rhule.. So just like Snow Matt won't be Micromanaging Mcadoo, Campen, Snow, Tabor or Wilkes and Pasqualone..

[frankw]

Joe Brady needed to go. But he didn't hire himself and in the lead up to the 2020 season I definitely recall in depth interviews about his philosophy and together with Rhule their desire to try to replicate things from the Saints offense. This notion that Matt Rhule was saddled with a clueless idiot in over his head and had no idea that was going to happen is revisionist history.

[Jackie Lee]

2 minutes ago, Tbe said:

From what I remember, allowing him to pick his staff was a condition to coming here. That mistake is all on Tep.

Yeah the Jets were like no way. The fuging Jets. They have really made quite the impact on this new look Panthers team

[WOW!!]

2 minutes ago, gofightwin said:

They could have hired an old experienced OC and had Brady be passing game coordinator and still pay him a ton and actually learn the OC job. But always with the big splash that turns into the big belly flop. 

Yes that would have been way better..

My only problem with this plan is Brady thought he was better then he was ..

Remember he was going on HC interviews after 2020.. I don't think he felt he needed a internship situation..

[frankw]

1 minute ago, Jackie Lee said:

Yeah the Jets were like no way. The fuging Jets. They have really made quite the impact on this new look Panthers team

Giants too. You know they had a real good time kicking our asses last year because of it.