Reich was an amazing head coach

[strato]

1 minute ago, t96 said:

Idk man, CJ here would definitely be much better than Bryce but last year we still probably don’t win any more than 5-6 games, and CJ wouldn’t be anywhere near OROY. Reich just was not a good HC. I’m basing that mostly on his Indy tenure and I didn’t want him when we hired him either, so Tepper/Bryce have very little to do with it.

Bryce would kill any coach. So what's the point of dogging Reich for being vanilla? 

 

[t96]

Just now, strato said:

Bryce would kill any coach. So what's the point of dogging Reich for being vanilla? 

 

Reich killed himself in Indy

[strato]

1 minute ago, t96 said:

Reich killed himself in Indy

You are welcome to your opinion, I'll leave you alone.

But the guy was a lifer and really didn't do that bad when he had a good QB, that's my final attempt to bridge the disagreement.

[fanpanther]

6 minutes ago, t96 said:

Idk man, CJ here would definitely be much better than Bryce but last year we still probably don’t win any more than 5-6 games, and CJ wouldn’t be anywhere near OROY. Reich just was not a good HC. I’m basing that mostly on his Indy tenure and I didn’t want him when we hired him either, so Tepper/Bryce have very little to do with it.

I think cj easily adds 14 more points to the panthers per game last season its an entirely different situation if so. 

[strato]

39 minutes ago, fanpanther said:

I think cj easily adds 14 more points to the panthers per game last season its an entirely different situation if so. 

For one thing people on the team could look at the guy and have some faith that he could get there. 

If there ever was such a thing as addition by subtraction, Bryce is the subtractee. 

Seriously, what could they have thought after camp and a few games, about Bryce Young? The organization looks stupid as hell to players when they watch CJ Stroud and then go back to practice with Bryce on Tuesday. Don't kid yourself. 

It's just a whole different world in Carolina without Bryce Young in it. 

I still got some beers left it going to get worse once we put that Texans game on.

 

[Joe Bear]

2 hours ago, electro's horse said:

lofty goals for dave

Won't happen this year but maybe next.

Edited September 16, 2024 by Joe Bear

[GoobyPls]

2 hours ago, JawnyBlaze said:

No, he really wasn’t. No matter what some stupid cherry picked graphic would lead you to believe. His accuracy was atrocious last year too. 

Nope, everyone who studied tape would tell you. But let me guess they are homers too 

[Shotgun]

2 hours ago, electro's horse said:

reich benched bryce which is more than we're going to be able to say about canales 

And won twice with Young. Reich deserves an award for that. I'm not sure Canales can get a win with Young playing. 

[hepcat]

5 hours ago, bandu said:

i honestly think Reich would still be coaching the Panthers today if we had drafted CJ Stroud

 

 

I think that’s a pretty safe assumption

[Day1PanthersFan]

I was heavily against the Riech hire, I wanted a proven winner like Payton, or a proven leader like Wilks 

But it didn't matter who we hired , Tepper The Clown was going to undermine them and micro manage, and just was hiring a fall guy 

 Bryce Young is a coach killer, a bad player propped up by ownership, it didn't matter if we hired Andy Reid , even he would go 0-10 with Bryce

I hope Frank decides to come back into coaching with a legitimate owner and an NFL QB, I wouldn't want the end of my legacy to be David Tepper and Bryce Young.

Edited September 16, 2024 by Day1PanthersFan

[JawnyBlaze]

30 minutes ago, GoobyPls said:

Nope, everyone who studied tape would tell you. But let me guess they are homers too 

Ok, he just all of a sudden became the most inaccurate QB ever. Whatever you say buddy. 

[strato]

36 minutes ago, GoobyPls said:

Nope, everyone who studied tape would tell you. But let me guess they are homers too 

Get yourself some tape of his Pro Day and extrapolate that. 

[GoobyPls]

16 minutes ago, JawnyBlaze said:

Ok, he just all of a sudden became the most inaccurate QB ever. Whatever you say buddy. 

That’s exactly what happen, his confidence is dead.  

[fanpanther]

13 hours ago, GoobyPls said:

That’s exactly what happen, his confidence is dead.  

The biggest stat I see people quote on young from college is his horrific downfield accuracy in college like 20or 30% for anything over 20 yards I cant remember exact stat but that is one I believe pretty much sums up his nfl career combined with terrible arm strength not so much his size to me just that even on his quick passes the ball gets there slow allowing defenders time to tackle quickly.  He just is not an nfl qb and it is amazing nfl evaluators had him as a number one overall pick but at this point nothing to do but hope the panthers draft better this year.