5 good players out of 31 draft picks

[Hoenheim]

2019 to 2022. 31 draft picks, I count 5 good players. That is insanely abysmal drafting.  

Chinn and Ickey are debatable I guess,  that's why I made a 3rd category with the orange mark as unknown   

Red = bust , orange = unknown/too difficult for me to judge , blue check = good player 

[LinvilleGorge]

Brutal. And honestly, Chinn is more of an undetermined vs. a checkmark simply because we can't figure out how to utilize him.

[PootieNunu]

To further this, these are only good players. Not one all pro, barely a pro bowler.  

Tons of assets wasted on drafting athletic guys who cant play any fuging position. 

Not to mention all the picks that were traded away to field this garbage. 

 

Edited November 4, 2023 by PootieNunu

[LinvilleGorge]

1 minute ago, PootieNunu said:

To further this, these are only good players. Not one all pro, barely a pro bowler.  

Tons of assets wasted on drafting athletic guys who cant play any fuging position. 

Not to mention all the picks that were traded away to field this garbage. 

 

That some folks are still clinging to not having enough information on Fitterer is honestly baffling. I wanted him to follow Rhule out the door but allowed that maybe he'd look a lot more competent without Rhule. Well... that hasn't happened.

[Hoenheim]

Just now, LinvilleGorge said:

Brutal. And honestly, Chinn is more of an undetermined vs. a checkmark simply because we can't figure out how to utilize him.

Yea some of these are a little hard to grade.  Ickey woudlve been a check last year but he's done so poorly this year I had to demote him to unknown. 

Chinn did initially succeed. But yea I guess it's been inconsistent since then. I feel like he's good if you know how to use him...

 

Christensen is definitely solid enough for the check. Some might debate me on Chubba but he was a 4th rounder. We've got some incredibly good production from him being a 4th round pick and he's  our starting rb that's way better than 1000+ yard fa rb we signed. 

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

Chinn ain't done poo since his rookie year. Whether thats a Chinn problem or a coaching problem, it doesn't matter. He's not a checkmark.

Christenson should be orange.

Horn needs to be red. No I don't care if he's good the 3 snaps he plays per year. The fact that a guy on a HOF level track that plays the same position was taken right after him is a double whammy of poo.

Overall, a disaster. Shitterer needs to be canned, tepper needs to sell the team, Reich needs to be put in a retirement home.

Edited November 4, 2023 by Sean Payton's Vicodin

[PootieNunu]

5 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

That some folks are still clinging to not having enough information on Fitterer is honestly baffling. I wanted him to follow Rhule out the door but allowed that maybe he'd look a lot more competent without Rhule. Well... that hasn't happened.

Yea I never understood why he was kept other than Tepper's ineptitude. I didnt have much hope for him following Rhule as he was only hired to be a yes man. 

Edited November 4, 2023 by PootieNunu

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

5 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

That some folks are still clinging to not having enough information on Fitterer is honestly baffling. I wanted him to follow Rhule out the door but allowed that maybe he'd look a lot more competent without Rhule. Well... that hasn't happened.

[LinvilleGorge]

Just now, PootieNunu said:

Yea I never understood why he was kept other than Tepper ineptitude. I didnt have much hope for him following Rhule as he was only hired to be a yes man. 

I didn't have much faith in him as soon as he took a GM job that didn't have final roster say. Legit GM candidates don't take that offer. They wait for a real GM offer. Now we're seeing him operate as a real GM and it ain't good.

[PootieNunu]

5 minutes ago, Hoenheim said:

Yea some of these are a little hard to grade.  Ickey woudlve been a check last year but he's done so poorly this year I had to demote him to unknown. 

Chinn did initially succeed. But yea I guess it's been inconsistent since then. I feel like he's good if you know how to use him...

 

Christensen is definitely solid enough for the check. Some might debate me on Chubba but he was a 4th rounder. We've got some incredibly good production from him being a 4th round pick and he's  our starting rb that's way better than 1000+ yard fa rb we signed. 

No quibbles about those as you only said good players.  If we move the needle to great players we probably only have DB standing, and he was drafted by Hurney. 

[Castavar]

That is...................................................absolutely fuggin beyond pathetic. You could argue your random forum fan could draft better than this. Hell, your average fan on here would have taken Surtain over Horn, and Howell over Corral, and Josh Downs over Mingo. The majority of Panther nation also did not want Reich. I'm actually starting to think we could have fielded a better team than our NFL GM, and that's saying A LOT. Fittrerer has to go.

[Castavar]

Also, this ALONE should be fire worthy. Let's not even get into his FA acquisitions (or lack thereof) and trades.

Edited November 4, 2023 by Castavar

[kungfoodude]

12 minutes ago, Castavar said:

That is...................................................absolutely fuggin beyond pathetic. You could argue your random forum fan could draft better than this. Hell, your average fan on here would have taken Surtain over Horn, and Howell over Corral, and Josh Downs over Mingo. The majority of Panther nation also did not want Reich. I'm actually starting to think we could have fielded a better team than our NFL GM, and that's saying A LOT. Fittrerer has to go.

Maybe run a Huddle poll for every draft pick?

[pantherclaw]

Can't say I agree with the grades, but I get the point. 

Not sure where we going to find that perfect drafting GM, especially when head coaches get a say in the picks.