Off-season bore topic- Excluding the 1st overall pick, would you trade Tmac for any other first round pick??

[Basbear]

If so, which pick breaks you from Tmac?

Or even the 2nd overall pick << Tmac...

What say thee??

[mccjeff]

Short answer: No!

Long answer: Noooooooooooooooo!

[strato]

He seems to be a home run at 8, tough to find anyone I would definitely swap him for. 1st, I haven’t watched the other players much at all, and watched Tet for the whole season here. 
 

I still think we need a QB though. If this were a realistic scenario I would sure be watching a lot of video of Cam Ward. 

Edited 3 hours ago by strato

[Basbear]

2 hours ago, mccjeff said:

Short answer: No!

Long answer: Noooooooooooooooo!

KC calls and offers this years 9th and a future 1st, what say thee???

[Basbear]

48 minutes ago, strato said:

He seems to be a home run at 8, tough to find anyone I would definitely swap him for. 1st, I haven’t watched the other players much at all, and watched Tet for the whole season here. 
 

I still think we need a QB though. If this were a realistic scenario I would sure be watching a lot of video of Cam Ward. 

 

I mean the 2nd overall seems to be locked into David Bailey, the best edge..... For me to turn that down......does take a Tmac player. 

I just stole this form bill Simmons and his Wenby for the top two picks, or three or four......He said Wenby on each since he's on the god path. He did say the first five >Wenby, but NBA is different...

Tmac for _______ I dare ask @tukafan21 his least willing trade package....

Just off-season filler, mock stuff need to happen NOW!!...

[frankw]

You guys realize that the Panthers in their earlier years didn't draft a first round WR for 16 years straight right?

I'm just happy to have another legit young WR on the roster after trading away the only other good one that we drafted in the first round in the last 26 years before that.

Edited 2 hours ago by frankw

[strato]

14 minutes ago, Basbear said:

 

I mean the 2nd overall seems to be locked into David Bailey, the best edge..... For me to turn that down......does take a Tmac player. 

I just stole this form bill Simmons and his Wenby for the top two picks, or three or four......He said Wenby on each since he's on the god path. He did say the first five >Wenby, but NBA is different...

Tmac for _______ I dare ask @tukafan21 his least willing trade package....

Just off-season filler, mock stuff need to happen NOW!!...

I think I misunderstood and interpreted it as basically a redraft of 2025.
There might be a couple of guys talent wise this year, but we now know Tet as a proven commodity at a blue chip position that is commanding huge salaries.  

Edited 2 hours ago by strato

[Basbear]

7 minutes ago, strato said:

I think I misunderstood and interpreted it as basically a redraft of 2025.
There might be a couple of guys talent wise this year, but we now know Tet as a proven commodity at a blue chip position that is commanding huge salaries.  

I always do a poor job about being thorough.

The topic is would you trade Tmac for ANY of the 2026 first round picks.(minus the 1st overall).

Like Jets call and offer 2nd overall for Tmac, yes or no?

Or if giants called and offered the 5th overall pick?

Personally I would turn it down, but its not a clear "yes".... I have some long pause at 2nd overall.....And I would for fernando, but that's not the question...

Just trying to freshen up the huddle some.....

[strato]

5 minutes ago, Basbear said:

I always do a poor job about being thorough.

The topic is would you trade Tmac for ANY of the 2026 first round picks.(minus the 1st overall).

Like Jets call and offer 2nd overall for Tmac, yes or no?

Or if giants called and offered the 5th overall pick?

Personally I would turn it down, but its not a clear "yes".... I have some long pause at 2nd overall.....And I would for fernando, but that's not the question...

Just trying to freshen up the huddle some.....

Yeah I corrected myself.  I think the conservative bird in the hand strategy works for me. The WRs getting 40 mil contracts is a big influence on that. We have a proven guy, just leave it be.  
 

My answer on the part I misunderstood was about the same - only if QB is in play.  Which Cam Ward is what he is, I rate Mendoza above him. And Bryce. 

[Basbear]

34 minutes ago, strato said:

Yeah I corrected myself.  I think the conservative bird in the hand strategy works for me. The WRs getting 40 mil contracts is a big influence on that. We have a proven guy, just leave it be.  
 

My answer on the part I misunderstood was about the same - only if QB is in play.  Which Cam Ward is what he is, I rate Mendoza above him. And Bryce. 

That JSN 42.5 did reset the league, and it made it "ok" to pull the matt millen...

 

FYI JSN was 20th overall pick......insane to think about that now and man that 19th pick.......hope is at a high with that and FA....