Short Stack vs Pickles

[Panthers Fan 69]

Gonna have some fun here. Who is worse?

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

Pickles is the worse QB but Bryce is the most draft pick I've ever seen a team do

Edited November 10, 2023 by Sean Payton's Vicodin

[Mage]

Bryce has sucked but even at his worst, he's still way better than Clausen.

The only way this is a debate for anyone is if they didn't see Clausen play.  Bryce has looked like your usual bad QB (although I have not given up on him).  Jimmy looked like an all-time bad QB.  Huge difference IMO.  To this day I really don't know how many QBs I'd say were worse than Clausen? 

And keep in mind Clausen sucked with what was a solid supporting cast.  Steve Smith, rookie LaFell is better than anyone we have sans Thielen, Stewart (Williams was hurt), Gettis too, OL was good... Clausen was just so bad.  There is a reason he only played 3 seasons.  I'm convinced he could lead just about any team to the No. 1 Overall Pick.  Just about any QB trait you could think of, Clausen was the worst.  IQ?  Accuracy? Arm Strength? Mobility? Awareness?  Leadership?  Clausen was a 0/10 across the board.

Edited November 10, 2023 by Mage

[Stumpy]

2 minutes ago, Mage said:

There is a reason he only played 3 seasons. 

What makes you think Bryce will get that long?

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

15 minutes ago, Sean Payton's Vicodin said:

Pickles is the worse QB but Bryce is the most draft pick I've ever seen a team do

I can't edit, but I meant to say the most DAMAGING draft pick

[Mage]

4 minutes ago, Stumpy said:

What makes you think Bryce will get that long?

I guarantee you he will last more than 3 seasons in the NFL, even if it is as a back-up QB.  To think otherwise is just being ignorant.

Clausen wasn't even good enough to be a back-up.  We're talking about a guy who threw 7 TDs in 14 starts.  Young has already surpassed that.

Again anyone who says otherwise just didn't watch or doesn't remember how awful Clausen was.  He was an all-time bad QB.  Like over the entire history of the NFL.  Bryce Young is just regular bad.

It's like asking Mark Sanchez vs Jimmy Clausen... yeah, Sanchez sucked, but he won't Clausen bad.

Edited November 10, 2023 by Mage

[LinvilleGorge]

Not gonna lie, the last two games got me like

[Panthers Fan 69]

22 minutes ago, Mage said:

I guarantee you he will last more than 3 seasons in the NFL, even if it is as a back-up QB.  To think otherwise is just being ignorant.

Clausen wasn't even good enough to be a back-up.  We're talking about a guy who threw 7 TDs in 14 starts.  Young has already surpassed that.

Again anyone who says otherwise just didn't watch or doesn't remember how awful Clausen was.  He was an all-time bad QB.  Like over the entire history of the NFL.  Bryce Young is just regular bad.

It's like asking Mark Sanchez vs Jimmy Clausen... yeah, Sanchez sucked, but he won't Clausen bad.

Sanchez was good for a couple years going to a couple AFC championships. 

[Stumpy]

22 minutes ago, Mage said:

I guarantee you he will last more than 3 seasons in the NFL, even if it is as a back-up QB.  To think otherwise is just being ignorant.

Clausen wasn't even good enough to be a back-up.  We're talking about a guy who threw 7 TDs in 14 starts.  Young has already surpassed that.

Again anyone who says otherwise just didn't watch or doesn't remember how awful Clausen was.  He was an all-time bad QB.  Like over the entire history of the NFL.  Bryce Young is just regular bad.

It's like asking Mark Sanchez vs Jimmy Clausen... yeah, Sanchez sucked, but he won't Clausen bad.

That's a lot of text to not answer the question.

Also, The Jimmy was in the NFL for 6 seasons not 3. To think otherwise is just being ignorant.

[Stumpy]

1 minute ago, Panthers Fan 69 said:

Sanchez was good for a couple years going to a couple AFC championships. 

Rookie Sanchize would be a massive upgrade over Bryce!

Probably currently, too.

[CLG]

Edit: my bad I’m in the wrong thread lol
 

It’s like the battle of which head coach can look like the biggest dumbass on the sideline 

Edited November 10, 2023 by CLG

[Ricky Spanish]

12 minutes ago, Stumpy said:

Rookie Sanchize would be a massive upgrade over Bryce!

Probably currently, too.

Rookie Sanchez threw for 2.4k yards in 15 games with 12 TDs to 20 INTs...

Bryce hasn't looked good but the hyperbole comparing him to guys like Clausen and Sanchez is just lazy.

[Panthers Fan 69]

13 minutes ago, CLG said:

Edit: my bad I’m in the wrong thread lol
 

It’s like the battle of which head coach can look like the biggest dumbass on the sideline 

apparently ours. 

[Ricky Spanish]

29 minutes ago, Panthers Fan 69 said:

apparently ours. 

Ah, so he is a true panther fan.