QB 2026 (For the Young Haters)

[electro's horse]

1 minute ago, cmichd08 said:

well we better not win any more game this year, but I doubt we get a QB who will dislodge Young till his 5th year is up. He has given Tepper enough hope to keep him there unless we find a Dart like NY Giants did in last years draft.

we could have had daniel jones this year for nothing. Honestly he'd fuging eat in this offense. 

And he's not given tepper anything to be hopeful enough. That's a stupid thing to say. And yet, I can't say for sure you're wrong. 

[Paa Langfart]

We need to get a vet from some body.  Let Canales pick 2 or 3 guys he likes,  then let Dan Morgan go to work .

[Khaki Lackey]

1 minute ago, cmichd08 said:

well we better not win any more game this year, but I doubt we get a QB who will dislodge Young till his 5th year is up. He has given Tepper enough hope to keep him there unless we find a Dart like NY Giants did in last years draft.

No, I'm sure our FO brain trust is going to keep Bryce around. They have too much invested to outright admit failure. But a competent vet backup, or draft pick, will probably have opportunities to take over the starting job in the next two seasons.

[electro's horse]

1 minute ago, Paa Langfart said:

We need to get a vet from some body.  Let Canales pick 2 or 3 guys he likes,  then let Dan Morgan go to work .

Canales has never once picked a qb.

I cannot imagine looking at his work since getting to carolina and thinking he needs to be allowed to make that decision

[Paa Langfart]

1 minute ago, electro's horse said:

I cannot imagine looking at his work since getting to carolina and thinking he needs to be allowed to make that decision

So who in the Panthers organization would be better qualified  ?

[electro's horse]

1 minute ago, Paa Langfart said:

So who in the Panthers organization would be better qualified  ?

Best performing coach right now is Evero. 

[Jon Snow]

31 minutes ago, CPF4LIFE said:

Who tf can give you a better option for next year in the middle of the current season?? Be forreal.

This^. 

[cranky]

10 minutes ago, csx said:

Everyone is like 3 Tar Heel fans.

I didn't say anything about him being a Tar Heel guy. Just that he's a local guy.

[jfra78]

Get a vet, sit Bryce behind him, draft a QB in 2027, have him sit behind the vet to begin the season

[Jon Snow]

24 minutes ago, woahfraze said:

Bryce hasn’t played well enough to justify that sort of extension. If the organization wants to roll with him at QB moving forward, any extension they offer should be commensurate with his play. For “passable” QB play (however you want to define that…I use the term generally to mean that he’s a game manager that you can win with if you build the rest of the team right but that he’s going to limit your ceiling and potentially lose you some games here and there; I do not think he‘s “the guy.”), the going rate is going to be a lot lower. Something more in the 3 years 45 million range. And if Young thinks he can get more elsewhere, then he’s free to try to do so. 
 

Whether that would be an OK decision depends entirely on the answer to the premise of this thread. Do you think you can meaningfully improve on Young? If the answer is no, whether yet be due to lack of attractive options in the draft or free agency and no one willing to trade a good QB for a decent price, then I don’t have a problem with rolling with Bryce (sans 5th year extension and/or with a reasonable contract) and taking some late in the draft flyers and exploring worse options (but better than Dalton) in free agency.  Paying less for a QB does allow for the flexibility to build strength elsewhere on the roster, and then you hope you can upgrade from Bryce later. 

[Paa Langfart]

7 minutes ago, electro's horse said:

Best performing coach right now is Evero. 

You still hungover bro ?  You want the DC to pick the quarterback ?

[electro's horse]

The panthers need a guy with a big arm. A guy who has overcome adversity. A guy who’s played his best in the biggest stage in college football. A guy who makes huge game changing throws and can put the team on his back. They need a guy with moxie. 

They need a qb with a coke problem to balance out an evangelical coach. 

most importantly they need a goddamn dawg. 

Thats right baby. The panthers need Stetson Bennett. 

 

[csx]

3 minutes ago, cranky said:

I didn't say anything about him being a Tar Heel guy. Just that he's a local guy.

Im saying its Tar Heel fans who would do that.

I root for all Panthers to succeed regardless but college affiliation means zero to me

[LinvilleGorge]

28 minutes ago, cmichd08 said:

don't disagree but they took a chance on Allen, and Allen worked to become the talent he is today. No Young is not Allen and never will be, but he is better than Dalton and we can design plays, so Young has better vision on who he is throwing to. DC has made Young a better QB in just the last year and half. Next year he will be better. Great no. Better yes.

He's better than the current version of Dalton who should be out of the league. I don't see that Bryce is "better". We've just gotten better at hiding Bryce behind a great RB and a suddenly shockingly dominant defense. He hasn't gotten better, we just don't have to ask much out of him and can lean on the rest of the roster. I honestly think he's about at his ceiling. He's just very physically limited.