Grade our 2013 draft

[Carl Spackler]

What say ye?

[thunderraiden]

We went full Marty Hurney after the 2nd round, so I have to give it a B- despite our first round being an A+

[CharlottePanther]

If not for Star falling into our laps I would say a D or C-. Getting Star id say a C

[chknwing]

u cant grade this draft for atleast a year

[Manos]

All in all a solid draft, would have liked someone other than Barner but the rest of the picks were good.

[Kevin Greene]

uhhmm, hello

[carpanfan96]

Solid B+ - A draft. They got depth and ST help in the 4th and 6th, Kugbila can be a starter in a year or two. Klein is going to help on special teams from the start and is good depth at OLB and ILB, also adds versatility to the LB core as he can play all three spots. Barner in the 6th is a scat back/change of pace guy that's surprisingly strong for being small, he's got quick feet and good hands. He's an air back, that can give you an extra dimension to your offense.

[carolina-chuck]

Overall: A-

(1) Star Lotulelei : A+

(2) Kawann Short : A-

(4) Edmund Kugbila D

(5) A.J. Klein C+

(6) Kenjon Barner B+

It doesn't take all draftees to boom in order to have a A+ draft. We just need to boom with the high picks. The 2011 draft is disgusting but it's still an A grade draft bc we landed Cam.

[Carl Spackler]

uhhmm, hello

[Carl Spackler]

Star A+

Short B

Kugbila D-

Klein B+

Barner B

[IamSoClutch]

Overall: A-

(1) Star Lotulelei : A+

(2) Kawann Short : A-

(4) Edmund Kugbila D

(5) A.J. Klein C+

(6) Kenjon Barner B+

It doesn't take all draftees to boom in order to have a A+ draft. We just need to boom with the high picks. The 2011 draft is disgusting but it's still an A grade draft bc we landed Cam.

Championship teams find talent in late rounds. We didnt do that we passed on talent. He got lucky with star and short

[Captroop]

Didn't address glaring need in our secondary. Still don't have Smitty's replacement. So can't go higher than a C. Was looking for C+

[Mr Mojo Risin]

B- at best and that's just from rd 1 and 2

[Ship]

I loved Star, I think Short is gonna be siqq on our d-line even though i wish we'd liked someone else enough to take them (and if you listened to his phone interview on panthers.com he is very excited to be picked by us and was hoping that he would be which is priceless for a draft pick i think), the rest of the picks all make perfect sense but i selfishly don't like them anyway. this draft was truly gettleman making us take our medicine and it blows. that's why i gave this an A-.

i think we all tend to keep the blinders on in regard to our big name vets, but TD could be done any time, Beason could never come back right and if he does he probably will be gone after this year anyway, Dwill will probably be gone after this year too. Gettleman thinks we already have the answers at WR, S, and CB. at the end of the day I'm homer enough to eat that idea up.