DRAFT POLL [UPDATE: JORDAN MATTHEWS ADDED change vote if neccessary]

[cultclassiccat]

just because im in need of a smitty fix...cooks and or everyone except kudajango

[CarolinaSock]

Benjamin reminds me of Stephen Hill from a few years ago. Physical specimen but very limited in his route running in college. A first seems a bit much for a guy that needs quite a lot of work to be able to run a full route tree.

[stirs]

Value is what you want at 28.

 

Cooks is more ready than Benjamin but Benjaimin has higher ceiling. If he gets there is another story.

 

Is Moses a guy we have with a 45-50 value like others say?  If so, pass?

 

Pryer might or might not be there, but would most likely be your best value pick.  I would catagorize their worth as follows.

 

Player      Value

 

Pryor        15-25

Cooks       20-35

Verrett       25-40

Benjamin  30-45

Moses      35-50

 

I picked Cooks by the way

[MichaelNewtonII]

Value is what you want at 28.

 

Cooks is more ready than Benjamin but Benjaimin has higher ceiling. If he gets there is another story.

 

Is Moses a guy we have with a 45-50 value like others say?  If so, pass?

 

Pryer might or might not be there, but would most likely be your best value pick.  I would catagorize their worth as follows.

 

Player      Value

 

Pryor        15-25

Cooks       20-35

Verrett       25-40

Benjamin  30-45

Moses      35-50

 

I picked Cooks by the way

 

we have more need with wr so I wouldn't take pryor over cooks or benjamin

 

[panfanman]

To me, I would draft anybody on defense in the 1st. So it would have to be either a WR or OT. There are still better sign FA OT's out there now so I'm going WR. Between Cook and Benjamin, I'm going Benjamin. Why? Because Cook has been compared to Smith so much unless he himself becomes a HOFer he will always be in Smith's shadow and anything he does will never be enough.

Give me that big body in the endzone. Give me Benjamin.

[JawnyBlaze]

If one of the big three OTs was somehow there at 28 I'd take him in a heartbeat. Since that probably won't happen I'd take Benjamin. I wouldn't be mad about Cooks, but even though he's supposedly "more pro ready" Cooks looks very comparable to Tavon Austin from last year (except Cooks is a little less explosive). Cooks doesn't look significantly "more pro ready" than Austin did and we need much more than comparable to what Austin did this past year. At the very least Benjamin would give us someone that could fight for jump balls. We can (hopefully) sign Cotchery to be the possession guy to catch underneath stuff.

I'd also take Matthews at #28 if he's available, and I'd probably take him ahead of Benjamin or Cooks. Quite possibly OBJ too.

[Semaj]

I like whoever can catch the dang ball. Lsu receiver beckham would be fine too.

Sent from my LG-LS840 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[JJman]

Why people like Benjamin over Cooks baffles me.

[Swaggasaurus]

Easily Cooks....doubt he is there though. I have a suspicion that he jumps Lee.

[Jackofalltrades]

Why people like Benjamin over Cooks baffles me.

Size and ceiling are captivating.

[CarolinaCoolin]

Benjamin reminds me of Stephen Hill from a few years ago. Physical specimen but very limited in his route running in college. A first seems a bit much for a guy that needs quite a lot of work to be able to run a full route tree.

Stephen hill had Sanchez throwing to him in the jets offense. Worlds different

[scarface]

I dont care how big Benjamin is, Cooks is a better playmaker & WR. 

[CarolinaSock]

Stephen hill had Sanchez throwing to him in the jets offense. Worlds different

 

He has 45 catches in 2 years, he was 6th in receptions on the Jets last year. They aren't exactly stacked at WR. Lafell had 38 in one year with Clausen and Moore at QB. 

[CarolinaCoolin]

He has 45 catches in 2 years, he was 6th in receptions on the Jets last year. They aren't exactly stacked at WR. Lafell had 38 in one year with Clausen and Moore at QB.

Again. The jets offense